Live data from Hacker News

24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

thedrive.com

61–65 of 65 posts

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#61
post #33
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I actually don’t think it’s that absurd. It definitely is hype but I think e-scooters and (far more) e-bikes actually are a huge innovation in personal transport, not in pure tech but in effect on lifestyles especially when you factor in cost. I have a cargo e-bike I use as my daily driver, taking the kids to school, picking up groceries etc. If they didn’t exist I’d probably have to pay for (and deal with) a car. A…

But bikes aren’t scooters.

I stand corrected.

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#62
post #32

If you're going to be this ridiculous, at least make it look cool. Re-invent the Penny Farthing perhaps. An electric version of that, with some funky way of lifting the rider up, would be amazing. This is like the cronut of bikes, all the downsides of a scooter, and none of the upsides of a motorbike.

> This is like the cronut of bikes, all the downsides of a scooter, and none of the upsides of a motorbike.

Is it possible you didn't look at the article and are thinking of something like a Vespa rather than the type of thing you stand upright on while holding onto a handle?

These things have plenty of advantages. They're incredibly portable and easy to charge. When the weather is nice my friend rides his the ~20 miles from his place to my place (which is mostly covered by rail trail bike paths). You can bring one into the office and charge it at your desk. Many public transit systems allow you to bring them on the subway or bus, which at rush hour might not be possible with a normal bicycle. If bike lockups aren't available at the nearest station/stop, this lets people who live within a mile or two still get the advantage of public transit.

> Re-invent the Penny Farthing perhaps. An electric version of that, with some funky way of lifting the rider up, would be amazing.

The penny farthing bike is certainly ridiculous, but I can't imagine a way you could possibly make one look cool. Is it even legal to ride one if you don't have some sort of ironic facial hair, a bowler hat, or a vest?

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I just roll mine around it's not really a problem

They don't have baskets at this store. You have to use a push cart. This probably has something to do with the amount of theft that occurs in this area. I'm also probably not equally abled to you so a _bicycle_ is more useful to me and pushing that around a store with a cart getting groceries would be a ridiculous chore. The world would probably be better if you didn't assume that everyone's experiences are identical…

I don't know of a solution for the types of half-size carts common in small grocery stores, but I've seen people stash their scooters in the space below the main basket of full size carts

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They don't have baskets at this store. You have to use a push cart. This probably has something to do with the amount of theft that occurs in this area. I'm also probably not equally abled to you so a _bicycle_ is more useful to me and pushing that around a store with a cart getting groceries would be a ridiculous chore. The world would probably be better if you didn't assume that everyone's experiences are identical…

I don't know of a solution for the types of half-size carts common in small grocery stores, but I've seen people stash their scooters in the space below the main basket of full size carts

Okay.

Could you also just put some anti-theft features on the device itself?

Is there some reason NOT to do this?

What an absurd conversation this has been.

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know of a solution for the types of half-size carts common in small grocery stores, but I've seen people stash their scooters in the space below the main basket of full size carts

Okay. Could you also just put some anti-theft features on the device itself? Is there some reason NOT to do this? What an absurd conversation this has been.

It seems like that would be difficult given its size. It's hard to secure something you can just pick up and walk away with if you can't lock it to something
Post reply on HN