Live data from Hacker News

Claude Code: Now in Beta in Zed

zed.dev

61–70 of 431 posts

Re: Claude Code: Now in Beta in Zed

#61
post #54

Naive question: is using Claude Code from the command line or in these tools like VSC or Zed different from using it in the native app on a desktop? Is that because it has access to your codebase?

Not tried with Zed yet, but in VS Code it's mostly the same except you can view the diffs in the editor, and can give context from the open file. I think it can also see errors from the editor.

Re: Claude Code: Now in Beta in Zed

#62
post #54

Naive question: is using Claude Code from the command line or in these tools like VSC or Zed different from using it in the native app on a desktop? Is that because it has access to your codebase?

After having troubles with Claude desktop not properly updating canvas document, I found that apparently Claude Code is same as desktop one plus you can use it not just for code but documents in VS Code.

Re: Claude Code: Now in Beta in Zed

#63

Zed used to be a good editor but it is increasingly LLM infested.

Just disable it. It seems like they've made is as simple as possible to do so while also being realistic about what it takes to make a successful (read: profitable) IDE the year 2025.

I've found that the sort of people who complain about AI or cryptocurrency don't care if it can be disabled. The mere fact that such functionality exists taints the product for them. I can't say I understand the reasons (I like AI functionality), but that's what I've noticed.

Re: Claude Code: Now in Beta in Zed

#64
post #16

Zed used to be a good editor but it is increasingly LLM infested.

I know what you mean. I used to like Emacs but then they added syntax highlighting for Rust and I don't use Rust so I'll never touch that editor ever again.

Can you believe they had the gall to even run code that allowed those vim heathens to feel comfortable in emacs? The horror /s

Re: Claude Code: Now in Beta in Zed

#65
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Top of my head switching between IntelliJ and Zed: - Git UI is extremely barebones with no support for other VCS - No merge tool or side-by-side diffs - Configuration is all JSON - Would be nice having a full file tree for the search editor instead of just the list; having the functionality split between a tab and the outline panel is quite clunky. - Ability to move panels (files/git/console/debugger/etc) into standa…

No side-by-side diff is a deal-breaker for me unfortunately.

I use git icdiff (a plugin) in my terminal. I use Zed and VSCode GUI editors, but I don’t care to use their git tools. Command line git is fine.

https://www.jefftk.com/icdiff

Re: Claude Code: Now in Beta in Zed

#66
post #54

Naive question: is using Claude Code from the command line or in these tools like VSC or Zed different from using it in the native app on a desktop? Is that because it has access to your codebase?

Not just your codebase, but also a wide range of *nix tooling. Night and day to working on the CLI vs an IDE.

Re: Claude Code: Now in Beta in Zed

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just disable it. It seems like they've made is as simple as possible to do so while also being realistic about what it takes to make a successful (read: profitable) IDE the year 2025.

Given the state of information technology in 2025 I think your parent has a good reason to believe AI features ruins everything. It is common in well funded (read VC funded) technology to start with an easy toggle to disable, and then slowly make opt-out ever harder to completely accomplish. Disable 3rd party tracking ads on google platforms used to be a simple toggle as well.

You can think that AI ruins everything, or that tracking ads ruin everything, but the reality is that VC investment ruins everything, because it turns you from the customer to the product.

I guess the eventual culprit is capitalism, where profit is the ultimate goal for everything, so there will never be a single product that is not enshittified in this way.

The best part? If you don't like it, there's nothing you can do! It's the whole culture.

Re: Claude Code: Now in Beta in Zed

#68

I am sure Zed is great and I appreciate the effort put in to create it, but nowadays I just cannot imagine switching from VSCode to something else. In my limited understanding, none of the existing alternatives offer anything (and often misses at least something) truly innovative or anything else that VSCode extension wouldn't solve. On VSCode I have about 15 different profiles setup, each with different settings and…

It's really interesting point of view. I'm one of those people who avoid using VSCode at any cost. It's slow, it's bloated, the UI is not great, and it's slowly being locked down by Microsoft.

If Zed would not exist, I would be using helix, neovim, or emacs as I did before.

Re: Claude Code: Now in Beta in Zed

#69
post #37

what i am missing by using claude cli with nvim. i don't understand why editor integration needed.

The editor treats edits from Claude Code as a first class citizen. You can easily review, approve, rollback, etc. Claude's changes in a curated experience that is much faster than digging around in diffs or needing to approve each edit as it is proposed. https://zed.dev/agentic

i open my nvim on a socket and tell calude code cli about it. my claude.md has a line "look for lsp errors when you are done editing" so it communicates with neovim on the socket and gets whatever it needs from editor.

Re: Claude Code: Now in Beta in Zed

#70
post #10

Zed is so great, I do wish they would focus just a little bit more on bringing the UI just a bit more up to parity with VS Code, I would switch full time.

What's so great about zed ?

It’s built by the team that built atom which was way better than vscode but was mothballed when Microsoft bought GitHub.

They built it from scratch and not on electron bloat so it is a much better foundation. It will take a long time to reach parity with vscode but when it does it will smoke it.

Post reply on HN