Live data from Hacker News

Exploit allows for takeover of fleets of Unitree robots

spectrum.ieee.org

11–20 of 88 posts

Re: Exploit allows for takeover of fleets of Unitree robots

#11
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I, Robot is exactly why I’m concerned, but in this case it’s not a sentient AI gone rogue but any random script kiddie who can get on your wifi and send your robot commands. Or your neighbours robot. Or their own robot. We thought this might happen with DJI drones, but let’s be honest it’s way easier to do real damage with a humanoid robot that has a kitchen knife taped to its arms (especially to a sleeping victim) t…

Why not tie the kitchen knife to the drone?

(I’m an engineer, but making assumptions) I think physics kind of blocks that from working, a DJI drone doesn’t have the weight and inertia to do serious damage, and they are hella noisy. Can’t open doors. Don’t have servos to do a proper swing or stab.

Maybe theoretically possible… but I’m more scared of robots personally.

By the same logic, autonomous cars are an even better murder weapon than robots because they are very heavy and can drive through walls. Mow down tens or hundreds of people at once.

Re: Exploit allows for takeover of fleets of Unitree robots

#13
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why not tie the kitchen knife to the drone?

(I’m an engineer, but making assumptions) I think physics kind of blocks that from working, a DJI drone doesn’t have the weight and inertia to do serious damage, and they are hella noisy. Can’t open doors. Don’t have servos to do a proper swing or stab. Maybe theoretically possible… but I’m more scared of robots personally. By the same logic, autonomous cars are an even better murder weapon than robots because they a…

And yet people aren't scared of cars. Maybe we need a cautionary tale scifi movie starring Will Smith being chased by evil cars, a la Futurama's The Honking

Re: Exploit allows for takeover of fleets of Unitree robots

#14
I love* that this comes out around the same time that engineers are making fun videos of themselves beating up robots half their size and literally training the robots to develop the same sort of fight-or-flight instincts that were forcibly instilled into the engineers

* I do not in fact love it

Re: Exploit allows for takeover of fleets of Unitree robots

#15
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Haven't you ever seen I, Robot? That won't work! We're doomed!

I, Robot is exactly why I’m concerned, but in this case it’s not a sentient AI gone rogue but any random script kiddie who can get on your wifi and send your robot commands. Or your neighbours robot. Or their own robot. We thought this might happen with DJI drones, but let’s be honest it’s way easier to do real damage with a humanoid robot that has a kitchen knife taped to its arms (especially to a sleeping victim) t…

Can't such systems be made airgapped?

Re: Exploit allows for takeover of fleets of Unitree robots

#16

I love* that this comes out around the same time that engineers are making fun videos of themselves beating up robots half their size and literally training the robots to develop the same sort of fight-or-flight instincts that were forcibly instilled into the engineers * I do not in fact love it

Why are all the videos of the robots doing combat stuff? I don't need combat stuff. All I need the robot to do is fold the laundry and mop every now and then. Less combat, please!

Re: Exploit allows for takeover of fleets of Unitree robots

#17
post #6

I cannot image what if Tesla has a similar vulnerability issue, and someone took over all of its vehicles.. Or maybe someone is already able to do that, and just waiting.

Why only mention Tesla when the market for EVs is getting quite broad? How about Hyundai, VW, one of the many Stellantis brands, Lynk, BYD, XPeng, Xiaomi or any of the others?

Re: Exploit allows for takeover of fleets of Unitree robots

#18
post #6

I cannot image what if Tesla has a similar vulnerability issue, and someone took over all of its vehicles.. Or maybe someone is already able to do that, and just waiting.

Why only mention Tesla when the market for EVs is getting quite broad? How about Hyundai, VW, one of the many Stellantis brands, Lynk, BYD, XPeng, Xiaomi or any of the others?

Owning a Tesla myself, I think the mention is valid since it's the only brand I know of with a decent share of people regularly letting the car drive itself. I am not aware of any other brand being in that same situation

Re: Exploit allows for takeover of fleets of Unitree robots

#19

Given the security and privacy history of smart devices, you’d have to be a complete moron to let a human sized robot into your home.

How much of a moron do you have to be to buy direct-to-bezos listening devices that are always on and submit your conversations to the cloud? Only because you don't want to print a recipe?

There's a lot of morons.

Post reply on HN