Live data from Hacker News

Oracle is underwater on its $300B OpenAI deal

ft.com

121–130 of 194 posts

Re: Oracle is underwater on its $300B OpenAI deal

#121

I seem to recall Musk saying something about OpenAI being over-valued/under-funded earlier this year. Of course he was summarily booed off the stage by the startup crowd.

Elon Musk is suing OpenAI over the for-profit conversion so that clouds his judgement.

Re: Oracle is underwater on its $300B OpenAI deal

#122
post #111

Oracle has no IP in this deal. All they are doing is unpacking Nvidia servers, plugging it in, and keeping them cool. They get 15% markup for this.

The market is pricing in significant counterparty risk. It's possible Oracle does the buying, unpacking, and cooling of Nvidia servers and doesn't get paid.

> It's possible Oracle does the buying, unpacking, and cooling of Nvidia servers and doesn't get paid.

The beauty of being a cloud infra provider is you're selling shovels. OpenAI going bust? Doesn't matter too much for Oracle, there will always be someone willing to pay them for GPU compute capacity.

Even if the hype behind AI dies down, which I hope it does rather sooner than later, the fundamental aspects aren't vaporware like with the cryptocurrency craze - AI, even the relatively lackluster state we have today, has a ton of very useful usage cases that are actually working in the field.

Re: Oracle is underwater on its $300B OpenAI deal

#123

This slide from their investor preso is bonkers. $10B revenue today, but we promise we'll get to $166B in revenue in 5 years, by the simple expedient of growing 75% every year for five years! https://d9j0pm70mrv84f.archive.is/Qdf2n/baa236e2a4d94d45fe93...

Feels a bit like Elons 1tn deal

Re: Oracle is underwater on its $300B OpenAI deal

#124
post #45

The market (over)reacted to the OpenAi announcement sending Oracle’s share price up and now may be overreacting to Altman’s interview with an investor pushing their stock price down. And we are measuring (what seems like) a non-binding investment against market cap which swings everyday.

The market is priced for perfection. Delivery is underwhelming. I think the audacity and hijinks of Altman, Musk, the Trump whack pack, Theil, etc in this zero regulatory environment is starting to wear thin on Wall St. The honest players like NVidia, Micron, Microsoft, Meta and Google who are shipping product or making money with this tech. IMO there’s a non-zero probability that OpenAI and the “Elon cinematic unive…

Why do people say “non-zero probability” instead of “chance” or “possibility”?

Re: Oracle is underwater on its $300B OpenAI deal

#125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

booing is also covered by free speech.

I might be misunderstanding what booing means then. My understanding is covering another person's voice with shouts in order to sabotage his speech. It might indeed be part of what some society might define free speech, but I'd consider it more of a coward form of violence. If with "booing" you mean "disrespect whatever good idea a person has because it also has very bad ideas", then I wonder who we will end up respe…

> but I'd consider it more of a coward form of violence.

Booing being a form of violence is the hottest take i’ve seen this week.

Re: Oracle is underwater on its $300B OpenAI deal

#126
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Finally, been waiting for this moment since I've learned about Oracle. Would be well-deserved for them. Hope Larry Ellison loses his yacht.

[flagged]

Please stop. This kind of rage-posting is not what HN is for. It's fine to think whatever you want about Mr Ellison or any other tech luminaries, and criticize them for whatever you like. But commenting in this style does nothing to harm Ellison, whilst making HN a dismal place for your fellow community members who do actually read what you post.

Re: Oracle is underwater on its $300B OpenAI deal

#127
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The market is pricing in significant counterparty risk. It's possible Oracle does the buying, unpacking, and cooling of Nvidia servers and doesn't get paid.

> It's possible Oracle does the buying, unpacking, and cooling of Nvidia servers and doesn't get paid. The beauty of being a cloud infra provider is you're selling shovels. OpenAI going bust? Doesn't matter too much for Oracle, there will always be someone willing to pay them for GPU compute capacity. Even if the hype behind AI dies down, which I hope it does rather sooner than later, the fundamental aspects aren't v…

We’re talking about building 10x existing datacenter capacity to support you based ai workloads. There will be no other buyer if OpenAI goes bust.

Re: Oracle is underwater on its $300B OpenAI deal

#128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It would be an Adam Neumann moment. There’s no way OAI can IPO with its current financials.

Isn't it the whole point of current AI environment? "We can't, we shouldn't, yet we did and look at our stock". I won't bet anything at it but the whole thing, the whole AI economy looks like a big YOLO, so taking another step further into this insanity is, well, just another step. Who knows, maybe next day Beff Jezos will IPO newly established company and somehow pull 1T IPO in 10 days of company existence. Wouldn't…

AFAIC, the correct take on the situation is thus:

https://files.catbox.moe/ufn8qa.png

And if even these guys can see it, we're screwed.

Re: Oracle is underwater on its $300B OpenAI deal

#129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

booing is also covered by free speech.

I might be misunderstanding what booing means then. My understanding is covering another person's voice with shouts in order to sabotage his speech. It might indeed be part of what some society might define free speech, but I'd consider it more of a coward form of violence. If with "booing" you mean "disrespect whatever good idea a person has because it also has very bad ideas", then I wonder who we will end up respe…

That is exactly what booing is, but citizens are allowed to boo. I can boo you, you can boo me. If you are booing me then I can walk away, and likewise you can walk away from me. If I'm booing you during a public performance that is indeed rude but then I need to be thrown out by security, which is perfectly allowed and expected.

Citizens, i.e each other, are not the problem when it comes to free speech, ever. The only entity which needs to be defended against is the entity that has a monopoly on violence, which is of course the government.

Re: Oracle is underwater on its $300B OpenAI deal

#130
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The market is pricing in significant counterparty risk. It's possible Oracle does the buying, unpacking, and cooling of Nvidia servers and doesn't get paid.

> It's possible Oracle does the buying, unpacking, and cooling of Nvidia servers and doesn't get paid. The beauty of being a cloud infra provider is you're selling shovels. OpenAI going bust? Doesn't matter too much for Oracle, there will always be someone willing to pay them for GPU compute capacity. Even if the hype behind AI dies down, which I hope it does rather sooner than later, the fundamental aspects aren't v…

> AI, even the relatively lackluster state we have today, has a ton of very useful usage cases that are actually working in the field.

Useful use cases at what price? It's totally possible that after VC money dries up the price increases far beyond what customers (both business and consumer) have been paying, resulting in demand destruction rendering the investment a net negative for Oracle.

Post reply on HN