Live data from Hacker News

Are Logo Design Contests Even Legal?

thelogofactory.com

21–24 of 24 posts

Re: Are Logo Design Contests Even Legal?

#21
post #6

There is a comment from a lawyer at the end that just laughs at the whole post. There are design competitions all over the place, just not on the web. My GF regularly enters painting competitions. All the laws were set up to protect consumers from unscrupulous marketers, "Buy my cereal and maybe you will win something."

I think the key is how geographically widespread the entrants of online design contests are. Sure anyone can enter the painting competition at their local community college, but I doubt you'll have somebody across federal and state boundaries entering the same contest. This is just a really good example of the legal oversight startups often have.

Re: Are Logo Design Contests Even Legal?

#23
post #4

a logo design studio speaking out against design contests that drive down the price? I'm shocked. SHOCKED!

Yea I agree. Technically he could be correct, but he's fighting a losing fight. These things are clearly not against the law in every country and so to try to ban them on the internet will just move it out of America to countries that do allow it. That's how things work on the internet, just ask the online gambling operators.

This guy doesn't care about the law. This is just one of his many rants against logo design contests. E.g.

http://www.thelogofactory.com/library/articles/design-logo-c... http://www.thelogofactory.com/logo_blog/index.php/contest-de...

Whether design contests are good or not, this argument is a sham. The real conflict is that design contests give non-designers a really cheap way to get design done. In particular they make it easy and low-risk to hire people from low-wage countries. And a lot of people claim the resulting design is just as good. So if you are a high-paid freelance designer, design contests are a threat to your business model.

Re: Are Logo Design Contests Even Legal?

#24
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The only "contest" that is regulated by law is legally called a "Sweepstake". A sweepstake is quite clearly defined as "free entries into drawings of chance". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweepstakes Comparing a design contest to a sweepstake is incorrect. They are not the same thing. And links to sites with a clear, stated, and extreme bias doesn't help you convince me "design contests are bad". It only drives home…

>The only "contest" that is regulated by law is legally called a "Sweepstake". What about, for example, poker tournaments?

Poker was deemed a game of chance by the US Government. That's why US Banks can't work directly with poker sites anymore.
Post reply on HN