Live data from Hacker News

When Knowing Someone at Meta Is the Only Way to Break Out of "Content Jail"

eff.org

71–80 of 174 posts

Re: When Knowing Someone at Meta Is the Only Way to Break Out of "Content Jail"

#71
Another case was some fellow selling Python & Pandas educational content on FB and was completely banned from advertising because AI flagged it as promoting animal cruelty and then AI reviewed itself and said it has done nothing wrong.

Re: When Knowing Someone at Meta Is the Only Way to Break Out of "Content Jail"

#72
I feel like this is a cultural value pretty common among modern companies, where the "proper channels" is a broken system and we have to work around it. We've seen it often, where the only way someone will get support requests looked at is by commenting here, on Twitter, etc. Once a furniture company wasn't really taking action on my warranty claim until I commented about it on a promotional Facebook post.

Re: When Knowing Someone at Meta Is the Only Way to Break Out of "Content Jail"

#73
post #37

I lost my facebook account about five years ago--total outright account ban. No recourse at all. It happened to a group of about 10 people that had been administrators of a local non-profit's facebook page and who had managed groups for the organization in the past. Our non-profit was non-denominational and helped local teens with after school type programs. We never knew why our personal accounts were banned. Best w…

The internet has been like this forever. In the 90s I was banned from hotmail for having an inappropriate email address because my last name is Cummings. No recourse for some idiotic regex filter.

Hi Richard

Re: When Knowing Someone at Meta Is the Only Way to Break Out of "Content Jail"

#74

I lost my facebook account about five years ago--total outright account ban. No recourse at all. It happened to a group of about 10 people that had been administrators of a local non-profit's facebook page and who had managed groups for the organization in the past. Our non-profit was non-denominational and helped local teens with after school type programs. We never knew why our personal accounts were banned. Best w…

Buying an Oculus actually did allow me to successfully restore my wife's Facebook after it was hacked, thanks to finding probably the same thread you're referencing.

The amount of emotional capital held in various platforms is terrifying when you consider how easy it is to be locked out.

I now regularly "takeout" all of our actively used platforms and store them on physical media.

Re: When Knowing Someone at Meta Is the Only Way to Break Out of "Content Jail"

#75
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

These are not hackers but Meta employees/contractors who make money on the side by using their access to internal support tooling/channels. It's a fireable offense (it's only intended for actual friends/family) but still happens a lot.

Do you have proof of this though? Otherwise, we're just speculating it's a likely possibility.

I am a Meta employee. Don't want to disclose any inside info or dox myself but there's been other articles written about this, e.g. https://www.theverge.com/2022/11/17/23464297/meta-allegedly-...

Re: When Knowing Someone at Meta Is the Only Way to Break Out of "Content Jail"

#76
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been slowly migrating logins off of a @gmail.com email and onto an email at a domain that I own/control for this reason. It's tedious and feels a little like an overreaction (presumably the odds of this happening to individual users are pretty low). On the other hand, the thought of some faceless fraud algorithm deciding that I should no longer have access to the credentials I use to log in to my bank, investmen…

> I didn't want to actually host my own mail stack Is there a way to only host the receive portion? I'm happy to pay someone to handle all the idiocy around sending email and getting it through Google and Microsoft, but I'd really like to hold my emails myself.

If you have your own domain, you can do whatever you want (including splitting sending and receiving).

Re: When Knowing Someone at Meta Is the Only Way to Break Out of "Content Jail"

#77
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I saw these spam mails start showing up a few months ago, and I was like WOW how is google infra just letting nefarious actors use their own domain to bounce spam/fishing emails?

Amusingly Firebase auth (a Google product) has such a bad reputation with GMail that standard procedure is to bring your own mail service. Or your password-reset emails are binned.

Firebase technicians allegedly attempted to contact gmail support, but found that gmail did not have an inbound support contact and thus the firebase technicians were unable to rectify their issue.*

*This entire post is fabricated satire. Though, I would not be shocked if it were true.

Re: When Knowing Someone at Meta Is the Only Way to Break Out of "Content Jail"

#78
post #65
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh you sweet summer child, Google gives the cold shoulder to everyone , including paying customers.

Including governments (except maybe US gov? But even that is not sure).

I’ve always wondered if litigation avenues would be a viable approach, if not dangerous

Re: When Knowing Someone at Meta Is the Only Way to Break Out of "Content Jail"

#79

I lost my facebook account about five years ago--total outright account ban. No recourse at all. It happened to a group of about 10 people that had been administrators of a local non-profit's facebook page and who had managed groups for the organization in the past. Our non-profit was non-denominational and helped local teens with after school type programs. We never knew why our personal accounts were banned. Best w…

Buying an Oculus actually did allow me to successfully restore my wife's Facebook after it was hacked, thanks to finding probably the same thread you're referencing. The amount of emotional capital held in various platforms is terrifying when you consider how easy it is to be locked out. I now regularly "takeout" all of our actively used platforms and store them on physical media.

Does this still work?

Re: When Knowing Someone at Meta Is the Only Way to Break Out of "Content Jail"

#80
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been slowly migrating logins off of a @gmail.com email and onto an email at a domain that I own/control for this reason. It's tedious and feels a little like an overreaction (presumably the odds of this happening to individual users are pretty low). On the other hand, the thought of some faceless fraud algorithm deciding that I should no longer have access to the credentials I use to log in to my bank, investmen…

> I didn't want to actually host my own mail stack Is there a way to only host the receive portion? I'm happy to pay someone to handle all the idiocy around sending email and getting it through Google and Microsoft, but I'd really like to hold my emails myself.

You could use a desktop e-mail client like Thunderbird and include its data in your backups and maybe occasionally export it somewhere in a standard exchange format for e-mail folders. You can even re-upload such local data to another e-email provider if you switch.

All of that seems easier than setting up a server to keep your e-mails.

Post reply on HN