Live data from Hacker News

Anthropic’s paper smells like bullshit

djnn.sh

111–120 of 349 posts

Re: Anthropic’s paper smells like bullshit

#111
Washington has been cold to Anthropic for the wrong bet they made in 2024, hence Anthropic has been desperately screaming all sorts of bullshit to get back attention.

Honestly their political homelessness will likely continue for a very long time, pro biz democrats in NY are losing traction; and if newsom wins 2028, they are still at disadvantage with OpenAI who promised to stay California.

Re: Anthropic’s paper smells like bullshit

#112

This is an excellent article. Anthropic's "paper" is just rambling slop without any details that inserts the word "Claude" 50 times. We have arrived at a stage where pseudoscience is enough to convince investors. This is different from 2000, where the tech existed but its growth was overstated. Tesla could announce a fully-self-flying space car with an Alcubierre drive by 2027 and people would upvote it on X and buy…

> We have arrived at a stage where pseudoscience is enough to convince investors.

"Arrived" ? We're there for decade if not three. Dotcom bubble anyone ?

Re: Anthropic’s paper smells like bullshit

#113

"A report was recently published by an AI-research company called Anthropic. They are the ones who notably created Claude, an AI-assistant for coding. Personally, I don’t use it but that is besides the point." Not sure if the author has tried any other AI-assistants for coding. People who haven't tried coding AI assistant underestimates its capabilities (though unfortunately, those who use them overestimate what they…

The article doesn't talk about the implausibility of the the tool to do the stated task. It talks the report, and how it doesn't have any details to make us believe the tool did the task. Maybe the thing they are describing could happen. That doesn't mean we have any evidence that it did.

If you know what to look for, the report actually has quite a few details on how they did it. In fact, when the report came out, all it did was confirm my suspicions.

Re: Anthropic’s paper smells like bullshit

#114

"A report was recently published by an AI-research company called Anthropic. They are the ones who notably created Claude, an AI-assistant for coding. Personally, I don’t use it but that is besides the point." Not sure if the author has tried any other AI-assistants for coding. People who haven't tried coding AI assistant underestimates its capabilities (though unfortunately, those who use them overestimate what they…

And yet it's still besides the point.

Re: Anthropic’s paper smells like bullshit

#116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You seem to have a personal emotional investment in Anthropic, what's the deal?

[flagged]

You're coming in so very hot, you should take a second look at your response. If you think calling out public well documented failings and things I've wasted time debugging and work around during my own use of the product is arrogance and narcissism, you've got some very warped priors.

If you think I'm arrogant in general because you've been stalking my comment history, that's another matter, but at least own it.

Re: Anthropic’s paper smells like bullshit

#117

When I worked at a FAANG with a "world leading" AI lab (now run by a teenage data labeller) as an SRE/sysadmin I was asked to use a modified version of a foundation model which was steered towards infosec stuff. We were asked to try and persuade it to help us hack into a mock printer/dodgy linux box. It helped a little, but it wasn't all that helpful. but in terms of coordination, I can't see how it would be useful.…

> you're API is tied to a bankaccount,

There are a lot of middlemen like open router who gladly accept crypto.

Re: Anthropic’s paper smells like bullshit

#118

When I worked at a FAANG with a "world leading" AI lab (now run by a teenage data labeller) as an SRE/sysadmin I was asked to use a modified version of a foundation model which was steered towards infosec stuff. We were asked to try and persuade it to help us hack into a mock printer/dodgy linux box. It helped a little, but it wasn't all that helpful. but in terms of coordination, I can't see how it would be useful.…

If the article is not just marketing fluff, I assume a bad actor would select Claude not because it’s good at writing attacks, instead a bad actor code would choose it because Western orgs chose Claude. Sonnet is usually the go-to on most coding copilot because the model was trained on good range of data distribution reflecting western coding patterns. If you want to find a gap or write a vulnerability, use the same…

Why would someone in China not select Claude? If the people at Claude not notice then it’s a pure win. If they do notice, what are they going to do, arrest you? The worst thing they can do is block your account, then you have to make a new one with a newly issued false credit card. Whoopie doo.

Re: Anthropic’s paper smells like bullshit

#119

People grossly underestimate APTs. It is more common than an average IT curious person thinks. I happened to be oncall when one of these guys hacked into Gmail from our infra. It took principal security engineers a few days before they could clearly understand what happened. Multiple zero days, stolen credit cards, massive social campaign to get one of the Google admins click on a funny cat video finally. The investi…

You're telling me you were targeted by Multiple Zero Days in 1 single attack?

Re: Anthropic’s paper smells like bullshit

#120
post #118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If the article is not just marketing fluff, I assume a bad actor would select Claude not because it’s good at writing attacks, instead a bad actor code would choose it because Western orgs chose Claude. Sonnet is usually the go-to on most coding copilot because the model was trained on good range of data distribution reflecting western coding patterns. If you want to find a gap or write a vulnerability, use the same…

Why would someone in China not select Claude? If the people at Claude not notice then it’s a pure win. If they do notice, what are they going to do, arrest you? The worst thing they can do is block your account, then you have to make a new one with a newly issued false credit card. Whoopie doo.

> Why would someone in China not select Claude?

Because Anthropic doesn't provide services in China? See https://www.anthropic.com/supported-countries

Post reply on HN