Live data from Hacker News

24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

thedrive.com

11–20 of 65 posts

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#11
post #8

Scooters are just deceptively dangerous. The ease with which you can just hop on and go 20, 30, 40mph in instant is a false sense of security. There’s no drama, no warning, just pure speed standing upright, feet mere inches off the ground. Crashing on a 100mph scooter is sure to end gruesomely.

Yeah I’m a scooter rider and there’s no way I would get on a scooter going that fast, even with protective equipment. Much less use it around other people.

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#13
post #8

Scooters are just deceptively dangerous. The ease with which you can just hop on and go 20, 30, 40mph in instant is a false sense of security. There’s no drama, no warning, just pure speed standing upright, feet mere inches off the ground. Crashing on a 100mph scooter is sure to end gruesomely.

They should move slower, not faster

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#15
post #8

Scooters are just deceptively dangerous. The ease with which you can just hop on and go 20, 30, 40mph in instant is a false sense of security. There’s no drama, no warning, just pure speed standing upright, feet mere inches off the ground. Crashing on a 100mph scooter is sure to end gruesomely.

I’m unsure how the risk compares to an e-bike.

Assuming speeds are equal I think the consequences of a crash are better on a scooter. You don’t have a crossbar between your legs to trip you as you fall, and you start in a standing position, so you’re more likely to land on your feet. Also your head and shoulders are above the cars so you’re less likely to end up under the car.

Having said that I think scooter crashes are more likely given the tiny wheels and less stable frame. Try riding an e scooter without hands. It doesn’t self balance like a bike.

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#16
post #15
post #8

Scooters are just deceptively dangerous. The ease with which you can just hop on and go 20, 30, 40mph in instant is a false sense of security. There’s no drama, no warning, just pure speed standing upright, feet mere inches off the ground. Crashing on a 100mph scooter is sure to end gruesomely.

I’m unsure how the risk compares to an e-bike. Assuming speeds are equal I think the consequences of a crash are better on a scooter. You don’t have a crossbar between your legs to trip you as you fall, and you start in a standing position, so you’re more likely to land on your feet. Also your head and shoulders are above the cars so you’re less likely to end up under the car. Having said that I think scooter crashes…

Would you want a person on an e-bike to blow past you at 40mph mere inches from your body? Because it can be a common occurrence with scooters.

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#17
post #12

I did ctrl+F and searched for "danger" and "risk" and neither word appears in the article.

To be fair the guy is wearing full protection gear, so already there people should be able to get an idea about how clever it is to ride this without one.

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#18
I like to look at these things in terms of kinetic energy. 100mph is roughly 100x more KE than at 10mph.

Assume I hit a car with enough energy to break my leg and the car's windshield. This seems plausible at 10mph. Now, we scale this by 2 orders of magnitude. You could cripple lots of people with this thing in one shot. Bollards wont stop a guy with a scooter.

Re: 24,000-Watt Scooter Is Going for a 100 MPH Speed Record at Bonneville

#19
post #15
post #8

Scooters are just deceptively dangerous. The ease with which you can just hop on and go 20, 30, 40mph in instant is a false sense of security. There’s no drama, no warning, just pure speed standing upright, feet mere inches off the ground. Crashing on a 100mph scooter is sure to end gruesomely.

I’m unsure how the risk compares to an e-bike. Assuming speeds are equal I think the consequences of a crash are better on a scooter. You don’t have a crossbar between your legs to trip you as you fall, and you start in a standing position, so you’re more likely to land on your feet. Also your head and shoulders are above the cars so you’re less likely to end up under the car. Having said that I think scooter crashes…

E-bikes have relatively huge wheels. These interact with any bumbs, curbwalls, pot-holes, rocks in much more safe manner. This with stability makes them to me much safer.

Still does not do much difference when crashing to someone or something or someone crashing into you.

Post reply on HN