Live data from Hacker News

The EU could be scanning your chats by October 2025

techradar.com

81–90 of 259 posts

Re: The EU could be scanning your chats by October 2025

#81
post #4

it seems it is the general Zeitgeist in Europe. Also in Switzerland and generally erosions of Privacy laws all across the continent. The governments are scared of insurgencies from the right, from the left, from immigrants, from foreign nations. Paranoia and fear are quite prominent.

[flagged]

Re: The EU could be scanning your chats by October 2025

#82
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

OK, I’ll bite. What reason would there be to paint every bird orange?

There isnt. Its a crazy example of what is happening here. To use a real world example take this "EU deal" that Trump did. Everyone is talking like its already taken effect. But the reality is the EU just handshake agreed to this, but at the end of the day all of the member states have to rattify it. And if states dont or if there are arguements made the whole thing gets tossed. I just wish people would say that they…

You are spreading some serious disinformation about how the EU works.

Once such EU-wide regulations are fully passed (incl. the EP), the countries have to implement them in their law. Sure, they can drag their feet, or there actually might be a real showdown, for example, if the German Constitutional Court says that this is against the Grundgesetz and that it does not recognize supremacy of EU law over itself / the German Constitution. If the same happens in Poland, there will be extra drama added.

But at the same time, at least half of the EU, countries with negligible tech sector, will happily pass that legislation without any significant friction, because a) think of the children, b) monitoring opposition and dissent, yay!, c) we have to, because Brussels said so, d) the lawmakers know shit about encryption and tech and they will be exempt from monitoring anyway, so encryption is something that is only used by criminals and terrorists and if you have nothing to hide etc. etc.

At which point you have the surveillance infrastructure installed and in operation across half the continent, and with elections changing governments, it will spread.

Our main protection used to be that small countries like Slovenia or Malta don't have the weight to push Apple or Google to introduce deliberate holes in their software.

If the European Commission joins the push, that is a completely different pressure.

Re: The EU could be scanning your chats by October 2025

#83

Nothing will come of this. Germany, for some reason, really doesn't like the idea of monitoring citizens messages. Anything that eventually passes will be extremely toothless.

German politicians love surveillance. I guarantee the CDU and AfD would immediately support this.

The AfD would support it? They seem like one of the more freedom focused parties in Germany.

Re: The EU could be scanning your chats by October 2025

#84

I just don't get it - criminals will just continue to use "real" encryption. Why are some of these people so obsessed with reading everyone's chats?

Easy - you can scan and ban political dissent. This is the only reason the scumbags are pushing it hard.

I wonder if anyone believes those measure are actually against childporn.

Re: The EU could be scanning your chats by October 2025

#85
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mean, you can say that, but the unelected will decide for us. Oh when it was just for "easier international trade". What a good one.

While I also strongly disagree with this plan, everyone involved is elected. The whole "unelected" angle is europhobic propaganda.

How do I vote Ursula out?

Re: The EU could be scanning your chats by October 2025

#86
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

OK, I’ll bite. What reason would there be to paint every bird orange?

There isnt. Its a crazy example of what is happening here. To use a real world example take this "EU deal" that Trump did. Everyone is talking like its already taken effect. But the reality is the EU just handshake agreed to this, but at the end of the day all of the member states have to rattify it. And if states dont or if there are arguements made the whole thing gets tossed. I just wish people would say that they…

You picked a really bad time to defend a "politicians will eventually do what is best for us" position, given that such a law just came into effect in UK. And I think it's you who don't understand how the EU works. It's the biggest countries that must agree to something. Then they coerce/convince the rest. At best, the smaller countries can put on some kind of resistance until they extract some minor exception. This isn't "some Dutch mayor proposes free Internet". This is a relentless onslaught on encryption and privacy. And it's already in effect in other countries where someone at sometime also said "nah, don't worry, they just messing with us, it's not gonna pass".

Re: The EU could be scanning your chats by October 2025

#87
post #38
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Open source will find a way around it; there's no reason to be afraid. Unless one day their spyware is installed at the hardware level but that would be the equivalent of raiding our homes, so that's not very likely.

open source wont save you. if they make encryption without backdoor illegal they will just throw you in jail

It'll definitely save the criminals.

Selling drugs on the Internet is also illegal. Selling them in real life too. How many people are doing it still? Doesn't seem very effective, this solution.

Re: The EU could be scanning your chats by October 2025

#89

"the EU wants to scan your messages" implies its every member state and not one freak from Denmark putting this forward where it will die. The EU has always been 90 days from passing mass surveliance for the last decade. Until member states start actually backing this these articles are nothing but click bait.

"not one freak from Denmark putting this forward where it will die" Not true. The truth is that Chat Control has returned several times already and the majority of the EU states were actually always for, but a blocking minority has been reached each time - barely so. Worryingly, one of the blocking minority countries used to be Germany, where privacy-minded smaller parties (Greens, FDP) are no longer in government. T…

> Fuck, I don't want to live in a China with a blue flag instead of red. This is absolutely dystopian.

I think it's too late. People already showed they'd loudly support this if propagandized enough like during COVID times where the most draconian and anti constitutional of policies were enacted, literally following and lobbied by China.

Unless people recognize that they did a terrible thing in supporting covid policies instead of burying their head under the sand or persisting in the ridiculous propaganda about anti-vaxxers and disinformation, they're always going to be easily manipulated. The same goes for the "let's invade new country because 'dictator/terrorism/grave threat to our western way of life'".

Are we the baddies is a rethorical question at this point.

Re: The EU could be scanning your chats by October 2025

#90
post #85
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While I also strongly disagree with this plan, everyone involved is elected. The whole "unelected" angle is europhobic propaganda.

How do I vote Ursula out?

By voting out the conservative governments that appointed her - the same way you vote the US president out by voting out the electors that appointed him.
Post reply on HN