Live data from Hacker News

Why Does Amazon.com Hate Open Source?

odonnellweb.com

1–6 of 6 posts

Re: Why Does Amazon.com Hate Open Source?

#3
I don't think Amazon hates open source. You're complaining that they haven't build the same tools to support album downloads that they have on Mac and Windows, which is a fair point. But not having a "download full album" feature for Linux is very different from "hating open source".

You feel like a second-class citizen as a result of the music purchase experience on Amazon while using Linux, which is completely different from what your headline suggests. #clickbait

Re: Why Does Amazon.com Hate Open Source?

#4
Businesses do a somewhat simple cost benefit analysis. How much does X cost and how much revenue will X make us in the short and long run? Building software is not cheap in companies like Amazon. A trivial piece of software will end up costing multiple millions of dollars over the life of the product if you factor in support and maintenance and new versions.

According to Gruber, who points it out snarkily, Amazon made only $7 million last quarter. http://daringfireball.net/linked/2012/07/27/amzn-profit-corr...

So, it's a question of Linux server vs. desktop Linux, the latter of which has very less marketshare as to be a drop in the ocean of Amazon's revenues. They figure that the goodwill loss among desktop Linux users is not worth the effort to get their services working on Linux, since things like DRM for the movie streaming service is usually more tricky on Linux.

They do support Android though, so it shows that it's not about Open Source but about profitability. Many companies leveraging Open Source do not feel the need to give back more than for just that software in question, see Apple with no support for Open Source desktop at all, and wrapping the BSD stuff in heavy DRM on iOS. Tivoization is another egregious example. If companies weren't legally obligated to release some software under the GPL, they most likely won't. Google did not release their proprietary Linux kernel for the longest time(no idea if they have done it yet).

Re: Why Does Amazon.com Hate Open Source?

#5
> If I’m not getting the same service as the Windows or Mac user why am I paying the same price?

This is a silly argument. Software for smaller platforms costs more to develop per unit revenue, since there are fewer users and software development costs are essentially fixed.

The blog post author makes a comparison to iTunes, but iTunes won't let you do _anything_ on Linux. By comparison, clicking each song to download it is really not too bad.

Re: Why Does Amazon.com Hate Open Source?

#6

Businesses do a somewhat simple cost benefit analysis. How much does X cost and how much revenue will X make us in the short and long run? Building software is not cheap in companies like Amazon. A trivial piece of software will end up costing multiple millions of dollars over the life of the product if you factor in support and maintenance and new versions. According to Gruber, who points it out snarkily, Amazon mad…

cost benefit analysis -- OP should get a copy of the songs fro friends and not buy it from anywheree