It's militaristic, it's alienating, it's fetishistic, it's hostile, it insidiously portrays class and ethnic conflict as an everyday battle worth fighting, and it panders to the worst in Americans who already endorse the myriad excesses and injustices of an ever-growing quasi-private law and order machine that has ruined the lives of millions. But awesome job on the scrollbars, yo.
I live in Melbourne Australia and I have got to say, this is the first reaction I had as well. The imagery used on their website was frankly shocking. My first response was "WTF! Is this really how Americans see their police? Is their job to charge round shooting people?" Compare and contrast the pictures used on the 'about' page of the Victoria police website: http://www.police.vic.gov.au/content.asp?Document_ID=3 W…
Milwaukee Police News
81–90 of 119 posts
Re: Milwaukee Police News
#82I think the more communication the better. Is it propoganda? Maybe, but I wouldn't work my brain into a lather about that.
Overall, I'd say it's cool. If my town had a site like this I'd read it.
Re: Milwaukee Police News
#83> WARNING: We have detected that you currently have Javascript disabled. > This website requires the use of Javascript, for the best possible viewing experience we highly recommend that you enable Javascript via your browser's options. Do I really need to elaborate here? For the record, the site works (to some extent) in Lynx. But in Firefox without Javascript, they actually took the time to make it completely useles…
Re: Milwaukee Police News
#84Re: Milwaukee Police News
#85It's militaristic, it's alienating, it's fetishistic, it's hostile, it insidiously portrays class and ethnic conflict as an everyday battle worth fighting, and it panders to the worst in Americans who already endorse the myriad excesses and injustices of an ever-growing quasi-private law and order machine that has ruined the lives of millions. But awesome job on the scrollbars, yo.
I'm also more comfortable with it as a ARG site for a fictional dystopian movie rather than a site for a real police department, which means it's obviously clearly a propaganda site, which I find disturbing and unsettling.
Re: Milwaukee Police News
#86Re: Milwaukee Police News
#87Not only was this site posted just 16 days ago,[1] but as I commented at the time, scrolling the site causes 100% usage of one of my CPU's cores. This is still the case. The fact that so many people consider sites such as this to be "awesome" is one of the many reasons I'm glad I no longer work for clients. [1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4436366
Re: Milwaukee Police News
#88Earlier quoted context omitted.
If you scroll the experience is terribly broken and scrolling is a deeply ingrained interaction paradigm for web sites. Its particularly annoying on a mac trackpad due to inertial scroll. Saying "don't scroll, use the buttons" to get a non broken experience is like saying "don't click the big red button" to avoid the server throwing a 500.
Well I personally don't find the experience terribly broken, or broken at all. I don't see why anything on that page even has to perfectly line up. I mean on Pinterest you don't expect everything to perfectly line up when infinite scrolling, and you don't really lose any information if the image doesn't line up on this page. However, I can see how it can really annoy some obsessive type personalities (who consider it…
It's time-wasting, annoying and useless.
Re: Milwaukee Police News
#89Earlier quoted context omitted.
Exactly what part of that website "portrays class and ethnic conflict"?
The part where the two actors are heavily armed police and a box of mugshots of minorities stamped MOST WANTED. Edit: Also it's worth noting that as of several weeks ago this was a much more elaborate site. It's been significantly toned down since.
Re: Milwaukee Police News
#90Earlier quoted context omitted.
Exactly what part of that website "portrays class and ethnic conflict"?
The part where the two actors are heavily armed police and a box of mugshots of minorities stamped MOST WANTED. Edit: Also it's worth noting that as of several weeks ago this was a much more elaborate site. It's been significantly toned down since.