Live data from Hacker News

Where did the Smurfs get their hats (2018)

pipelinecomics.com

31–40 of 72 posts

Re: Where did the Smurfs get their hats (2018)

#32
post #23
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

+1 for Dirkjan, always. Another classic https://dirkjan.nl/cartoon/20231004_3677623503/ And this one always gets me too: https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=http%3A%2F%2Fw... with the "Jesmurfa's witness"

I don't get that first one :(

[deleted]

Re: Where did the Smurfs get their hats (2018)

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What, you think the article was written by AI? Why?

It's 2025, you can flip a coin and be correct half the time, and no consequences if you're wrong.

Looks like there are consequences, they’re being called out, which is good

Re: Where did the Smurfs get their hats (2018)

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Not AI. Indexed in 2020 by the wayback machine: https://web.archive.org/web/20201001000000*/https://www.pipe... Why GPT writing sounds like the median lazy blog post of five years ago is left as an exercise for the reader.

But facts? That goes against the hive mind

Re: Where did the Smurfs get their hats (2018)

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What, you think the article was written by AI? Why?

I guess because it is full of guesswork and devoid of real factual research (at least for the main headline question). But it turns out that bloggers looking for content and lacking any skill are also capable of writing plausible-sounding slop.

I wouldn’t call this article slop

Re: Where did the Smurfs get their hats (2018)

#37
post #18

Dutch catoonist Dirkjan revealed the real answer already years ago: https://www.reddit.com/r/dirkjan/s/zszexnXLRu

ChatGPT's translation:

Panel 1 Waiter: "Sir, I’d like to ask you to take off your cap in this restaurant." Smurf: "Take off my cap? You’re not asking me to take off my pants, are you?!"

Panel 2 Waiter: "That’s not the same." Smurf: "That is the same."

Panel 3 Cook (to waiter): "Let him put his cap back on." Waiter: "That’s maybe better."

Re: Where did the Smurfs get their hats (2018)

#38

This is almost certainly completely wrong, the smurfs get their hat designs from the type of hats that gnomes and dwarves and goblins usually wear in germanic folklore, the most well known of all being the garden dwarves, whose design also inspired the dwarves in snow white. The design of garden dwarves is quite recent and apparently come from miners. The hats were filled with straw to protect the miner's head from t…

But the article does cover that. German gnomes (Kobolde, especially Hödekin) are usually depicted with pointy hats, or at least ones that curl backwards. The smurf hats are clearly wearing Phrygian caps.

A quick Google image search for "garden gnome" and "gartenzwerg" shows that both types are quite common. But they originally didn't necessarily have the hats common today. These are the oldest surviving garden gnomes according to [1]:

Schloss Mirabell: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Mirabellgarten_%E7%B... (1690-1695)

Schloss Greillenstein: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Schloss_Greillenstei... (around 1700)

1: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gartenzwerg

Re: Where did the Smurfs get their hats (2018)

#39

This is almost certainly completely wrong, the smurfs get their hat designs from the type of hats that gnomes and dwarves and goblins usually wear in germanic folklore, the most well known of all being the garden dwarves, whose design also inspired the dwarves in snow white. The design of garden dwarves is quite recent and apparently come from miners. The hats were filled with straw to protect the miner's head from t…

But the article does cover that. German gnomes (Kobolde, especially Hödekin) are usually depicted with pointy hats, or at least ones that curl backwards. The smurf hats are clearly wearing Phrygian caps.

the first smurf drawings had pointy hats, the curve is most likely a stylistic evolution.

https://www.lm-magazine.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/schtr...

Post reply on HN