Live data from Hacker News

Open models by OpenAI

openai.com

261–270 of 909 posts

Re: Open models by OpenAI

#261

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Update: I tried it out. It took about 8 seconds per token, and didn't seem to be using much of my GPU (MPU), but was using a lot of RAM. Not a model that I could use practically on my machine.

To clarify, this was the 20B model?

Yep, 20B model, via Ollama: ollama run gpt-oss:20b

Screenshot here with Ollama running and asitop in other terminal:

https://bsky.app/profile/pamelafox.bsky.social/post/3lvobol3...

Re: Open models by OpenAI

#262
post #233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"the most important decade in human history." Lol. To be young and foolish again. This covid laced decade is more of a placeholder. The current decade is always the most meaningful until the next one. The personal computer era, the first cars or planes, ending slavery needs to take a backseat to the best search engine ever. We are at the point where everyone is planning on what they are going to do with their hoverbo…

> ending slavery happened over many centuries, not in a given decade. Abolished and reintroduced in many places: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_abolition_of_slave...

you can say the same shit about machine learning but ChatGPT was still the Juneteenth of AI

Re: Open models by OpenAI

#263

Model cards, for the people interested in the guts: https://cdn.openai.com/pdf/419b6906-9da6-406c-a19d-1bb078ac7... In my mind, I’m comparing the model architecture they describe to what the leading open-weights models (Deepseek, Qwen, GLM, Kimi) have been doing. Honestly, it just seems “ok” at a technical level: - both models use standard Grouped-Query Attention (64 query heads, 8 KV heads). The card talks about how…

Also: attention sinks (although implemented as extra trained logits used in attention softmax rather than attending to e.g. a prepended special token).

Re: Open models by OpenAI

#264

I'm out of the loop for local models. For my M3 24gb ram macbook, what token throughput can I expect? Edit: I tried it out, I have no idea in terms of of tokens but it was fluid enough for me. A bit slower than using o3 in the browser but definitely tolerable. I think I will set it up in my GF's machine so she can stop paying for the full subscription (she's a non-tech professional)

Wondering about the same for my M4 max 128 gb

It should fly on your machine

Re: Open models by OpenAI

#265
post #233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"the most important decade in human history." Lol. To be young and foolish again. This covid laced decade is more of a placeholder. The current decade is always the most meaningful until the next one. The personal computer era, the first cars or planes, ending slavery needs to take a backseat to the best search engine ever. We are at the point where everyone is planning on what they are going to do with their hoverbo…

> ending slavery happened over many centuries, not in a given decade. Abolished and reintroduced in many places: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_abolition_of_slave...

Slavery is still legal and widespread in most of the US, including California.

There was a ballot measure to actually abolish slavery a year or so back. It failed miserably.

Re: Open models by OpenAI

#266

Earlier quoted context omitted.

True, but there's still a meaningful difference in friction and scale. With closed APIs, OpenAI can monitor for misuse, throttle abuse and deploy countermeasures in real-time. With open weights, a single prompt jailbreak or exploit spreads instantly. No need for ML expertise, just a Reddit post. The risk isn’t that bad actors suddenly become smarter. It’s that anyone can now run unmoderated inference and OpenAI loses…

OpenAI and Azure both have zero retention options, and the NYT saga has given pretty strong confirmation they meant it when they said zero.

I think you're conflating real-time monitoring with data retention. Zero retention means OpenAI doesn't store user data, but they can absolutely still filter content, rate limit and block harmful prompts in real-time without retaining anything. That's processing requests as they come in, not storing them. The NYT case was about data storage for training/analysis not about real-time safety measures.

Re: Open models by OpenAI

#267
thanks openai for being open ;) Surprised there are no official MLX versions and only one mention of MLX in this thread. MLX basically converst the models to take advntage of mac unified memory for 2-5x increase in power, enabling macs to run what would otherwise take expensive gpus (within limits).

So FYI to any one on mac, the easiest way to run these models right now is using LM Studio (https://lmstudio.ai/), its free. You just search for the model, usually 3rd party groups mlx-community or lmstudio-community have mlx versions within a day or 2 of releases. I go for the 8-bit quantizations (4-bit faster, but quality drops). You can also convert to mlx yourself...

Once you have it running on LM studio, you can chat there in their chat interface, or you can run it through api that defaults to http://127.0.0.1:1234

You can run multiple models that hot swap and load instantly and switch between them etc.

Its surpassingly easy, and fun.There are actually a lot of cool niche models comings out, like this tiny high-quality search model released today as well (and who released official mlx version) https://huggingface.co/Intelligent-Internet/II-Search-4B

Other fun ones are gemma 3n which is model multi-modal, larger one that is actually solid model but takes more memory is the new Qwen3 30b A3B (coder and instruct), Pixtral (mixtral vision with full resolution images), etc. Look forward to playing with this model and see how it compares.

Re: Open models by OpenAI

#268

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed, these models seem relatively mediocre to Qwen3 / GLM 4.5

Nah, these are much smaller models than Qwen3 and GLM 4.5 with similar performance. Fewer parameters and fewer bits per parameter. They are much more impressive and will run on garden variety gaming PCs at more than usable speed. I can't wait to try on my 4090 at home. There's basically no reason to run other open source models now that these are available, at least for non-multimodal tasks.

From my initial web developer test on https://www.gpt-oss.com/ the 120b is kind of meh. Even qwen3-coder 30b-a3b is better. have to test more.

Re: Open models by OpenAI

#269
post #150

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Qwen3 has multiple variants ranging from larger (230B) than these models to significantly smaller (0.6b), with a huge number of options in between. For each of those models they also release quantized versions (your "fewer bits per parameter). I'm still withholding judgement until I see benchmarks, but every point you tried to make regarding model size and parameter size is wrong. Qwen has more variety on every level…

The benchmarks of the OpenAI models are comparable to the largest variants of other open models. The smaller variants of other open models are much worse.

With all due respect, you need to actually test out Qwen3 2507 or GLM 4.5 before making these sorts of claims. Both of them are comparable to OpenAI's largest models and even bench favorably to Deepseek and Opus: https://cdn-uploads.huggingface.co/production/uploads/62430a...

It's cool to see OpenAI throw their hat in the ring, but you're smoking straight hopium if you think there's "no reason to run other open source models now" in earnest. If OpenAI never released these models, the state-of-the-art would not look significantly different for local LLMs. This is almost a nothingburger if not for the simple novelty of OpenAI releasing an Open AI for once in their life.

Re: Open models by OpenAI

#270

Anybody got this working in Ollama? I'm running latest version 0.11.0 with WebUI v0.6.18 but getting: > List the US presidents in order starting with George Washington and their time in office and year taken office. >> 00: template: :3: function "currentDate" not defined

Sorry about this. Re-downloading Ollama should fix the error
Post reply on HN