Live data from Hacker News

When you opened a screen shot of a video in Paint, the video was playing in it

devblogs.microsoft.com

11–20 of 78 posts

Re: When you opened a screen shot of a video in Paint, the video was playing in it

#11
I had a Matrox Millenium card with a breakout box for capturing RCA, S-Video, and Cable TV; I'd watch TV on my Windows 98 SE2 computer, which was the craziest thing back then, but I always felt like the green-screen like effect was some kind of mysterious bug that I'd better not mess with, or video capture would break. Windows 98 was barely working on a good day, so it felt like the computer was in the process of failing in a graceful and useful way, so I'd better not push my luck.

Every so often you could get a glimpse of the man behind the curtain, by dragging the window quickly or the drivers stuttering, which would momentarily reveal the green color (or whatever color it was) before the video card resumed doing its thing. Switching between full screen and windowed mode probably also revealed the magic, or starting a game that attempted to grab the video hardware context. And of course sometimes other graphical content would have the exact right shade of color, and have video-displaying pixels.

Re: When you opened a screen shot of a video in Paint, the video was playing in it

#14
If you watch Twitch, you can see that all instances of the same emote in chat animate together. Then I tested this more generally in a web page, and the same thing happens - if the same gif is placed multiple times in a page, all instances of that gif will play in sync even if loaded at different times. I guess there's a similar idea in browsers then, where maybe there's only one memory representation of the gif across the page or the browser.

Re: When you opened a screen shot of a video in Paint, the video was playing in it

#15
The irony is that in 2025, this answer is now wrong again. Starting with smartphones, scanout hardware supports multiple planes/overlays again that are composited on the fly by fixed function blocks. This bypasses having to power on the GPU and wasting memory bandwidth (a large amount of power use in a smartphone). No longer involves hacks with green pixels though.

Re: When you opened a screen shot of a video in Paint, the video was playing in it

#16
Fun Fact: This same sort of thing also happened on the Classic Macintosh Quadra 840AV, when running in 8-bit (256 color) mode. Playback of realtime video capture reserved color index #243 (a very dark green in the system palette), and ANYWHERE that color was used, it would be replaced with the live video. I created some cool effects using this back in the 90s.

Re: When you opened a screen shot of a video in Paint, the video was playing in it

#17
post #15

The irony is that in 2025, this answer is now wrong again. Starting with smartphones, scanout hardware supports multiple planes/overlays again that are composited on the fly by fixed function blocks. This bypasses having to power on the GPU and wasting memory bandwidth (a large amount of power use in a smartphone). No longer involves hacks with green pixels though.

Right, because we have alpha channels now

Re: When you opened a screen shot of a video in Paint, the video was playing in it

#19
post #5

This was a nice trick to protect text from copying. For instance, student assignments. Students could still use digital camera on CRT display, but 20 years ago cameras were costly and students did not have them. And typing text from scratch was a tedious job. So online served assignments were not shared too fast.

> And typing text from scratch was a tedious job

At least by typing them the typer might learning something. :)

Re: When you opened a screen shot of a video in Paint, the video was playing in it

#20

Iirc you can also set that "green screen" as wallpaper and have video as desktop background!

Yeah, I used to have a few "live wallpaper" type videos I'd use this way. Around the time AVC-ish algorithms were democratized by DivX. IIRC the player I used had #0000A0 as its overlay color... may have even been the DivX branded player.

...This is the oldest I've ever felt, unsure of my own memories regarding something I have to consult historical records about...

Post reply on HN