Live data from Hacker News

Replacement.ai

replacement.ai

11–20 of 725 posts

Re: Replacement.ai

#11
post #3

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/85/The_Unre...

The difference being that we knew how to manage it, so it was actual hysteria borne from ignorance

Re: Replacement.ai

#13
The dream solution for every problem that the true socialist agenda finds while implementing its political project.

Comrades, we can now automate a neo KGB and auto garbage-collect contra-revolutionaries in mass with soviet efficiency!

Re: Replacement.ai

#14
It's actually kinda noteworthy that corporations don't talk like this (yet). Masks are off lately in political discourse, where we're all in on crass flexing on the powerless, the othering, cruelty, humiliation. How long before CEOs are openly talking about workers in the same ways that certain politicians talk about ${out_group}? If you're b2b with nothing consumer-facing to boycott, may as well say what you really think in a climate where it can't hurt and might help. The worst are filled with passionate intensity, something something rough beast etc.

Re: Replacement.ai

#15
post #11
post #3

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/85/The_Unre...

The difference being that we knew how to manage it, so it was actual hysteria borne from ignorance

Another difference is that their proponents were not hyping their valuations in the hypothetical of mass unemployment.

Re: Replacement.ai

#16

I kind of get it, but at the same time...isn't "we made a machine to do something that people used to do" basically the entire history of of technology? It feels like somehow we should have figured out how to cope with the "but what about the old jobs" problem

Not really, because this time it's not machine to do something that people used to do, but a machine to do anything and everything that people used to do.

Re: Replacement.ai

#17

I kind of get it, but at the same time...isn't "we made a machine to do something that people used to do" basically the entire history of of technology? It feels like somehow we should have figured out how to cope with the "but what about the old jobs" problem

History is full of technology doing things that go beyond human possibility as well. Think of microscopes, guns, space shuttles. There has been technology that explicitly replaces human labor but that is not at all the whole story.

Re: Replacement.ai

#18

I kind of get it, but at the same time...isn't "we made a machine to do something that people used to do" basically the entire history of of technology? It feels like somehow we should have figured out how to cope with the "but what about the old jobs" problem

that is the point of Luddism! the original Luddite movement was not ipso facto opposed to progress, but rather to the societal harm caused by society-scale economic obsolescence. the entire history of technology is also powerful business interests smearing this movement as being intrinsically anti-progress, rather than directly addressing these concerns…

Re: Replacement.ai

#20

I kind of get it, but at the same time...isn't "we made a machine to do something that people used to do" basically the entire history of of technology? It feels like somehow we should have figured out how to cope with the "but what about the old jobs" problem

Yes and thanks to this we're working more and more because most of the profit goes to the top as the inequality is rising. At some point it will not be possible to put up with this.
Post reply on HN