Live data from Hacker News

Mastercard deflects blame for NSFW games being taken down

pcgamer.com

31–40 of 621 posts

Re: Mastercard deflects blame for NSFW games being taken down

#31

Anti-monopoly laws are good, but how about some harsh anti-duopoly laws? Could also hit the iOS-Android bird with the same stone!

Existing "antimonopoly" laws already cover unfair competition, market manipulation, etc. regardless of the number of entities.

Re: Mastercard deflects blame for NSFW games being taken down

#33

What's stopping a large, profitable company like Valve from starting its own payment processor? Surely the technology part of it can't be an impossible hurdle.

I mean they kind of do. Most of the time I would hand wave away any company offering gift cards or credits, but Steam has created an economy / structure that I think warrants mentioning here.

I have sold a few items on Steam because I don't care about cosmetics in games. I'm also lazy and because of that "sat" on items for a while that appreciated. I mention this because Steam credit is very fungible: it can be easily converted.

Steam also makes it very easy to redeem credit, gift, etc.

I believe you can buy Steam cards at most places Xbox cards and similar are sold as well.

Also in the early days of Bitcoin buying and selling of digital Steam assets was one of the most popular things.

Re: Mastercard deflects blame for NSFW games being taken down

#36

What's stopping a large, profitable company like Valve from starting its own payment processor? Surely the technology part of it can't be an impossible hurdle.

Adoption.

You'd have to onboard hundreds/thousands of banks and terminal providers so they accept/give out your card.

I excpect the underlying technical stuff isn't that hard compared to getting people and companies to actually use it.

Re: Mastercard deflects blame for NSFW games being taken down

#37
post #27

Lots of outrage at the card companies, but strangely, no outrage at the laws that actually caused this. One is the Australian law to remove that type of content and the other is the US law that says the payment processor can't participate in illegal transactions.

Then they would just get removed in Australia, not worldwide.

Re: Mastercard deflects blame for NSFW games being taken down

#38
post #20

I feel like nobody cares really and none of the companies care, but are all worried because of the massive stranglehold 2 players have (and realistically each has almost entire control). Mastercard don't care you want porn, or games, or whatever. Neither does VISA. They like money. They want money and want people to move their money so they can siphon off some of it for their own pockets. Almost nobody is going to av…

This has nothing to do with charge backs and everything to do with the Australian and US laws.

Re: Mastercard deflects blame for NSFW games being taken down

#39

[flagged]

>Bewildering to see the outrage over this. Get real, cleaning up the smut is not an attack on free speech or democracy.

Sure, religious fascists enjoy this now, next they will remove GTA and shooter games, metal music and Hip HOp and when some Rust fanboy extremist will complain C++ and PHP content will be removed for safety reasons.

We need to complain so religious fascist content is removed too

Re: Mastercard deflects blame for NSFW games being taken down

#40
post #27

Lots of outrage at the card companies, but strangely, no outrage at the laws that actually caused this. One is the Australian law to remove that type of content and the other is the US law that says the payment processor can't participate in illegal transactions.

Do you have info on the US law? I am curious if it follows the same trend Russia set years ago with requiring them to put a large deposit and if they break the rules they get to keep all the money.
Post reply on HN