Live data from Hacker News

I don't want AI agents controlling my laptop

sophiebits.com

31–40 of 43 posts

Re: I don't want AI agents controlling my laptop

#31
post #6

I must be out of the loop, I didn't know people were actually doing this in their workflow. When I do use LLMs, it's in a separate app, where I can cherry pick what I input and output at my own pace. Maybe I'm naive, but the ever-increasing tradeoffs for even more velocity does not seem worth it.

Don’t worry, the only people that are doing this are creating absolute dumpster fires.

Re: I don't want AI agents controlling my laptop

#32
post #27
post #22

What about buying a dedicated machine for running agents? One macbook for agents and one for personal/private work plus a good KVM switch maybe or remote desktop.

It doesn't work that way. The dedicated machine for running agents will have very limited utility because it will not have access to anything it needs like your credit card to automatically purchase stuff on your behalf etc.

> credit card to automatically purchase stuff on your behalf

Why would anyone _want_ that?

Or, let’s pretend for a moment they did, wouldn’t it make more sense to grant access to a purchasing account (e.g. Amazon) with payment info pre-linked?

Especially given the “record absolutely everything for evidence” approach companies are taking, giving them auto access to payment info isn’t very smart.

Re: I don't want AI agents controlling my laptop

#33
>modern desktop operating systems are not really designed for strong security boundaries

I agree, I do not want AI anywhere near my Laptop. But there are Operating Systems that do not and probably never be controlled by "AI".

The quote above is curious, there are OSs with strong security. OpenBSD is touted as one, plus there is Linux and other BSDs, which can be configured to be far more secure than the operating systems the article is referring to.

Re: I don't want AI agents controlling my laptop

#34

I don’t understand the author’s complaint - are the AI agents forcibly installing themselves on your computer? Are they shipping these agents without settings to change permission seeking behavior? This is just a rant about something you absolutely don’t have to do

>Microsoft re-enables disabled abc after xyz

>Microsoft launches shitfoo; users livid they can't disable it

If I had a dollar for every time one of these headlines has scrolled across my screen.. just recently CoPilot has drawn the ire of devs who don't want it involved with their repos.

https://www.theregister.com/2025/09/05/github_copilot_compla...

If you think MS isn't interested in shoving all this down your throat on Windows at the earliest opportunity, then I dunno what to tell you. But people are allowed to have opinions on things and TFA is just that.

Re: I don't want AI agents controlling my laptop

#35

I don’t understand the author’s complaint - are the AI agents forcibly installing themselves on your computer? Are they shipping these agents without settings to change permission seeking behavior? This is just a rant about something you absolutely don’t have to do

They say during the gold rush, the people selling shovels made more money than the miners themselves. AI has a similar pattern. Those profiting from AI hype it relentlessly. Meanwhile the butthurts with nothing to sell become the loudest critics, just to stay relevant.

We get it guys. AI sucks and you don't like it. You need not turn yourself into a parrot. Nobody's in the market for your outrage.

Re: I don't want AI agents controlling my laptop

#36

I want AI agents controlling my laptop. And not only AI. There are lots of cool software programs I want on my laptop besides AI too. The problem is not AI, the problem is the awful security model that is the foundation of all modern operating systems.

What would be a better security foundation?

Re: I don't want AI agents controlling my laptop

#37
post #6

I must be out of the loop, I didn't know people were actually doing this in their workflow. When I do use LLMs, it's in a separate app, where I can cherry pick what I input and output at my own pace. Maybe I'm naive, but the ever-increasing tradeoffs for even more velocity does not seem worth it.

same. I think this is the way for most of good engineers

Re: I don't want AI agents controlling my laptop

#38

I want AI agents controlling my laptop. And not only AI. There are lots of cool software programs I want on my laptop besides AI too. The problem is not AI, the problem is the awful security model that is the foundation of all modern operating systems.

What would be a better security foundation?

qubesOS

too complicated for most people

Re: I don't want AI agents controlling my laptop

#39
post #23

It's really a question of whether you want a deterministic machine or a probabilistic one. Depends on the use case, really.

What's the use case for a probabilistically controlled computer?

Excitement and perhaps a delusional pitch to a VC?

Re: I don't want AI agents controlling my laptop

#40
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, relinquish all control because .. embracing the future.

we already have - every time you get in a car you're elevating the chance of death considerably from before you hopped in. (seriously it's like 1000000x more dangerous than just sitting on a sofa) Granted it's a low chance, but it's also similarly low that your bank account will be drained to zero because you codex --yolo'd it. If that DOES happen to someone then yeah, I'd consider changing my behavior. For example t…

I thought most people died while sleeping in their beds.
Post reply on HN