Live data from Hacker News

What makes Claude Code so damn good

minusx.ai

11–20 of 322 posts

Re: What makes Claude Code so damn good

#11
post #5

What do people think of Google's Gemini (Pro?) compared to Claude for code? I really like a lot of what Google produces, but they can't seem to keep a product that they don't shut down and they can be pretty ham-fisted, both with corporate control (Chrome and corrupt practices) and censorship

According to the guys from Amp Claude Sonnet/Opus are better at tool use.

Re: What makes Claude Code so damn good

#13
post #4

[flagged]

If you want to be really stringent, RAG originally referred to going from user query to retrieving information directly based on the query then passing it to an LLM: With CC the LLM is taking the raw user query then crafting its own searches

But realistically lots of RAG systems have LLM calls interleaved for various reasons, so what they probably mean it not doing the usual chunking + embeddings thing.

Re: What makes Claude Code so damn good

#14
post #8
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please don't post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News, and especially not putdowns. The idea here is: if you have a substantive point, make it thoughtfully. If not, please don't comment until you do. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

I appreciate the vague negative takes on tools like this where it feels like there is so much hype it's impossible to have a different opinion. "It's bad" is perfectly substantiative in my opinion; this person tried it, didn't like it, and doesn't have much more to say because of that, but it's still a useful perspective. Is this why HN is so dang pro-AI? the negative comments, even small ones, are moderated away? ex…

I think this comment would be a little better by specifying WHY it's bad instead of just a "it's bad" like it's a Twitter thread.

Re: What makes Claude Code so damn good

#15
post #9
post #4

[flagged]

Yes technically it is RAG, but a lot of the community is associating RAG with vector search specifically.

it does? why? the term RAG as I understand it leaves the methodology for retrieval vague so that different techniques can be used depending on the, er, context.. which makes a lot more sense to me

Re: What makes Claude Code so damn good

#16
I don’t know if I’m doing something wrong. I was using Sonnet 4 with GitHub Copilot. Recently a week ago switched to Claude Code. I find GitHub Copilot solves problem and bugs way better than Claude Code. For some reason, Claude Code seems very lazy. Has anyone experience something similar?

Re: What makes Claude Code so damn good

#17
It shocks me when people say that LLMs don't make them more productive, because my experience has been the complete opposite, especially with Claude Code.

Either I'm worse than then at programming, to the point that I find an LLM useful and they don't, or they don't know how to use LLMs for coding.

Re: What makes Claude Code so damn good

#18

It shocks me when people say that LLMs don't make them more productive, because my experience has been the complete opposite, especially with Claude Code. Either I'm worse than then at programming, to the point that I find an LLM useful and they don't, or they don't know how to use LLMs for coding.

Agreed. I only started using Claude Code about a week and a half ago and I'm blown away by how productive I can be with it.

Re: What makes Claude Code so damn good

#19

It shocks me when people say that LLMs don't make them more productive, because my experience has been the complete opposite, especially with Claude Code. Either I'm worse than then at programming, to the point that I find an LLM useful and they don't, or they don't know how to use LLMs for coding.

Productivity boost is unbelieveable! If you handle it right, its a boon - its like having 3 junior devs at hand. And I'm talking about using the web interface.

I guess most people are not paying and cant therefore apply the project-space (which is one of the best features), which unleashes its full magic.

Even if I'm currently without a job, I'm still paying because it helps me.

Post reply on HN