Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Most Wikipedia articles lead to the same loop

wikiloopr.com

71–80 of 171 posts

Re: Show HN: Most Wikipedia articles lead to the same loop

#71
After having twenty tries that got me into the philosophy loop, I started to think what are the most basic concepts that philosophy is "made of". Maybe I could escape the loop that way?

And lo and behold, I tried word "word" and it loops between "emotion" and "psychology". http://wikiloopr.com/word

Re: Show HN: Most Wikipedia articles lead to the same loop

#72

This may be hyper naive but is this the consequence of beginning most articles representing the current topic as a more specific form of another topic? For example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Algebra "Algebra ... is a branch of mathematics." (mathematics being a link) So if you continue to generalize you'll end up at the most general subject which appears to be philosophy. [update] added an example

ah so thats why the degree is called Doctor of Philosophy?! Thanks for the enlightenment! I've wondered quite a lot of times why I'm a Doctor of Philosophy in Computer Science, and not Doctor of Computer Science.

Re: Show HN: Most Wikipedia articles lead to the same loop

#73

It's funny, but it's true that everything in life ultimately leads back to philosophy. As noted by XKCD, everything is based on something else: http://xkcd.com/435/ And I think after Maths on that should come Philosophy.

"Nematode" and "Flow (psychology)" stop at "psychology" which I think is just another example of that discipline putting on airs.

Re: Show HN: Most Wikipedia articles lead to the same loop

#74

I quite like the loop between Doubt and Belief http://wikiloopr.com/Doubt

The loop found for "Psychology" is pretty neat: http://wikiloopr.com/Psychology

Edit: Looks like somebody is editing certain articles that don't have philosophy as the first link to have it. Psychology used to loop with itself through like 5 intermediates.

Re: Show HN: Most Wikipedia articles lead to the same loop

#76

After having twenty tries that got me into the philosophy loop, I started to think what are the most basic concepts that philosophy is "made of". Maybe I could escape the loop that way? And lo and behold, I tried word "word" and it loops between "emotion" and "psychology". http://wikiloopr.com/word

I fixed that.

Re: Show HN: Most Wikipedia articles lead to the same loop

#78
post #73

It's funny, but it's true that everything in life ultimately leads back to philosophy. As noted by XKCD, everything is based on something else: http://xkcd.com/435/ And I think after Maths on that should come Philosophy.

"Nematode" and "Flow (psychology)" stop at "psychology" which I think is just another example of that discipline putting on airs.

That's changed now, thanks to me.

Re: Show HN: Most Wikipedia articles lead to the same loop

#79
post #39

From a mathematical perspective, this is actually not that surprising. Think of the act of clicking the first link in the Wikipedia article as a function that takes in the page you're on and outputs another page. If you call this function on itself over and over again (ie use the output of one step as in the input of the next step), you will eventually enter a loop. The proof of this is simple: there are only a finit…

Agreed. I'd love to know how many different cycles the wikipedia article graph contains. If most articles lead to 1 out of 20 possible cycles, it's much less interesting than if it's 1 out of 5,000,000.
Post reply on HN