Live data from Hacker News

The lightbulb reinvented

kickstarter.com

51–60 of 138 posts

Re: The lightbulb reinvented

#51

Wouldn't it make more sense to make the actual lightswitch wi-fi controllable rather than the lightbulb?

It looks like their goal is to make the entire project "electrician-free". Replacing a light switch is still intimidating for a large number of people.

Re: The lightbulb reinvented

#52
From an efficiency/sustainability point of view, I have a basic discomfort with the idea of throwing away all the wifi/controller stuff each time you need a new bulb. I know LEDs don't run out very fast, but they do run out. This has cost implications too.

What about a setup where there are two levels of screw: the LED bulb screws into a fixture with the wifi stuff inside, which then screws into the light fixture? Then when the bulb goes out, you can just unscrew the LEDs without having to throw away all the other components.

Maybe there's something I'm missing though; I am by no means knowledgable about electronics.

Re: The lightbulb reinvented

#53

I wonder if it can be paired to multiple phones? Otherwise you'll end up with only one person who can turn the lights on or off.

They say they have mac/pc apps as well. I'd assume anyone on the local network could control the lights, probably with optional password protection?

Re: The lightbulb reinvented

#55

Wouldn't it make more sense to make the actual lightswitch wi-fi controllable rather than the lightbulb?

That would also likely undo the color adjustment features (or make them really hard to implement). I'm probably most excited about that part if it works well.

Re: The lightbulb reinvented

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I prefer 'assume makes an ass of u and me'.

I've never understood why it makes an ass out of the "me" in that context. I can only imagine scenarios in which the person doing the assuming is making an ass out of themselves, not where their assuming is making an ass out of other people.

Some people simply respond more strongly to clever wordplay (Ooh look! It's the same letters!) than to sound reasoning.

Re: The lightbulb reinvented

#57
You guys need to expose a simple API so that I can program a home server to control many lights. Navigating a different screen for each light in my house would be a pain. You're essentially recreating part of the X10 ecosystem with wifi. At this point you should just buy a bunch if x10 and reimplent the features. They've had nearly 30 years to explore how people use this stuff.

Re: The lightbulb reinvented

#58
post #29

The home automation market has been an utter disaster for decades. I hoped the "green" movement would nudge it mainstream. Not yet, and Google even killed off their home electricity monitoring projects. Here's a similar product: http://www.smarthome.com/2672-222/INSTEON-LED-Bulb/p.aspx No color change capability and requires some other stuff as part of the system, but once you start turning on lightbulbs you quickly…

Let's change it (company name in my profile). And I'm most disappointed that Google just "disappeared" Android@Home, which is exactly what this Kickstarter seems to be pitching.

Re: The lightbulb reinvented

#59
This. Is. Featurebloat.

Seriously, color changing? Dimming? Make a simple natural light bulb, a smartphone app and a wifi wall switch. Latter is far far more important than an ability to drown my kitchen in a shade of green. Keep it useful, damn it. Not a single home automation company gets this. Usability is a key to adoption.

Re: The lightbulb reinvented

#60
I like the idea of "f.lux for my house". Might improve my sleeping. This part of the project is potentially life-altering.

Lots of people in the comments are getting hung up on the "control your lights over wifi" aspect of this project, which is far less interesting. INSTEON is (AFAIK) the current best solution for home automation, and already does this pretty well: http://www.insteon.net/

It's backwards compatible with X10, uses both powerline and RF to send control signals, and each INSTEON device also functions as a repeater, so you're far less likely to run into poor signal issues that plagued X10.

Post reply on HN