Live data from Hacker News

Financial lessons from my family's experience with long-term care insurance

whitecoatinvestor.com

191–200 of 210 posts

Re: Financial lessons from my family's experience with long-term care insurance

#191
post #12

Healthcare in the US is broken and they won’t let you fix it because the money is too good. Think about the fact that PBMs, which is there to save and manage on pharma is incentivized to promote drug price inflation. That’s just one “small” piece of this clusterf*k. It’s layers and layers of these convoluted system of incentives. As to OP, the simplest solution is to move out of the US early enough or become “poor” e…

Healthcare is little more than a jobs program at this point. I believe it is the largest industry by employment in every single state now. That compounds the problem even further. Really fixing it would put a double digit percentage of people out of work. I'm all for it, but I can see why politicians are hesitant.

To be fair, the NHS is the largest employer is the UK as well

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_United_Kingdom...

Keeping people healthy is labour intensive.

Re: Financial lessons from my family's experience with long-term care insurance

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the UK, with the NHS, it seems the focus of the NHS became management, rather than clinical care. One example I read of stuck with me; a superb nurse, who ran her ward extremely well, had to leave clinical nursing because as a career path, it was a dead end. She had to move into management, and her former ward descended into chaos. NHS budget has last I knew increased many times over since 1948, but the bed count…

This problem is far broader than health care. Doesn't matter whether your actual "product" is hospital wards, sheet steel, romance novels, or mowed lawns - if your sector of the economy is not structured to have draconian penalties for bloated management/bureaucracy/overhead, then it will quickly develop ever-worsening bloat. Because it's always quicker & easier to scale up the desks & paperwork. And guess who makes…

Seems like large tech companies never have a shortage of management.

Between the matrix style organizational structure and the many layers (project manager, program manager, director, VP, senior VP, BU president, etc…), I would love to know what, if anything, the higher levels actually DO.

Re: Financial lessons from my family's experience with long-term care insurance

#193
post #141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The public system in Hong Kong doesn't really cost anything. It's not that you get costs "waived" if you whine hard enough that you ought to be a charity case (which, by the way, is degrading,) and it's not that costs are passed on to a middleman. Medical treatment is transparently priced and simply inexpensive -- so it's simply not a cause of bankruptcy in Hong Kong, whereas, in the US... > https://worldpopulationre…

Nearly identical with a coat of paint. Every "horror story" I've heard about having to beg with the health system here is tellingly parroted by people who do not have experience with the system. It is the default to get itemized bills when you are insured and the outcome is the same. And again, there is nothing unusual about private care in the US - I pay cash, direct, a small amount monthly, for excellent private ca…

You are completely wrong, and I can almost hear in my mind how you think something you are promoting as true, is 'basically true' - but please know there are plenty of people reading HN from afar and may come to expect 'free healthcare in US (just go to the ER!)' from your comments.

No it is not.

Lots of experience with the health system in the US, for me, and helping many other navigate the systems.

It's not even close to identical. If you go to ER here and you can't pay, they may provide you with a certain level of 'care' to 'stabilize you' (as the law says they are supposed to, and the feds send some money to hospitals to cover some of this), and you will get billed, and collections calling, and credit report issues, and threats to sue and have your property auctioned (have held one of these letters in my hand, complete with a list of property that was in my name.

Even worse, the 'care' you may get is normally crap. For example I have seen the same people with same condition, at one hospital get a quick surgery and leave with a colostomy bag for rest of life, and other person at other hospital with insurance get placed in a room and treated for weeks - then left with a warning to avoid seeds.

I have seen so many examples of places leaves humans to rot with no insurance - hospitals.

Even with insurance, you can find yourself waiting 6-8 weeks for a doc appointment. I have so many examples.

Re: Financial lessons from my family's experience with long-term care insurance

#194

Earlier quoted context omitted.

“USA is very very good at complicated, cutting edge medical care” - i hear this but haven’t seen it in practice or in statistics. Everyone I know that has needed such things has had the same poor quality of care that primary care providers have - long waits, insurance issues and mediocre outcomes.

> i hear this but haven’t seen it in practice or in statistics curious. what kind of statistics would that show up? When i was looking into clinical trials for prostate cancer. almost 80% of experimental cutting edge medicine was in usa. They even have spl k2 visa for International patients to participate.

I suppose it’s semantics but i wouldn’t consider experimental research “medical care”.

Re: Financial lessons from my family's experience with long-term care insurance

#195

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is it a coincidence that the industries with the most heavy government involvement - health care, education, and housing - are the most messed up with perverse incentives? Whereas the software industry, with near zero government involvement, has had enormous improvements in function and has pushed the cost to literally zero.

When it comes to healthcare, we didn't used to have so much regulation. And, well, it sucked. People died, black people got injected with radiation, and we experimented on humans. Ultimately, I don't want poor people to just... die. Because that's bad. So we need some sort of guarantees. Or, we don't: in which case, I hope you're content scraping bodies off the freeway for free. Someone has to do it if we're not payi…

> People died, black people got injected with radiation, and we experimented on humans.

Those were experiments done by the government or funded by the government.

Re: Financial lessons from my family's experience with long-term care insurance

#196
I am 68 I was diagnosed in 2023 neurologist told me I wouldn’t benefit from any meds right now due to age.. My primary care provider introduced me to MS-4 Protocol from uinehealthcentre. Net and i immediately started on their Multiple Sclerosis treatment, this MS-4 treatment has made a tremendous difference for me. My symptoms including muscle weakness, fatigue, mood swings, numbness, double vision and urinary retention all disappeared after the 4 months treatment! It’s a shame my comment might be considered as spam as there’s alot of spam comments on this group.

Re: Financial lessons from my family's experience with long-term care insurance

#197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> i hear this but haven’t seen it in practice or in statistics curious. what kind of statistics would that show up? When i was looking into clinical trials for prostate cancer. almost 80% of experimental cutting edge medicine was in usa. They even have spl k2 visa for International patients to participate.

I suppose it’s semantics but i wouldn’t consider experimental research “medical care”.

even outside clinical trials. for prostate cancer, only doctors i found practicing newer therapies was in usa.

Re: Financial lessons from my family's experience with long-term care insurance

#198

I am 68 I was diagnosed in 2023 neurologist told me I wouldn’t benefit from any meds right now due to age.. My primary care provider introduced me to MS-4 Protocol from uinehealthcentre. Net and i immediately started on their Multiple Sclerosis treatment, this MS-4 treatment has made a tremendous difference for me. My symptoms including muscle weakness, fatigue, mood swings, numbness, double vision and urinary retent…

Interesting this comment!!! It looks like there are bots out there shilling specific treatments on message boards? Wonder where this price shows up in our cost structure!!!???

Re: Financial lessons from my family's experience with long-term care insurance

#199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This problem is far broader than health care. Doesn't matter whether your actual "product" is hospital wards, sheet steel, romance novels, or mowed lawns - if your sector of the economy is not structured to have draconian penalties for bloated management/bureaucracy/overhead, then it will quickly develop ever-worsening bloat. Because it's always quicker & easier to scale up the desks & paperwork. And guess who makes…

Seems like large tech companies never have a shortage of management. Between the matrix style organizational structure and the many layers (project manager, program manager, director, VP, senior VP, BU president, etc…), I would love to know what, if anything, the higher levels actually DO.

> I would love to know what, if anything, the higher levels actually DO.

In many org's, they mostly compete with other higher-levels for status.

And the biggest signifiers of status are usually (1) how many lower-level managers ultimately report to you, and (2) how many layers those lower-level managers span.

Re: Financial lessons from my family's experience with long-term care insurance

#200

I am 68 I was diagnosed in 2023 neurologist told me I wouldn’t benefit from any meds right now due to age.. My primary care provider introduced me to MS-4 Protocol from uinehealthcentre. Net and i immediately started on their Multiple Sclerosis treatment, this MS-4 treatment has made a tremendous difference for me. My symptoms including muscle weakness, fatigue, mood swings, numbness, double vision and urinary retent…

You comment is the definition of spam
Post reply on HN