Live data from Hacker News

Favicons in the retina age

nashape.com

31–40 of 42 posts

Re: Favicons in the retina age

#31

If there isnt already a website that lets you just upload a large image and then creates all the different sizes for you and provides the code to paste in for you then there needs to be. If it doesnt exist and people here are interested, i'll make it this weekend.

Compare http://www.favicon.cc/ for ordinary small .ico's.

Re: Favicons in the retina age

#34

Yet another article written from a mac-only user point of view. Most desktop monitors are still around 100 dpi, far from "retina" standards.

The article mentions supporting multiple favicon sizes and old browsers. Did you even read the article or was it too hard to read on your low dpi display?

Re: Favicons in the retina age

#35
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As if "the retina age" were an actual thing. How many people have them now?

You don't think screen resolutions will continue to increase? I give it a couple of years, maybe less, before the "retina" resolution is standard hardware.

I don't want to think what beastly GPU I will have to buy to run next crisis on native resolution on ~150 dpi 21" monitor.

Re: Favicons in the retina age

#36

Using SVG for favicons would be a much better approach. Otherwise we would just end up in a few years, where we are now. But SVGs are scalable and look as good when rendered as 16x16, as 64x64 as 1024x1024. Of course that won't work for photos and stuff, but you can pretty easily turn most favicons into a scalable vector graphic.

To start, vector icons don't look as good at 16x16 or 32x32 as they do at higher resolutions. Pretty much every desktop environment that supports both large and small icons (whether with a native vector format or many scaled versions of large "master" icon) features separate, hand-edited icons for the lower resolutions, and often a completely redrawn simpler icon for the lowest (usually 16x16).

The Tango Icon Theme Guidelines state this explicitly: http://tango.freedesktop.org/Tango_Icon_Theme_Guidelines\

Re: Favicons in the retina age

#37
Microsoft's icon format is remarkably flexible and backwards-compatible. It's grown from what was once a 32x32 1-bit icon format, to one which supports multiple versions of the same icon, from resolutions ranging from the tiny 16x16 to the huge 256x256, and supporting 1-bit, 16-bit, 24-bit, and now even 32-bit (alpha transparent) colour, with PNG compression.

And the great thing about it, of course, is every browser supports it. Even the Nintendo DS.

Re: Favicons in the retina age

#38

If there isnt already a website that lets you just upload a large image and then creates all the different sizes for you and provides the code to paste in for you then there needs to be. If it doesnt exist and people here are interested, i'll make it this weekend.

Clean and Lean wordpress plugin would be nice addition too, (hope I am not asking too much ;)

Re: Favicons in the retina age

#40
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't think screen resolutions will continue to increase? I give it a couple of years, maybe less, before the "retina" resolution is standard hardware.

I don't want to think what beastly GPU I will have to buy to run next crisis on native resolution on ~150 dpi 21" monitor.

That's most likely going to be a >200dpi screen, where you can simply use 2x upscaling for better performance (with no visual degradation compared to current monitors).
Post reply on HN