Live data from Hacker News

Windhawk Windows classic theme mod for Windows 11

windhawk.net

41–50 of 144 posts

Re: Windhawk Windows classic theme mod for Windows 11

#41
post #15
post #12

This is so neat looking. Is there an equivalent for MacOS?

Not exactly afaik, but I've recently been going to System Settings > Accessibility > Display, and turning on: Increase contrast Reduce transparency Differentiate without color Show toolbar button shapes https://imgur.com/a/DqfN07k I like the retro and simple vibe compared to the new Liquid Glass controls.

Ah! Thank you! Even on Sequoia this is a massive improvement!

Re: Windhawk Windows classic theme mod for Windows 11

#42
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not exactly alt-tab but it’s a ui-less immediate switcher (snappy af, zero latency) to switch between windows of the same app with alt-backtick (next to escape), originally a macOS feature: https://neosmart.net/EasySwitch/ (Backwards navigation with alt-shift-backtick)

Thank you. Actually the registry entry on 24H2 behaves somewhat similarly: alt-tab still switches windows (of all apps) but the UI is just gone (which is a problem for me because knowing how much time I need to press tab in advance leads to faster switching than "press tab, see if the focused window is what I wanted, and press tab again if it's not" which involves a computer-brain round trip every key press).

Interesting thanks for sharing. I can see how that makes sense for switching apps but imho for switching windows of the same app that benefit is negated since the thumbnail (without intense scrutiny) is generally too similar between windows of the same app.

(As a dev, I often have a dozen browser windows and a dozen or more terminals open, half a dozen IDEs, etc so being able to switch directly between instances if the same app, esp automatically filtering out minimized ones, is much faster than alt-tabbing through then all interleaved, and was my motivation for writing this.)

Re: Windhawk Windows classic theme mod for Windows 11

#43
post #14

I wish there was a "power user" mode in Windows that you could activate and you'd get the ability to have classic themes (my MS themselves), classic Control Panel, no constant nudging, no weather/Xbox/Solitaire apps, etc...

They tried that during the Chicago development and discarded the idea due to multiple problems with how humans work. Two different UIs meant that you had to learn them separately, you didn't have a slow ramp from one to the other, one familiar with one could get stuck on the other with no knowledge of how to get back, divided efforts between the two, etc. Not quite what you are asking for, but closer to Win95 shippin…

And yet they seem to have lost all that knowledge from Win8 onwards. WinForms, WPF, UWP, WinUI, MAUI... All of these with their own metaphores, design language, and they all feel half-baked, full of bugs.

Re: Windhawk Windows classic theme mod for Windows 11

#45
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've come across Windhawk before but the mods being just C++ programs seemed a little suspicious to me, how do you make sure the mods dont include malware?

Windhawk mods are distributed as source code and WH itself compiles it. It works the same way usescripts work with tampermonkey/violentmonkey on browsers. If a mod includes malware it'll be very obvious as mods are usually small.

Top tier malware can be incredibly terse and sophisticated. The trigger line to execute the xz exploit was a `.` in a build script. You are probably fine do to sheer obscurity - nerds who yearn for a Win9X experience are low in number and might only be running it for a laugh in a VM.

Re: Windhawk Windows classic theme mod for Windows 11

#46
post #25

It's incredible the effort Windows 10/11 users will go to in order to reach a somewhat functional and reliable computing experience via third party modifications, yet Linux is somehow too much effort. Just look at the instructions on that page..

Some of us still rely on Windows applications that either don’t run on Linux, can’t run under Wine, or don’t have alternatives that meet our needs.

Re: Windhawk Windows classic theme mod for Windows 11

#47

Can't speak for this product but disabling a lot of the animations, gradients, shadows & visual effects has made Windows 11 run significantly better on the computers I have it on. They didn't seem to add much value anyways. I'm a fan of a lot of the user experience improvements being made in Windows over the last decade, such as Terminal, running Linux, Power Toys features, screenshots & recording, Paint finally gett…

The Win11 screenshot tool is a travesty. It now takes multiple seconds to initialize, plus additional delay in actually selecting what you want to capture. The previous iteration was instantaneous. I have lost many opportunities to screenshot something from a screen share because of this trash performance.

Re: Windhawk Windows classic theme mod for Windows 11

#48
post #25

It's incredible the effort Windows 10/11 users will go to in order to reach a somewhat functional and reliable computing experience via third party modifications, yet Linux is somehow too much effort. Just look at the instructions on that page..

Every techie knows about Linux by now. Not everyone chooses to use Windows because they're foolish or don't know any better

Re: Windhawk Windows classic theme mod for Windows 11

#49
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not exactly afaik, but I've recently been going to System Settings > Accessibility > Display, and turning on: Increase contrast Reduce transparency Differentiate without color Show toolbar button shapes https://imgur.com/a/DqfN07k I like the retro and simple vibe compared to the new Liquid Glass controls.

Ah! Thank you! Even on Sequoia this is a massive improvement!

Great, glad to help. FYI there are similar settings for iOS and I do same on my phone.

Re: Windhawk Windows classic theme mod for Windows 11

#50

Can't speak for this product but disabling a lot of the animations, gradients, shadows & visual effects has made Windows 11 run significantly better on the computers I have it on. They didn't seem to add much value anyways. I'm a fan of a lot of the user experience improvements being made in Windows over the last decade, such as Terminal, running Linux, Power Toys features, screenshots & recording, Paint finally gett…

They probably had to go to 11 (unlike Spinal Tap, Microsoft's 11 isn't awesome) because they added the TPM requirement. If a computer was Windows 10 compatible but not Windows 10 version 24Hblahblah, it would confuse the average user...

Instead they can throw away their perfectly good computer and buy the confusion as a single package! Relax, the climate can take it!

Post reply on HN