Live data from Hacker News

Apple iPhone 5 US Carrier Comparison Chart

mgalligan.com

81–90 of 106 posts

Re: Apple iPhone 5 US Carrier Comparison Chart

#81
post #63

Imagine how much of an advantage it'd be to only enforce a 1 year contract. That'd be a huge differentiator, as it would allow you to upgrade your iPhone on it's yearly release. I'm sure that would cause a massive switch in carriers for Apple fans.

Or just buy it unlocked and use Straight Talk (which is AT&T).

This comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4523530 ... indicates that won't happen, as Straight-Talk won't offer NanoSims

Re: Apple iPhone 5 US Carrier Comparison Chart

#82
Americans pay a LOT for their cellular service. I mean $100/month is just absolutely insane.

Currently I pay about $17/month but if I wanted unlimited everything I could get it for $32/month.

We don't pay to receive calls or texts however so there is little need to have "unlimited" either. Even the thought that I am paying for advertisers to send me junk text messages or calls would drive me insane, if I was in the US.

The US and Canada really have it rough with mobile and internet services...

Re: Apple iPhone 5 US Carrier Comparison Chart

#83

Looks like there's no competition here - Verizon is dominant. Even when it comes to price, they're not much more expensive, and actually cheaper if you've got 3+ members on a family plan.

Looks like AT&T is still the only option for simultaneous voice+data, though, due to antenna limitations: http://arstechnica.com/apple/2012/09/still-no-simultaneous-v...

To be honest, that use case has rarely come up for me, if at all. I'd much rather have the confidence that I'll be able to make a call (something you have with Verizon, but not with AT&T).

Re: Apple iPhone 5 US Carrier Comparison Chart

#84

Looks like there's no competition here - Verizon is dominant. Even when it comes to price, they're not much more expensive, and actually cheaper if you've got 3+ members on a family plan.

Even if you use a lot of data? Seems like Sprint would be the best choice in that case.

Well, with Sprint you don't even have 4G in the vast majority of areas. So it really depends on whether you want speed or uncapped service.

Re: Apple iPhone 5 US Carrier Comparison Chart

#86
post #72

This is cool but if you could, please add prepaid? Specifically add the following? - 4th column for StraighTalk as one of the carriers - 5th column for Tmobile as one of the carriers) - Cost to buy iphone (199 normally, but full price prepaid) - Cost over the entire life of the plan See: - Tmobile: http://9to5mac.com/2012/09/10/t-mobile-unveils-its-big-plans... - StraighTalk: http://9to5mac.com/2012/07/30/review-the-…

There's no point in adding Straight Talk at this time because official word (via their Twitter) is that they do not have nano SIMs and they have no (announce-able) plans to sell nano SIMs at this time. Micro-SIMs cannot be cut down to nano-SIM dimensions and be used.

Why not? Is there a difference in the actual chip? I thought it was just a trimming of the plastic around the chip.

Re: Apple iPhone 5 US Carrier Comparison Chart

#87

Americans pay a LOT for their cellular service. I mean $100/month is just absolutely insane. Currently I pay about $17/month but if I wanted unlimited everything I could get it for $32/month. We don't pay to receive calls or texts however so there is little need to have "unlimited" either. Even the thought that I am paying for advertisers to send me junk text messages or calls would drive me insane, if I was in the U…

I was shocked at the dropped call rates. I can't recall the last time I got a dropped call, a 4.6% has to bee annoying.

Re: Apple iPhone 5 US Carrier Comparison Chart

#88

AT&T: Tethering is included (no additional cost, using your existing data pool) with the new shared data plans.

Corrected that part. Thanks.

You should also fix the cheapest unlimited plan with 4 GB is $110 not $120 with 1 GB.

Re: Apple iPhone 5 US Carrier Comparison Chart

#89
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I felt that was a disingenuous part of the chart. The author said that FaceTime only worked over cellular for AT&T when you moved to a shared data plan, but always worked on Verizon. That's technically true, but only really because Verizon won't offer customers subsidized pricing without moving to a shared data plan. From Verizon's perspective, if you pay their post-pay rates and bring your own iPhone, you're paying…

That $18.75/month buys you much more than unlimited data, if it's a truly unlocked phone.

It's a CDMA phone which by definition can't be unlocked.

Re: Apple iPhone 5 US Carrier Comparison Chart

#90

Americans pay a LOT for their cellular service. I mean $100/month is just absolutely insane. Currently I pay about $17/month but if I wanted unlimited everything I could get it for $32/month. We don't pay to receive calls or texts however so there is little need to have "unlimited" either. Even the thought that I am paying for advertisers to send me junk text messages or calls would drive me insane, if I was in the U…

Cherry-picking one number and comparing it to another country by converting the dollar amount is a ridiculous and meaningless comparison.

Looking on here:

http://shop.o2.co.uk/mobile_phone/pay_monthly/24_months/Medi...

It looks like the cost is $70/month for unlimited text/voice and 1 GB of data. That doesn't seem much cheaper at all to me.

Post reply on HN