In Mexico, bloggers are disemboweled and strung up from bridges as a warning to others, by cartels. In Syria, government snipers murdered bloggers to silence them. In China, bloggers are imprisoned at hard labor. In the United States, the Federalist Papers were released anonymously in order to protect the lives of their authors. It is only the spoiled, rich and free countries who make such naive and irresponsible sta…
Wouldn't an even better question be: how do we build the kind of society where people can express their thoughts attached to their names without fear of reprisal?
Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name
141–150 of 164 posts
Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name
#142Earlier quoted context omitted.
Real names policies are questionable but debatable. Asking friends to report friends to some authority reveals utter contempt for the very personal relationships that Facebook supposedly thrives on.
Absolutely. I think that everyone who receives one of these questionnaires should select "I don't want to answer". If the majority answer that it becomes meaningless.
Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name
#143I have been on online networks of one kind or another since 1992. I am 100 percent behind the idea that people using their real names (the rule of some networks I have been on) promotes better online community and people taking more responsibility for their personal behavior in the community. That said, I do have some friends who have long established pseudonyms that have most of the good effects of real names, becau…
Non-anonymous commentary is generally skippable. Attach your name to something, and you have to be careful to the point of sterility.
Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name
#144Earlier quoted context omitted.
What is a "real" name vs. one that is not "real"? Did you mean legal name? And if so does that exclude legal aliases? What about Madonna, is that her 'real' name?
Are you called "fleitz" in real life? No? That is not your real name then. It is a pseudonym. This isn't rocket science.
What if your nickname distorts its origins further, such as "J", which easily turns into "Jay". Have we know left the realm of Real Names?
What if you prefer to go by a middle name? Or an ethnic nickname which doesn't have an obvious relationship to the original (i.e. Alexei -> Alyosha). What about the common practice of adopting a "Western" name for people who native names translate poorly into English?
Is a facebook employee qualified to judge whether you're using your real name?
Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name
#145Earlier quoted context omitted.
>so these venues get empty pleasantries from me, certainly nothing controversial in any way. Is nobody familiar with the privacy settings? Facebook has lists, G+ has circles. One for family, one for acquaintances, one for close friends, one for business. Guess who gets to see the pictures from the house party and who doesn't?
> Is nobody familiar with the privacy settings? I'm not, and neither are you unless you work there. They routinely add new settings with recklessly chosen defaults; there's no way to be confident about may be publicized while we aren't looking.
Either this makes me lucky enough that I should consider playing the lottery, or these concerns are overstated.
Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name
#146In Mexico, bloggers are disemboweled and strung up from bridges as a warning to others, by cartels. In Syria, government snipers murdered bloggers to silence them. In China, bloggers are imprisoned at hard labor. In the United States, the Federalist Papers were released anonymously in order to protect the lives of their authors. It is only the spoiled, rich and free countries who make such naive and irresponsible sta…
These are valid points. But there are myriad ways to blog anonymously. If Facebook wants to be a place where people are known by their real names, then that's their business.
Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name
#147Earlier quoted context omitted.
Now imagine a whole generation socializing under these artificial restrictions. Can you imagine how stifling being raised under an umbrella of constant surveillance by your peer group, family, future employers and advertisers would be to your personality and relationships? We're developing a society of sociopatic egotists.
We are basically under constant surveillance by our peer group and family, just not in an Orwellian sense. It's incredibly common for people to grow up afraid to say many things, having massive restrictions on some parts of their personalities due to those kinds of pressures. We see it most obviously with the single big things such as "I can't tell my religious family I'm an atheist" or "I got ostracised for dating s…
Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name
#148Earlier quoted context omitted.
What is a "real" name vs. one that is not "real"? Did you mean legal name? And if so does that exclude legal aliases? What about Madonna, is that her 'real' name?
Are you called "fleitz" in real life? No? That is not your real name then. It is a pseudonym. This isn't rocket science.
Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name
#149A lot of educators aren't allowed using their real names on social networks.
Re: Facebook Wants You To Snitch On Friends Not Using Their Real Name
#150Earlier quoted context omitted.
Great post. I am in South Korea. I could be imprisoned for the the things I have written here about Samsung and their owning family.
In Thailand you could be imprisoned if anything you say can be misconstrued as a criticism of the King. This kinds of laws that make all kinds of utterly harmless speech a very serious risk are very widespread. See also what happened to some poor guy that made a joke in Twitter about his trip to the US. People in favor of "Real Names" are the same kind of people who say "If you have nothing to hide, why do you care a…
I've heard that is also true in Memphis.