Live data from Hacker News

David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story ends'

thetimes.com

21–30 of 187 posts

Re: David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story ends'

#21

I watched David Attenborough's recent film 'Ocean' on a big screen. The footage of bottom trawling was really shocking. I don't understand how that has been allowed to continue in UK coastal waters, let alone to be subsidised in marine protected areas. Madness. It's like napalming a forest to get a few deer. Thankfully things may be changing: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/government-proposes-to-ex... Don't know…

The relevant excerpt. [0]

[0] https://youtu.be/IzG9AwlypaY?feature=shared

Re: David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story ends'

#22

I think that not seeing how the story ends will be a blessing in disguise. (I do not share his optimism that we fix this, the forces of Line Must Go Up are going to win... at least until we all rapidly lose)

My theory: The forces of Line Must Go Up are going to keep winning. Mitigating the impact of climate change will be part of Line Goes Up. Whether it will be cheaper or more expensive than avoiding it in the first place will remain to be seen (but won't really matter in the end), but we will be facing whatever impacts we will be facing, and we will face them, and we will deal with them. If you have any doubt, look at…

- “Yes, the patient might die, but we’re confident that given enough resources, we’ll bring him back to life.”

Well, to be fair, it’s basically what’s happening with LLMs atm. So, maybe feathering up Mammon and aiming for the sun will be the tech industry’s most lasting legacy.

Re: David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story ends'

#23

I watched David Attenborough's recent film 'Ocean' on a big screen. The footage of bottom trawling was really shocking. I don't understand how that has been allowed to continue in UK coastal waters, let alone to be subsidised in marine protected areas. Madness. It's like napalming a forest to get a few deer. Thankfully things may be changing: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/government-proposes-to-ex... Don't know…

The relevant excerpt. [0] [0] https://youtu.be/IzG9AwlypaY?feature=shared

Watch it in a cinema, to get the full effect.

There are some before and after scenes of the sea bed, which are pretty shocking as well.

I'm not sure how that got that footage. Surely fisherman would not want that to be seen?

Re: David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story ends'

#26
post #17

I’m confused. We are beyond the point of no return when it comes to global warming. Hasnt he already seen how the story ends?

There is no single "point of no return". We have obviously passed the point where bad consequences can be avoided, but every extra ton of CO2 and methane makes things a bit worse.

I worry that the sentiment of "we have passed the point of no return" induces an impotent apathy in people, when the truth is that every step in the right direction makes our future a little bit less dire.

Re: David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story ends'

#27

I think that not seeing how the story ends will be a blessing in disguise. (I do not share his optimism that we fix this, the forces of Line Must Go Up are going to win... at least until we all rapidly lose)

If we keep at it like we have been maybe there's light at the end of the tunnel for Earth, ecologically. In say 100k or 1M years, after we're long gone and things have started to repair themselves.

Re: David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story ends'

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The relevant excerpt. [0] [0] https://youtu.be/IzG9AwlypaY?feature=shared

Watch it in a cinema, to get the full effect. There are some before and after scenes of the sea bed, which are pretty shocking as well. I'm not sure how that got that footage. Surely fisherman would not want that to be seen?

Found this:

"Technically, probably the hardest thing was trying to film bottom trawling because it's never been filmed before and we didn't know if it was possible. You have to film the wonder but you also have to film the destruction. Capturing that was absolutely essential and it took a lot of research to find some scientists planning bottom trawling experiments who decided that adding cameras would help their research and also help to share it with the world."

At:

https://www.arksen.com/blogs/news/ocean-with-david-attenboro...

Re: David Attenborough at 99: 'I will not see how the story ends'

#29

I watched David Attenborough's recent film 'Ocean' on a big screen. The footage of bottom trawling was really shocking. I don't understand how that has been allowed to continue in UK coastal waters, let alone to be subsidised in marine protected areas. Madness. It's like napalming a forest to get a few deer. Thankfully things may be changing: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/government-proposes-to-ex... Don't know…

> subsidised in marine protected areas

What do you mean?

Post reply on HN