Live data from Hacker News

Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc

apple.com

61–70 of 514 posts

Re: Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc

#61
post #54

Apple's integration of AI into its MacOS is the one reason why I am considering a switch back to Linux after my current laptop dies.

If that’s the one reason, have you considered just… not using the AI features?

Sure you can for now. But what when it's forced upon you to use them?

Re: Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc

#62
post #54

Apple's integration of AI into its MacOS is the one reason why I am considering a switch back to Linux after my current laptop dies.

If that’s the one reason, have you considered just… not using the AI features?

I find it offensive to have any generative AI code on my computer.

Re: Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc

#63

Some 15 years ago, A friend of mine said to me "mark my words, Apple will eventually merge OSX with iOS on the iPad". And with every passing keynote since then, it seemed Apple's been inching towards that prophecy, and today, the iPad has become practically a MacBook Air with a touch screen. Unless you were a video editor, programmer who needs resources to compile or a 3D artist, I don't see how you'd need anything o…

Does an iPad allow for multiple users?

Re: Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc

#64
I like that there's support for locally-run models on Xcode.

I wish I thought that the Game Porting Toolkit 3 would make a difference, but I think Apple's going to have to incentivize game studios to use it. And they should; the Apple Silicon is good enough to run a lot of games.

... when are they going to have the courage to release MacOS Bakersfield? C'mon. Do it. You're gonna tell me California's all zingers? Nah. We know better.

Re: Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc

#65

> New Design with Liquid Glass Looks like software UI design – just like fashion, film, architecture and many other fields I'm sure – has now officially entered the "nothing new under the sun" / "let's recycle ideas from xx years ago" stage. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aqua_%28user_interface%29 To be clear, this is just an observation, not a judgment of that change or the quality of the design by itself. I was gett…

I kind of hate it. Every use of it in the videos shown so far has moments where it's so transparent as to have borderline unreadable contrast.

Re: Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc

#66
post #37
post #4

> This year, App Intents gains support for visual intelligence. This enables apps to provide visual search results within the visual intelligence experience, allowing users to go directly into the app from those results. How about starting with reliably, deterministically, and instantly (say installed apps when searching by a prefix of their name ? As a second criterion, I would like to find files by substrings of th…

“How about starting with reliably, deterministically, and instantly (say searching by a prefix of their name? As a second criterion, I would like to find files by substrings of their name” Even I can, and have, build search functionality like this. Deterministically. No LLMs or “AI” needed. In fact for satisfying the above criteria this kind of implementation is still far more reliable.

I've also written search code like this. It's trivial, at least at the scale of installed apps and such on a single computer.

AI makes it strictly worse. I do not want intelligence. I want to type, for example, "saf" and have Safari appear immediately, in the same place, every time, without popping into a different place as I'm trying to click it because a slower search process decided to displace the result. No "temperature", no randomness, no fancy crap.

Re: Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc

#67
post #63

Some 15 years ago, A friend of mine said to me "mark my words, Apple will eventually merge OSX with iOS on the iPad". And with every passing keynote since then, it seemed Apple's been inching towards that prophecy, and today, the iPad has become practically a MacBook Air with a touch screen. Unless you were a video editor, programmer who needs resources to compile or a 3D artist, I don't see how you'd need anything o…

Does an iPad allow for multiple users?

Yes, but only if it's enrolled in MDM, bizarrely enough.

Re: Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc

#68
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ipad hardware is a full blown M chip. There's no real hardware limitation that stops the iPad from running macOS, but merging it cannibalizes each product line's sales

The new windowing feature basically cannibalizes MacBook Air.

A Macbook Air is cheaper than an iPad Pro with a keyboard though. Not to mention you still can't run apps from outside the app store, and most of these new features we're hoping work as well as they do on MacOS, but given that background tasks had to be an API, I doubt they will.

Re: Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc

#69

Some 15 years ago, A friend of mine said to me "mark my words, Apple will eventually merge OSX with iOS on the iPad". And with every passing keynote since then, it seemed Apple's been inching towards that prophecy, and today, the iPad has become practically a MacBook Air with a touch screen. Unless you were a video editor, programmer who needs resources to compile or a 3D artist, I don't see how you'd need anything o…

The fact that they haven't done it in 15 years should be an indication that they don't intend to do it at all. Remember that in the same time period Apple rebuilt every Macbook from scratch from the chipset up. Neither the hardware nor software is a barrier to them merging the two platforms. It's that the ecosystems are fundamentally incompatible. A true "professional" device needs to offer the user full control, and Apple isn't giving up this control on an i-Device. The 30% cut is simply too lucrative.

Re: Apple announces Foundation Models and Containerization frameworks, etc

#70
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ipad hardware is a full blown M chip. There's no real hardware limitation that stops the iPad from running macOS, but merging it cannibalizes each product line's sales

The new windowing feature basically cannibalizes MacBook Air.

There's still software I can't run on an iPad which is basically the only reason I have a MacBook Air. Maybe for some a windowing system may be the push to switch but that seems doubtful to me.
Post reply on HN