Live data from Hacker News

Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

reddit.com

121–130 of 365 posts

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#121
This is like something right out of the show Silicon Valley. You couldn’t have scripted a more cringe-worth demo.

It’s like they mashed up the AI and metaverse into a dumpster fire of aimless tech product gobodlygook. The AI bubble can’t pop soon enough so we can all just get back to normal programming.

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mark's definitely mastered optimizing for peak cringe factor while at 1.95T valuation.

They just need an emotionless android without conscience, who does whatever is in the best interest of raking in money. They don't need technological excellence. Whether people at his company technologically succeed or fail, what matters is, that the company processes all the PII and feeds the algorithms. The rest is just for show.

they have one in the already in the CEO position

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#123

Everything is always so cringe with Facebook and Zuck. It was always doomed to fail.

It's because Zuck doesn't actually believe in anything. Zuck's values, politics, and business goals change with the wind so everything that stems from them feels empty, because it's missing the true drive. In contrast, nothing Steve Jobs said felt empty, whether we agreed or disagreed with what he was saying it was clear that he was saying it because he believed it, not because it's what he thought you wanted to hear…

CEOs (and other spokespeople) are actors paid to believe things convincingly in front of other people.

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's because Zuck doesn't actually believe in anything. Zuck's values, politics, and business goals change with the wind so everything that stems from them feels empty, because it's missing the true drive. In contrast, nothing Steve Jobs said felt empty, whether we agreed or disagreed with what he was saying it was clear that he was saying it because he believed it, not because it's what he thought you wanted to hear…

CEOs (and other spokespeople) are actors paid to believe things convincingly in front of other people.

OK, then whose job is it to make important decisions and to define (and explain) the company's strategy? Is that also the CEO?

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#125
post #60

That wasn't prerecorded, but it was rigged. They probably practiced a few times and it confused the AI. Still it's no excuse. They've dropped Apollo-program level money on this and it's still dumb as a rock. I'm endless amazed that Meta has a ~2T market cap, yet they can't build products.

It's because their main business (ads, tracking) makes infinite money so it doesn't matter what all the other parts of the business do, are, or if they work or not.

That's Google's main business too, they have infinite money plus 50% relative to meta, and they are still in the top two for AI

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#126
post #107
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> confused the AI. I will die on this hill. It isn’t AI. You can’t confuse it.

They "poisoned the context" which is clearly what they meant.

“The blue square is red.”

“The blue square is blue.”

“The blue square is green.”

The future is here.

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Despite the Reddit post's title, I don't think there's any reason to believe the AI was a recording or otherwise cheated. (Why would they record two slightly different voice lines for adding the pear?) It just really thought he'd combined the base ingredients.

That's even worse because it would mean that it wasn't the scripted recording that failed, it means the AI itself sucks and can't tell that the bowl is empty and nothing was combined. Either this was the failure of a recorded demo that was faked to hide how bad the AI is, or it accurately demonstrated that the AI itself is a failure. Either way it's not a good look.

My layperson interpretation of this particular error was that the AI model probably came up with the initial recipe response in full, but when the audio of that response was cut off because the user interrupted it, the model wasn't given any context of where it was interrupted so it didn't understand that the user hadn't heard the first part of the recipe.

I assume the responses from that point onwards didn't take the video input into account, and the model just assumes the user has completed the first step based on the conversation history. I don't know how these 'live' ai sessions things work but based on the existing openai/gemini live ai chat products it seems to me most of the time the model will immediately comment on the video when the 'live' chat starts but for the rest of the conversation it works using TTS+STT unless the user asks the AI to consider the visual input.

I guess if you have enough experience with these live AI sessions you can probably see why it's going wrong and steer it back in the right direction with more explicit instructions but that wouldn't look very slick in a developer keynote. I think in reality this feature could still be pretty useful as long as you aren't expecting it to be as smooth as talking to a real person

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#128

I have a friend who does magic shows. He sells his shows as magic and stand-up comedy. It's both live entertainment, okay, but he is the only person I've ever seen use that tagline. We went to see him perform once and everything became clear when he opened the night. "This is supposed to be a magic show," he told us. "But if my tricks fail you can laugh at it and we'll just do stand-up comedy." Zuck, for a modest and…

So, wait, is he just a shitty magician and a funny guy, or does he fail on purpose?

The AI, or this person's friend?

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#129
post #2

There is a second part that is equally bad, but with Zuck: https://old.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/1nkbqyk/...

This is like "The Office" (Original UK version with Ricky Gervais as David Brent) with $2T market cap company.
Post reply on HN