Live data from Hacker News

Scientists say X has lost its professional edge and Bluesky is taking its place

psypost.org

11–20 of 357 posts

Re: Scientists say X has lost its professional edge and Bluesky is taking its place

#11
post #6

It would be nice if scientists started being just scientists again instead of activists. Hopefully being cloistered on bluesky will bring the old vibes back

What do you mean? Activism is an essential part of science but maybe I’m misunderstanding your use of “activist.”

Re: Scientists say X has lost its professional edge and Bluesky is taking its place

#12
post #6

It would be nice if scientists started being just scientists again instead of activists. Hopefully being cloistered on bluesky will bring the old vibes back

Actual quote: "Twitter, once considered the central gathering place for scientists on social media...".

Re: Scientists say X has lost its professional edge and Bluesky is taking its place

#13
post #6

It would be nice if scientists started being just scientists again instead of activists. Hopefully being cloistered on bluesky will bring the old vibes back

It’s basically impossible to make a career as a scientist these days without constantly promoting yourself and your work unfortunately. It’s very tiring and makes it difficult to focus on science. This is one of the reasons I changed careers.

Re: Scientists say X has lost its professional edge and Bluesky is taking its place

#15
post #6

It would be nice if scientists started being just scientists again instead of activists. Hopefully being cloistered on bluesky will bring the old vibes back

It’s basically impossible to make a career as a scientist these days without constantly promoting yourself and your work unfortunately. It’s very tiring and makes it difficult to focus on science. This is one of the reasons I changed careers.

I feel the same way about software, what career did you switch to?

Re: Scientists say X has lost its professional edge and Bluesky is taking its place

#17

X still appears above the fold in a special section on Google with custom previews. Eg. searching 'Anthony Albanese Bluesky' for Australia's leader has a link to X, with custom integrated previews, above the Bluesky link of the PM despite the search explicitly stating Bluesky and despite the account posting to Bluesky. It's hard for anyone to move over since the lack of engagement is rigged like this.

Btw if you set your browser default search to anything other than Google searching for people works much better. No customized bumping of X based links over other options when searching for people.

Duckduckgo and Bing put the bluesky link as #1 for the above. Seems straightforward to make the switch to me. If you haven't changed your browsers default search engine in the past 5 years now's a good time to do so. Much better results await.

Re: Scientists say X has lost its professional edge and Bluesky is taking its place

#18
post #6

It would be nice if scientists started being just scientists again instead of activists. Hopefully being cloistered on bluesky will bring the old vibes back

It’s basically impossible to make a career as a scientist these days without constantly promoting yourself and your work unfortunately. It’s very tiring and makes it difficult to focus on science. This is one of the reasons I changed careers.

That's bad, too, but true in many professions I think.

But I think what the GP means is let's do science, let's not do hot-political-topics-as-science.

Re: Scientists say X has lost its professional edge and Bluesky is taking its place

#19
post #9
post #6

It would be nice if scientists started being just scientists again instead of activists. Hopefully being cloistered on bluesky will bring the old vibes back

Scientists are allowed to have opinions outside of their work and share them.

It is 100% allowed, I just don't think it's really helpful or beneficial for them or society

Especially when they try to lean on their status as scientists in order to try and have their opinions be more influential.

The cdc for example saying it's ok to disregard their previous guidance in order to protest for black lives matter is one of these credibility damaging moments that is hard to undo.

Re: Scientists say X has lost its professional edge and Bluesky is taking its place

#20
post #6

It would be nice if scientists started being just scientists again instead of activists. Hopefully being cloistered on bluesky will bring the old vibes back

What do you mean? Activism is an essential part of science but maybe I’m misunderstanding your use of “activist.”

No, it's not. Good science requires objective thinking and evidence-based reasoning. Claims must be proven, not accepted based on authority or prima facie evidence.
Post reply on HN