Live data from Hacker News

iPhone 5 First Weekend Sales Top Five Million

apple.com

21–30 of 115 posts

Re: iPhone 5 First Weekend Sales Top Five Million

#21
post #11

This is not a success by the expectations and hype created. Analysts projected 10Million sales and worst case scenario of 6Million sales before launch: http://articles.cnn.com/2012-09-19/tech/tech_mobile_iphone-5...

What a bunch of nonsense. This beats the iPhone 4S, their previous top performer. Not a success! Some people will do anything to throw rocks.

Re: iPhone 5 First Weekend Sales Top Five Million

#23
post #11

This is not a success by the expectations and hype created. Analysts projected 10Million sales and worst case scenario of 6Million sales before launch: http://articles.cnn.com/2012-09-19/tech/tech_mobile_iphone-5...

The very first paragraph of your linked article reads: "Pre-order response to the iPhone 5 has been massive, outstripping expectations of analysts, who were bullish on Apple's latest smartphone to begin with, and apparently of Apple itself."

How do I reconcile that with your comment here?

Re: iPhone 5 First Weekend Sales Top Five Million

#24
post #11

This is not a success by the expectations and hype created. Analysts projected 10Million sales and worst case scenario of 6Million sales before launch: http://articles.cnn.com/2012-09-19/tech/tech_mobile_iphone-5...

Sales were limited by supply at least in many places although some carriers at least had some stock in particular models. The only real way to judge the sales success is when supply matches demand

Pretty sure Apple controls this to manage the numbers, and have an out if sales don't skyrocket as is/was believed to.

Re: iPhone 5 First Weekend Sales Top Five Million

#25
post #15
post #9

Turns out people just wanted a more refined iPhone with 4G. Who would have thought? Seriously though, I remember naysayers about the iPod back when it was first released, bemoaning the interface, design, and pointing out dozens of other mp3 players with longer feature lists at better prices. Yet the iPod still won out because it offered a consistent and predictable user experience, from the purchase to the day-to-day…

I think iTunes was probably the bigger motivator for customers purchasing iPods. Before iTunes, there weren't a lot of places to legally purchase digital music, and ripping CDs was kind of cumbersome.

I don't think you remember that time period very well. The iTunes store wasn't launched until over a year AFTER the iPod!

The original iPod, chunky by today's standards was by far the smallest and easiest to use mp3 player that could carry more than a few hundred MB of data. At the time there wasn't any Windows support but I think 3rd party software became available if you had Firewire on your PC.

From Wikipedia: iPod

"The iPod line was announced by Apple on October 23, 2001, and released on November 10, 2001."

From Wikipedia: iTunes Store

"It opened on April 28, 2003, as the iTunes Music Store"

Re: iPhone 5 First Weekend Sales Top Five Million

#26
post #12

"the world’s most advanced mobile operating system" I feel this needs to be quantified. How is it more "advanced" than the latest version of Android?

It's advertising on their site. Of course it doesn't need to be "qualified" just because some evangelistic wished every site talked up their favorite products instead.

Re: iPhone 5 First Weekend Sales Top Five Million

#28
post #11

This is not a success by the expectations and hype created. Analysts projected 10Million sales and worst case scenario of 6Million sales before launch: http://articles.cnn.com/2012-09-19/tech/tech_mobile_iphone-5...

The very first paragraph of your linked article reads: "Pre-order response to the iPhone 5 has been massive, outstripping expectations of analysts, who were bullish on Apple's latest smartphone to begin with, and apparently of Apple itself." How do I reconcile that with your comment here?

The article is from 19th (Before iPhone was released) where analysts expecting sales to be 10Million during weekend and 6 Million worst case scenario.

Re: iPhone 5 First Weekend Sales Top Five Million

#29
post #9

Turns out people just wanted a more refined iPhone with 4G. Who would have thought? Seriously though, I remember naysayers about the iPod back when it was first released, bemoaning the interface, design, and pointing out dozens of other mp3 players with longer feature lists at better prices. Yet the iPod still won out because it offered a consistent and predictable user experience, from the purchase to the day-to-day…

I agree that the criticism of the iPhone 5 was overblown, but I don't think these figures are a tremendous validation of the iPhone 5, either. The simple fact is that the vast majority of people are on two year cellphone plans, and it's been two years since the iPhone 4 came out. They took the upgrade in front of them.

The iPhone 5 was good enough that people didn't want to switch to Android, but that isn't the strongest compliment out there. IMO, Apple is simply benefitting from no-one else doing anything very interesting. I'd like to think that the Windows Phone devices from Nokia and HTC will change that, but at this point it may be too late.

Re: iPhone 5 First Weekend Sales Top Five Million

#30
post #12

"the world’s most advanced mobile operating system" I feel this needs to be quantified. How is it more "advanced" than the latest version of Android?

Android O&M is a disaster is not changing anytime soon. Quibble on features out of the box if you like, but in end-to-end support the iPhone is still the hands down winner.

See http://theunderstatement.com/post/11982112928/android-orphan...

Post reply on HN