Live data from Hacker News

Google can keep its Chrome browser but will be barred from exclusive contracts

cnbc.com

191–200 of 663 posts

Re: Google can keep its Chrome browser but will be barred from exclusive contracts

#191
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So... Google's punishment is to stop paying Apple and Mozilla for default search deals?! Well I guess that'll help?! (Yes, judges can search for best market solutions)

No, the actual remedy is not yet decided in detail (though sharing some search data is going to be part of it), this ruling was basically setting some parameters of what is on and off the table and then ordering the parties to meet on details before further court action.

It basically rules out structural remedies, so what's left is pinky promises of not misbehaving again. Whatever these promises are, that closes the case for me.

Re: Google can keep its Chrome browser but will be barred from exclusive contracts

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because they have a history of abusing their monopoly on browsers to push new standards that only help them.

What are some examples of that for web standards?

FLOC/Cohorts API, AMP, Manifest V3, Widevine, WEI.

Re: Google can keep its Chrome browser but will be barred from exclusive contracts

#193
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The ease with which a total newcomer was able to steal share from Google is real-world evidence that there wasn't really a monopoly and that Google competitors (Bing, etc.) just sucked and didn't want to spend the money to be better.

Well, courts disagree with your assessment and so do I. Yes, AI is a threat to Google. How much a threat remains to be seen. From normies I know, most of them are just using Gemini or whatever is on Google front page. They are not starting most of their searches on OpenAI or other ones.

Courts also decided you couldn't bundle a web browser and then turned a blind eye when it's done on a different platform with draconian restrictions against even installing an alternate browser.

Re: Google can keep its Chrome browser but will be barred from exclusive contracts

#195
post #182

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You really think Microsoft , a company worth $3.8 trillion , doesn't have enough money to pay for placement?

Bing by itself reportedly doesn't even gross that much, overall $20 billion represents about a quarter of Microsoft's entire annual profit. Microsoft already decided it wasn't viable to spend that much to compete, and the rest of the search market (including AI) need not apply.

And how will it ever if Microsoft won’t invest in it? Microsoft has wasted billions of dollars in other verticals to open revenue streams.

Re: Google can keep its Chrome browser but will be barred from exclusive contracts

#196
post #173

I think ultimately this is a good decision. The web has flourished in part because Google has supported Chrome so well over the years since they are incentivized to do so. You don't have to use Chrome (I don't) to benefit from this second order effect.

What do you define as "flourished"? Chrome won in part because it was better than Internet Explorer, but ironically, the internet was better back when IE had majority market share.

Today, 99% of internet traffic goes to a handful of sites/apps, and the vast majority of the ad revenue on the internet goes to a handful ad companies. The internet is a SEO spam shit hole crafted in service of Google's easily gamed ranking algorithms, and designed with the sole purpose of serving ads.

Google effectively owns the internet, and this ruling is a green light for them to take even more. I wouldn't be surprised if they stop releasing Chrome sources and fully ban ad blockers now. The court already ruled that the government can't touch them, even when they've been found to have broken the law.

Re: Google can keep its Chrome browser but will be barred from exclusive contracts

#197

Thank goodness. Them spinning that out would have been a nightmare. Bad day to be Apple. Edit: I just checked the stock, I had no idea people priced in a split with that much certainty.

After hours moves can be dramatic, we'll see where it's at tomorrow w/ full volume. It's good news for sure but you can't tell me Wall Street actually thought they would be broken up or anything drastic.

> but you can't tell me Wall Street actually thought

It's not binary. "Wall Street" is a lot of people independently pricing what they think is the probability and impact.

But so yes, Wall Street was absolutely pricing in a drastic breakup to some degree. If they'd thought it was even more likely, the bump would have been even larger.

Re: Google can keep its Chrome browser but will be barred from exclusive contracts

#198
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From an outsider POV (holding Alphabet stock!): The US legal system seems quite broken.

Oh course it is, but is there another country that is any better at antitrust? I haven't seen it. And remembering that antitrust which goes too far is just as harmful as antitrust that is too weak.

Any country trying to break Google will be fighting the US gov. It doesn't matter if other nations are better or worse in comparison, only the US has the power to rule over Google.

At best the EU could push penalties on Google, but nothing more.

Re: Google can keep its Chrome browser but will be barred from exclusive contracts

#199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mean, it’s a legitimate concern. Google is bleeding so hard right now from Gen Z and especially Gen Alpha deciding to use ChatGPT first and foremost when asking questions that Google would’ve answered previously. Whether or not that means they should keep Chrome as a product is up for debate.

I'm Gen X and recently been using ChatGPT a hell of a lot more than Google, especially for queries similar to sibling comment. Instead of trying to word my query optimally for search, I just write what I'm trying to achieve in natural language and I get an answer, instead of having to scan a few results to know if they're likely candidates. Even with the made up shit on occasion this is a win.

It's the only viable option for surfacing knowledge that is nearly gone from the dead internet.

Re: Google can keep its Chrome browser but will be barred from exclusive contracts

#200
post #31

This seems like a very sensible and logical conclusion by the judge to me. An exclusive contract with Apple/Samsung isn't great, but even Apple testified that they would not have accepted any other searcch engine because everyone else was worse. You can't make restrictions on what Apple is allowed to do because Google violated some law--if Apple wants to make Google the default, they should be allowed to do so! The b…

> Apple testified that they would not have accepted any other searcch engine

"We only accept bribes from other monopolies"

Post reply on HN