Live data from Hacker News

Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube

jeffgeerling.com

11–20 of 803 posts

Re: Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube

#11
post #6
post #3

Yeah, harmful to their revenue. Fuck YouTube

This is a good chance to suggest viable alternatives? TIA.

Vimeo and self-hosting are two alternatives. Are they realistic alternatives? That's another question.

Re: Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube

#12
post #6
post #3

Yeah, harmful to their revenue. Fuck YouTube

This is a good chance to suggest viable alternatives? TIA.

Don't watch youtube?

Want educational content? Read a book or a technical blog post or documentation.

Want entertainment? Read a book or watch a movie or TV show.

I've never found anything that great about YouTube.

Re: Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube

#13
I like the way Jeff signed off the article, pointing out that whilst the video has been pulled for (allegedly) promoting copyright infringement, Youtube, via Gemini, is (allegedly) slurping the content of Jeff's videos for the purposes of training their AI models.

Seems ironic that their AI models are getting their detection of "Dangerous or Harmful Content" wrong. Maybe they just need to infringe more copyright in order to better detect copyright infringement?

Re: Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube

#14
> In that case, I was happy to see my appeal granted within an hour of the strike being placed on the channel. (Nevermind the fact the video had been live for over two years at that point, with nary a problem!)

Looks like some L-(5|6|whateverthefuck) just got the task to go through YT's backlog and cut down on the mention/promotion of alternative video platforms/self-hosted video serving software.

Quick appeal grant of course, because it was more about sending a message and making people who want to talk about that kind of software think twice before the next video.

> But until that time, YouTube's AdSense revenue and vast reach is a kind of 'golden handcuff.' > > The handcuff has been a bit tarnished of late, however, with Google recently adding AI summaries to videos—which seems to indicate maybe Gemini is slurping up my content and using it in their AI models?

Balanced take towards the end (after the above quote), but yep, the writing is on the wall.

I really wonder where the internet goes in this age. The contract between third party content hosters and creators is getting squeezed, and the whole "you're the product" thing is being laid bare more and more.

Is it a given that at some point creators will stop posting their contents to platforms like YouTube? Is it even possible at this point given that YouTube garners so many eyeballs and is just so easy? Does a challenger somehow unseat YouTube because programming and underlying libraries (ffmpeg et al) becomes so easy to use that spinning up a YouTube competitor goes down to basically zero?

Seems like there needs to be a new paradigm for anyone to have a choice other than youtube. Maybe AI will enable this -- maybe "does jeff have any new videos" -> a video gets played on a screen in your house and it's NOT hosted on YouTube, but no one knows and no one cares?

Re: Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube

#17
post #12
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a good chance to suggest viable alternatives? TIA.

Don't watch youtube? Want educational content? Read a book or a technical blog post or documentation. Want entertainment? Read a book or watch a movie or TV show. I've never found anything that great about YouTube.

Those are alternatives for youtube _consumers_ but none of those are replacements for _producers_ on youtube.

Re: Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube

#18

> In that case, I was happy to see my appeal granted within an hour of the strike being placed on the channel. (Nevermind the fact the video had been live for over two years at that point, with nary a problem!) Looks like some L-(5|6|whateverthefuck) just got the task to go through YT's backlog and cut down on the mention/promotion of alternative video platforms/self-hosted video serving software. Quick appeal grant…

Isn't the competitor TikTok?

Re: Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube

#19
post #12
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a good chance to suggest viable alternatives? TIA.

Don't watch youtube? Want educational content? Read a book or a technical blog post or documentation. Want entertainment? Read a book or watch a movie or TV show. I've never found anything that great about YouTube.

30 years of playing the piano and listening to all kinds of music and harmony never really clicked with me even after studying music theory. But watching YouTube videos made an instant impact.

YouTube is a distracting mess full of doom scroll bait but if you have never found anything useful on YouTube, you haven't been looking very hard.

Post reply on HN