Live data from Hacker News

Build an AI telephony agent for inbound and outbound calls

github.com

11–20 of 50 posts

Re: Build an AI telephony agent for inbound and outbound calls

#11

No offense, but how many people will be jobless because of this?

We just hook up generators to bikes so that the former phone workers can now power the AI thats replaced them. This will eventually be a cheaper alternative to the current power grid as ai electricity consumption increases.

Re: Build an AI telephony agent for inbound and outbound calls

#12

No offense, but how many people will be jobless because of this?

A huge number of these jobs will go yes. A call centre supervisor may be safe taking escalation calls that need a human and so on but the masses will be replaced by this kind of tech.

However what will actually happen is society will use these people to brick lay for houses, care for the elderly or something else. That's honestly a good thing for society as we have massive shortages there, and not a bad thing for the individuals as a whole.

Re: Build an AI telephony agent for inbound and outbound calls

#13
post #12

No offense, but how many people will be jobless because of this?

A huge number of these jobs will go yes. A call centre supervisor may be safe taking escalation calls that need a human and so on but the masses will be replaced by this kind of tech. However what will actually happen is society will use these people to brick lay for houses, care for the elderly or something else. That's honestly a good thing for society as we have massive shortages there, and not a bad thing for the…

> However what will actually happen is society will use these people to brick lay for houses, care for the elderly or something else. That's honestly a good thing for society as we have massive shortages there, and not a bad thing for the individuals as a whole.

Labor "shortages" for those jobs exist because they are not financially attractive. Why is it a "good thing" to eliminate more attractive roles? How does this materially reduce the cost of living, or increase for the roles you point to?

Re: Build an AI telephony agent for inbound and outbound calls

#14

No offense, but how many people will be jobless because of this?

We just hook up generators to bikes so that the former phone workers can now power the AI thats replaced them. This will eventually be a cheaper alternative to the current power grid as ai electricity consumption increases.

Ah, so THIS is the background story of that Black Mirror episode!

Re: Build an AI telephony agent for inbound and outbound calls

#15
post #8

I'll take an alternative view of someone else's comment. No offense, but how much shittier will my customer service experience with my power company or ISP be because of this?

as somebody who works in this area: depends on how much effort they will be willing to invest. it might be better than current service or it might be worse.

big question will be availability of humans as fall back that actually have some skills

Re: Build an AI telephony agent for inbound and outbound calls

#16
post #15
post #8

I'll take an alternative view of someone else's comment. No offense, but how much shittier will my customer service experience with my power company or ISP be because of this?

as somebody who works in this area: depends on how much effort they will be willing to invest. it might be better than current service or it might be worse. big question will be availability of humans as fall back that actually have some skills

I still can't wrap my head around how making functional online portals and well written documentation for customers is too hard, but laying off entire call centers and replacing them with a chat bot that relies on checks notes a functional set of APIs for tool use and well written documentation for a KB, is easier. It looks like all the same effort plus more!

Re: Build an AI telephony agent for inbound and outbound calls

#17
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A huge number of these jobs will go yes. A call centre supervisor may be safe taking escalation calls that need a human and so on but the masses will be replaced by this kind of tech. However what will actually happen is society will use these people to brick lay for houses, care for the elderly or something else. That's honestly a good thing for society as we have massive shortages there, and not a bad thing for the…

> However what will actually happen is society will use these people to brick lay for houses, care for the elderly or something else. That's honestly a good thing for society as we have massive shortages there, and not a bad thing for the individuals as a whole. Labor "shortages" for those jobs exist because they are not financially attractive. Why is it a "good thing" to eliminate more attractive roles? How does thi…

Let's say answering a phone is 11/hour and laying bricks is 11.20/hour. No big shock that people will take the phone job, but if you remove that option more people will flow into the laying bricks job.

Re: Build an AI telephony agent for inbound and outbound calls

#18
post #8

I'll take an alternative view of someone else's comment. No offense, but how much shittier will my customer service experience with my power company or ISP be because of this?

No offense, but how about evaluating the project on its own merits?

In my experience AI based CS agents are not deployed to actually provide customer service. That does not differ too much from the "old school" phone call centre with scripts etc.

Anyway, you can run a phone exchange on a RPi. My favorite anti marketing thing is a simple IVR: "If you think we would like to speak to press 1, if you are making an unsolicited sales call, then hang up". However, that will soon be defeated (but not yet, I'm happy to report). Eventually, I will need the machine to take calls for me. For that I will probably need a system like OPs.

When it comes to telephony, the biggest issue is who pays for the call. For me it is the caller. For some (US int al) it might be the recipient. The only "cost" to me is my time to take a call.

Now, back to call centres. You want problem resolution and they want call stats. There is a bit of a disconnect. Power companies and other utilities all claim to be competitive but nearly everywhere that is bollocks.

In the UK we have privatised water companies, covering regions but how on earth can I, within the purvey of Wessex water, get my water from say Scotland. Ironically enough SSSE (one of the S is Scottish) is the local area electrical provider. I can choose my electic and gas supplier but not my water supplier. How on earth is that a free market? Well it might be but not for me, the consumer. I understand that ISP provision in the US is pretty similar to our water company situation: you have a choice of one.

So, I think, that the problem here is not the AI or the medium or whatever but something far deeper and far more entrenched.

Your shitty customer experience is because the status quo is say 50-100 years old and nothing to do with some nerdy new technology.

Re: Build an AI telephony agent for inbound and outbound calls

#19
post #8

I'll take an alternative view of someone else's comment. No offense, but how much shittier will my customer service experience with my power company or ISP be because of this?

I'm someone who builds these types of voice agent systems for businesses. And the short answer is, I think especially for the bigger corporations, customer service probably will get shittier.

It doesn't have to be inevitable...but the track record of big corps and their view of customer-facing departments as being loss-centers instead of being directly and indirectly connected to retaining and bringing in revenue doesn't leave me optimistic.

For small-to-medium businesses...it just depends. SMBs are typically more sensitive to the opinions and sentiments of their customers (and also bad press) and also typically have workers with relatively more institutional and tacit knowledge compared to big corporations. So I would like to believe more of them will be much more methodical and intentional about their approaches (especially with cautionary tales like Klarna and DuoLingo). There's no reason for any business to ruin their customer service with AI other than impulsive and/or poorly executed decisions being made out of some mix of fear, hype, greed, or willful ignorance. Entirely avoidable.

Re: Build an AI telephony agent for inbound and outbound calls

#20
post #8

I'll take an alternative view of someone else's comment. No offense, but how much shittier will my customer service experience with my power company or ISP be because of this?

Possibly better, possibly worse.

The bot will have more info and doesn't degrade every few years (as nobody is there to be replaced and lose the tribal knowledge that makes a business run).

It also.. is just a dumb bot and _only_ knows what it is told.

Post reply on HN