Live data from Hacker News

New IQ research shows why smarter people make better decisions

phys.org

11–20 of 68 posts

Re: New IQ research shows why smarter people make better decisions

#11
post #2

I think IQ is an incredibly bad measure of anything. So many IQ smart people I know make bad decisions and it's always because they don't judge other people well.

IQ is a rough measure of how big the engine is, like horsepower in a car. It says nothing about the quality of the driver or anything else about the car. A car with a huge engine in the hands of a bad driver can ram itself into a tree with great force.

In my experience I've met a ton of extremely high IQ people who believe insane things: the Moon landings didn't happen, bizarro political theories that fall apart if you look at them funny, occult mumbo jumbo, Scientology, vaccines cause autism and similar (RFJ Jr. probably has a high IQ), etc.

I wonder if having a high IQ means you can delude yourself better. Whether God can build a mountain he can't climb over may be a paradox, but humans with high IQ can absolutely create traps for their own mind they can't think their way out of.

I've also found that high IQ correlates -- at least in my sample -- with authoritarian political beliefs, with a roughly equal split between authoritarian leftism (Communism / tankie Marxism, technocratic socialism) and authoritarian rightism (race nationalism, fascism, neoreaction, authoritarian traditionalism / theocracy). I think this stems from an intuition on the part of the person that because they seem smarter than average and have trouble running their own life, there's no way an average person can be part of self-governing. I think they're both underestimating other people and overestimating the inherent efficacy of "smart" people.

Re: New IQ research shows why smarter people make better decisions

#14
post #11
post #2

I think IQ is an incredibly bad measure of anything. So many IQ smart people I know make bad decisions and it's always because they don't judge other people well.

IQ is a rough measure of how big the engine is, like horsepower in a car. It says nothing about the quality of the driver or anything else about the car. A car with a huge engine in the hands of a bad driver can ram itself into a tree with great force. In my experience I've met a ton of extremely high IQ people who believe insane things: the Moon landings didn't happen, bizarro political theories that fall apart if y…

"vaccines cause autism and similar"

RFK Jr. did win a lawsuit over injuries caused by a vaccine, although it wasn't autism.

Re: New IQ research shows why smarter people make better decisions

#15
post #13

If this is true, then I suppose that smarter people are also richer.

Happiness > Wealth Accumulation.

Depends on what you're optimising your life for. Money is very easy to measure, work/life balance, family and other factors are all incredibly difficult to measure and are arguably more important. Plenty of relatively poor people have extremely happy lives.

Re: New IQ research shows why smarter people make better decisions

#18
post #15
post #13

If this is true, then I suppose that smarter people are also richer.

Happiness > Wealth Accumulation. Depends on what you're optimising your life for. Money is very easy to measure, work/life balance, family and other factors are all incredibly difficult to measure and are arguably more important. Plenty of relatively poor people have extremely happy lives.

That's interesting. So I'd imagine that sharper folks might maximize quality of life, work/life balance, and friendships rather than a simple number.

Re: New IQ research shows why smarter people make better decisions

#19
post #11
post #2

I think IQ is an incredibly bad measure of anything. So many IQ smart people I know make bad decisions and it's always because they don't judge other people well.

IQ is a rough measure of how big the engine is, like horsepower in a car. It says nothing about the quality of the driver or anything else about the car. A car with a huge engine in the hands of a bad driver can ram itself into a tree with great force. In my experience I've met a ton of extremely high IQ people who believe insane things: the Moon landings didn't happen, bizarro political theories that fall apart if y…

> I've also found that high IQ correlates -- at least in my sample -- with authoritarian political beliefs

I think that’s just a side effect of being told “you’re very smart” a lot as a kid. You think that you can understand facts about the universe that others cannot, which steers you away from (boring, unthinking) normie positions.

Re: New IQ research shows why smarter people make better decisions

#20
It's interesting how people always try to find some kind of number to race against.

Here's a simple theoretical situation. A brilliant mathematician with very high IQ crashes in the jungle, but is unhurt.

Not far from the crash site, there's a tribesman who lived in the jungle all his life. He doesn't know how to read or write.

The jungle is filled with predators, spiders and snakes. The sun is setting, the night starts soon.

Who has bigger chances of surviving ? I guess most people would bet on the tribesman. Why does nature select the person who would most likely score lower on the IQ score ?

The point is - intelligence is contextual and circumstantial. It's not one number, like width or length. Not sure why people still try to squeeze some sort of conclusion from it..

Post reply on HN