Live data from Hacker News

Bypassing Google's big anti-adblock update

0x44.xyz

571–580 of 962 posts

Re: Bypassing Google's big anti-adblock update

#571

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, this is a mature way of looking at things.

[flagged]

Google can see extension code, there's no way you could have used this to make an adblocker without them patching it.

You're inventing a moral dilemma here that simply doesn't exist

Re: Bypassing Google's big anti-adblock update

#572

Even if bigs exists to work around what Google is doing, that isn’t the right way forward. If people don’t agree with Google move, the only correct course of action is to ditch Chrome (and all Chromium browsers). Hit them where it hurts and take away their monopoly over the future direction of the web.

We need webmasters to nudge people away from Chrome. E.g. show an annoying popup on opening the page or add a small delay.

Re: Bypassing Google's big anti-adblock update

#573

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Devs, particularly those with pressure to ship or who don't know better, unfortunately see 'it works in Chrome' as 'it works', even if it is a quirk of Chrome that causes it to work, or if they use Chrome related hacks that break compatibility with other browsers to get it to work in Chrome. - Sometimes the standards don't define some exact behavior and it is left for the browser implementer to come up with. Chrome i…

Before shipping any web site/app, make sure it works in Apple Safari Mobile is usually the one that is dragging it is foot in Web Standards.

Even in portugal/spain se have to worry about this. Safari mobile users are a minority here but they usually spend or have more money to spend

Re: Bypassing Google's big anti-adblock update

#574
post #438

So theoretically Chrome is open source. Open source is supposed to prevent issues like this, as it is possible to fork Chrome pre-MV3 and preserve this functionality. However, this appears to have not happened. Perhaps we need a better definition of “open source”, or well-funded organizations that are adversarial in nature to the maintainers of open source commercial software. Lots of f/oss has malware and misfeature…

Chrome is open source just like Russia and Iran are democratic dictatorships. Just in the naming.

Re: Bypassing Google's big anti-adblock update

#575
post #303

No judgement but I would love to hear from Google employees who worked on this. Do they believe they are improving the internet in any way?

There is also an argument to be made that adblocking is immoral. I think the idea is pervasive enough to fill a team of willing people, especially if you pay them 100k/year to at least go along with it for the time being I haven't made up my own mind about it yet, just that this might be a factor in why one would move the facilitating technology backwards in this way (and forwards in other ways, apparently: some peop…

Lol. Treating cancer is immoral. Miss me with this shit!

Re: Bypassing Google's big anti-adblock update

#576
post #9

I'd gladly pay for YouTube without ads if I trusted that it would remain ad free, but the track record from various companies on this is not good.

Paying to avoid ads just makes your attention even more valuable to them. Always block them unconditionally and without any payment. Ads are a violation of the sanctity of our minds. They are not entitled to our attention. It's not currency to pay for services with.

Ads are social cancer that's spreading without any attention nor control from the authorities. Just like cigarettes 30 years ago.

Re: Bypassing Google's big anti-adblock update

#577
post #520

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> use Linux except that for a majority of users, windows is where their applications are at - such as gaming, word processing, or some other thing. Sure there are replacements (somewhat) for each of those categories, but they are not direct replacements, and require a cost of some kind (retraining, or a substitute quality). This is esp. true for gaming, and it's only recent that gaming has made some inroads via the s…

> except that for a majority of users, windows is where their applications are at - such as gaming, word processing, or some other thing. Until you switch to linux you won't understand how inferior your windows setup always was. It's hard for us to tell you what you are missing out on, you simply need to experience it. I mostly game in a Windows 10 VM running on my Linux desktop computer. Single keypress to switch to…

> I mostly game in a Windows 10 VM running on my Linux desktop computer. Single keypress to switch to Linux workspace.

Apologies for hopping on this thread with off topic question, but would you mind describing your setup?

I haven’t tried this in years, but last time I did I had trouble getting pass-through to some of my hardware, in particular my nvidia card.

Agree with your approach 100%!

Re: Bypassing Google's big anti-adblock update

#578
post #520

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> use Linux except that for a majority of users, windows is where their applications are at - such as gaming, word processing, or some other thing. Sure there are replacements (somewhat) for each of those categories, but they are not direct replacements, and require a cost of some kind (retraining, or a substitute quality). This is esp. true for gaming, and it's only recent that gaming has made some inroads via the s…

> except that for a majority of users, windows is where their applications are at - such as gaming, word processing, or some other thing. Until you switch to linux you won't understand how inferior your windows setup always was. It's hard for us to tell you what you are missing out on, you simply need to experience it. I mostly game in a Windows 10 VM running on my Linux desktop computer. Single keypress to switch to…

Can you comment more on your VM setup? Can it utilize the GPU properly? Any performance or compatibility issues with running windows in a VM? Etc.

Re: Bypassing Google's big anti-adblock update

#580

Would it be possible to create a web browser where different tabs are running other browsers? Like I could have chrome in one tab and Firefox in another? Almost like a VM?

You used to have an activeX plugin for internet explorer that would selectively render certain sites using google chrome
Post reply on HN