Live data from Hacker News

Autonomous drone defeats human champions in racing first

tudelft.nl

341–342 of 342 posts

Re: Autonomous drone defeats human champions in racing first

#341

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This doesn’t address “Quickly overwhelmed”. Yes, a wall of $150,000 bushmasters with some servos can take hurl enough lead in the air to protect a city from a single gulf-war era $100,000 lawnmower engine on two meter wings bumbling in a straight line at jogging pace. We’re currently in the “a shipping container on a semi can could launch dozens of $2000 racing quads with molotov cocktails zip-tied to the bottom with…

>with enough agility to thread a needle faster than a turret can swing its own mass If it has a range of 1.5km, then the drone needs to be moving really fast in order to move a couple of degrees per second. If it's going like 80mph, then that's 36m/s, which comes out to <1.4 degrees/s at 1500m away. For 1000m, you get ~2 degrees/s. Not to mention that this velocity is at a right angle to the turret, and you have to c…

The point is that you can send lots of tiny drones to converge on the turret. They have to cover 1.5km (though that's only the distance if there's no cover, i.e. the gun is on a perfectly flat plain with no trees, buildings, etc). If the drones are travelling at 36m/s then that's about 50 seconds to cover 1.5km. If you drop 2000 drones, you'd need to kill 4 each second. That seems like a lot.

Re: Autonomous drone defeats human champions in racing first

#342

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>with enough agility to thread a needle faster than a turret can swing its own mass If it has a range of 1.5km, then the drone needs to be moving really fast in order to move a couple of degrees per second. If it's going like 80mph, then that's 36m/s, which comes out to <1.4 degrees/s at 1500m away. For 1000m, you get ~2 degrees/s. Not to mention that this velocity is at a right angle to the turret, and you have to c…

The point is that you can send lots of tiny drones to converge on the turret. They have to cover 1.5km (though that's only the distance if there's no cover, i.e. the gun is on a perfectly flat plain with no trees, buildings, etc). If the drones are travelling at 36m/s then that's about 50 seconds to cover 1.5km. If you drop 2000 drones, you'd need to kill 4 each second. That seems like a lot.

I got my maths wrong - you'd need to kill 40 drones a second.
Post reply on HN