Live data from Hacker News

DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia

cnbc.com

131–140 of 421 posts

Re: DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia

#131
post #90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

An example of a legal one is the UK

Unsurprisingly the UK was enabling this guy before he got too much heat. From a BBC article: "The UK government says it has frozen assets owned by his network, including 19 properties in London - one of which is worth nearly £100m ($133m)."

> the UK was enabling this guy before he got too much heat.

How does this quote indicate that the UK was enabling Zhi?

Re: DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia

#132
post #61

I had never heard of "pig butchering". > The practice is called “pig butchering” because scammers deliberately build up trust and emotionally manipulate victims over an extended period—much like fattening up a pig—before ultimately stealing as much money as possible in a final act of financial “slaughter”

It's a huge deal in China, though Europeans are starting to get targeted as well.

Re: DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia

#133
post #99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wait, hold on, I thought the promise of crypto was that: 1. The feds can't take your money. 2. Once your money's gone, it's gone. If criminals can't count on #1 holding true, and their victims can't count on #2 holding true, what is even the point of it?

They used the forbidden technique of 5€ wrench.

It's not even forbidden, anyone can use it.

Re: DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia

#134
post #115

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> 1/3 of the country's entire GDP $15 billion is a huge number to be sure, but it's unclear from the article how many years it took to acquire.

So should we praise the gang's money saving habits?

No. Just point out as others have that $15 billion vs GDP isn't a likes comparison.

Re: DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia

#135
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Had they thought $1B was enough they would have missed out on $14B.

I think the implication is they could have stayed under the radar and still have that $1B.

Chances are they still have a lot of the money scammed, just not those particular 15B.

In a way it's like with an overfunded startup: when at some point in time the music stops because even the last would-be investor realized that the business will never be profitable, the company collapses. But all those paychecks received for playing with Other People's Money don't magically return.

Re: DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia

#136
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well you could just reverse all the transactions. But they probably won't do that.

not really? presumably many people transfer via platforms like Coinbase that use a shared wallet system. You can't just "send the money back where it came from" as those wallets might not actually be controlled by the funds owner.

Coin base keeps transaction logs.

Unless this went through a mixer, Bitcoin is quite transparent.

Still easier to just transfer it all to the Treasury of course and screw the victims which is probably what will happen.

Re: DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia

#137

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Allowing them to do what? The feds are saying they already have the keys, so either they are lying, or they already had the means to get the keys. Which would be the juicy part of the story.

> they already had the means to get the keys. Yes, and the other big questions are how they even know about the existence of the bitcoin and then how they were able to demonstrate sufficient probable cause to a judge that A) the bitcoin belongs to the suspect, and B) this bitcoin is the direct proceeds of the charged crimes. Given the extremely unusual circumstances around this seizure, its unprecedented size and the…

Finding a judge who does not really understand what Bitcoin is won't be too hard. All your "evidence wasn't obtained illegally" and so on are questions impossiblec to ask without a reasonable amount of knowledge. Requirements of a judge order aren't really much of a bar to jump, hardly more than a four eyes formality.

Re: DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia

#138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The victims getting their money back would defeat the whole purpose of Bitcoin. No one knows who originally owned it. How about cash it out and trickle it down to us... or is all that just gonna magically disappear?

Surely it would be possible for victims to come forward and provide a paper trail of WhatsApp transcripts and blockchain transactions.

That's the thing with Bitcoin, all transactions are permanently stored in a public ledger.

Re: DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia

#139
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

their business is scam center that by definition is not counted by GDP anyway

That’s not necessarily true, though may be for Cambodia. GDP can include black market activities but countries differ in whether they include specific ones and how.

Does it even count in there though? Fraud isn't a normal transaction. It's the same as theft, which is simply a transfer from one person to another. An act of fraud or theft doesn't represent creation of value the way profit from legitimate transactions do for "black market" goods/services (even if the goods/services are illegal).

Re: DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia

#140
post #136
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

not really? presumably many people transfer via platforms like Coinbase that use a shared wallet system. You can't just "send the money back where it came from" as those wallets might not actually be controlled by the funds owner.

Coin base keeps transaction logs. Unless this went through a mixer, Bitcoin is quite transparent. Still easier to just transfer it all to the Treasury of course and screw the victims which is probably what will happen.

Even if the victims get their money back it would only account for 25% or so because the price of BTC has moved so far since they lost it. (I think many victims will successfully petition for their money back)
Post reply on HN