Live data from Hacker News

Hugging Face just launched a $299 robot that could disrupt the robotics industry

venturebeat.com

71–80 of 116 posts

Re: Hugging Face just launched a $299 robot that could disrupt the robotics industry

#71
post #6

Reachy Mini Lite specs say: "Compatible with Mac and Linux (Windows soon)" Ahahahahaha! Ahem. How the mighty have fallen.

are you suggesting that Windows doesn't have the majority of the install base?

The daily word games I run are obviously dominated by phones, but then I have 10% macOS and 6% Windows, which surprised me when I checked in on it recently.

Re: Hugging Face just launched a $299 robot that could disrupt the robotics industry

#73
post #33

Nothing in the article, the video, or the manufacturer's own blog post explains what this thing actually does . Seriously. This is an ephemeral marketing puff piece. As far as I can infer, the thing's basically a smart speaker which rotates.

The blog explains it: It can move its head, antennas, and rotate. It’s a little humanoid desk toy to stand in for computer interaction. It has nothing to do with the disrupting the “robot industry” like the Venture Beat headline says. It’s a little animated thing to house the AV equipment.

So a modern version of keepon? Will it dance to spoon?

Re: Hugging Face just launched a $299 robot that could disrupt the robotics industry

#74
post #23

The robot mostly looks like a very basic alternative to the Lego robotics offerings (mindstorms/technic/spike). And, they are in more or less the same price range as well Not sure what huggingface is going for here. Seems like a big distraction for the company

Hardly. This seems like the opposite alternative, something that has minimal or no mechanical hardware provisions, and few ways to interface with external motors and sensors.

Re: Hugging Face just launched a $299 robot that could disrupt the robotics industry

#75
post #25

"Reachy" is a weird name for a toy that has no arm or hand capable of interacting with its environment.

It's an easy bet that people will outfit the thing with arms, legs, wheels, tentacles - you name it. Assuming it can be modded, it will be modded.

Re: Hugging Face just launched a $299 robot that could disrupt the robotics industry

#76

For some reason it reminds me of the Nabaztag rabbit shaped, Internet connected device of a dozen years ago.

I was thinking the exact thing. I used to like my Nabaztags although (from the wikipedia page https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nabaztag ) it seems it was not a commercial success.

Re: Hugging Face just launched a $299 robot that could disrupt the robotics industry

#77
> One of the challenges with robotics is that you know you can’t just build on your laptop. You need to have some sort of robotics partner to help in your building, and most people won’t be able to buy $70,000 robots

Sure, but presumably those $70,000 robots aren't just a cute case for a Raspberry Pi + camera module.

Re: Hugging Face just launched a $299 robot that could disrupt the robotics industry

#78

There is a Black Mirror episode about a robot doll!

And I suppose it wasn't even user-programmable.

I bet in a few years we'll be walking between cute looking potential killer machines and everybody will think it is normal.

Re: Hugging Face just launched a $299 robot that could disrupt the robotics industry

#80
post #23

The robot mostly looks like a very basic alternative to the Lego robotics offerings (mindstorms/technic/spike). And, they are in more or less the same price range as well Not sure what huggingface is going for here. Seems like a big distraction for the company

I love huggingface and they've done a lot for the industry

...But...

I'm so confused by the economics, and not in a general way.

I'm a mobile developer by trade, and AFAICT from dipping my toe in the water of servers, file downloads are on the order of $0.01/GB, and cheapest you'll get publicly is maybe $0.04/GB. But they never ever charge and regularly have people downloading tens of gigabytes.

That's the cost side as far as I understand it.

On the revenue side...afaict all they have is inference? And they don't seem to be popular for an inference solution? I don't hear much about it and they don't seem to care too much.

How do their economics even begin to pencil out? It bothers me, I've lived through enough companies to know this doesn't matter in the short term. But this is novel, to me, in that there's no plan, no market being addressed. With other money losers, you knew what they were trying to do and they were doing it.

Post reply on HN