Live data from Hacker News

Consider Knitting

journal.stuffwithstuff.com

31–40 of 147 posts

Re: Consider Knitting

#31
post #3

Related: Why is everybody knitting chickens? 172 points, 122 comments (5 days ago) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44108139

My mother, a knitter for many decades, says to me about this -

>They are comfort chickens, good for cuddles for those going thru breast cancer treatment. A nice shape to hold, I understand. You might have to learn to knit..

Re: Consider Knitting

#32
post #24
post #2

I like crotcheting (tried it again for the first time since childhood during Covid). My main problem is that, unless you have already mastered it and can do it in your sleep, I have to fully concentrate on it to not fuck things up, which means I can't do something else at the same time, e.g. listen to an audiobook. And because I'm so slow it takes too much time for me to not think that it's a waste of time because I…

Could you try crocheting something for a purpose? Say, make small stuffed toys to donate to a local charity? That way, the task becomes "meaningful" and thus worthy of the additional time and focus that it demands, without becoming a pressing obligation on you to cause additional stress...

I did have a purpose and it didn't help much in this regard, it only helped with keeping up the friendly pressure to actually finish them. But generally, your advice is good nonetheless.

Re: Consider Knitting

#33
post #2

I like crotcheting (tried it again for the first time since childhood during Covid). My main problem is that, unless you have already mastered it and can do it in your sleep, I have to fully concentrate on it to not fuck things up, which means I can't do something else at the same time, e.g. listen to an audiobook. And because I'm so slow it takes too much time for me to not think that it's a waste of time because I…

Done something meaningful instead? Why don't you just do it for fun or while relaxing? I don't quite understand why it wouldn't be meaningful.

I absolutely did it for fun and to learn something new, it just didn't feel like as much fun as I had anticipated to me personally. I want it to be fun and relaxing, there is some fun in it but it's not relaxing.

Re: Consider Knitting

#35
post #16
post #2

I like crotcheting (tried it again for the first time since childhood during Covid). My main problem is that, unless you have already mastered it and can do it in your sleep, I have to fully concentrate on it to not fuck things up, which means I can't do something else at the same time, e.g. listen to an audiobook. And because I'm so slow it takes too much time for me to not think that it's a waste of time because I…

The early stages of any craft can feel more like mental gymnastics than relaxation

Absolutely! The difference is that with other things the learning curve can be part of the fun while you are in the process of figuring things out. With crotcheting, it only really takes a couple of minutes to get going, but doing it fast and consistently takes time, but you aren't really learning anything new other than becoming faster, so the emotional return isn't as big compared to, let's say, learning a new language or playing an instrument. It's just very mechanical by nature; which is a good thing, but for me personally, it takes away a bit of the joy.

Re: Consider Knitting

#36
post #2

I like crotcheting (tried it again for the first time since childhood during Covid). My main problem is that, unless you have already mastered it and can do it in your sleep, I have to fully concentrate on it to not fuck things up, which means I can't do something else at the same time, e.g. listen to an audiobook. And because I'm so slow it takes too much time for me to not think that it's a waste of time because I…

This was probably my issue as well. I grew up seeing my grandma crochet. She’d do it while watching TV (though I’m not sure if she was actually watching or just in proximity to others watching), and she was quick. I have a couple afghans she made. She probably made a couple dozen. The learning curve was higher than I expected, especially without someone to be there showing me stuff. I just tried watching some YouTube…

My mom also knits while watching TV, and she is super fast. I think one secret ingredient is that she doesn't care about making mistakes. Tinier mistakes she just ignores (even if they are visible in the end [I don't like that, so that's something I try to avoid, which adds pressure and slows me down]) and she doesn't mind backtracking and re-doing several rows if she really fucks up.

Re: Consider Knitting

#37

The thing knitting taught me is that you can have something beautiful and useful even tho literally every part of the piece is a single point of failure. No redundancy, no backstop. If any of the stitches gets cut, the entire piece can unravel completely. We're so used to redundancy, but sometimes you just need to get things done, and it's ok if it's all a deck of cards.

It depends on your medium. A good wool has little hooks along the shaft of its staple so once knit the yarn will cling. Cutting a single stitch will not cause a loss of coherency. In fact, a classic knitting technique for crafting something like a cardigan made with wool involves knitting in the round (making a spiral tube, essentially) and then slicing it open for the button band and sleeves. It's called "steeking".

Re: Consider Knitting

#38

The idea of sitting and quietly knitting is appealing but whenever I look at knitted goods I think there's no way I would spend hours making some rubbish tea towel/sweater etc

Scarves and hats are useful, though. Knit sweaters can be very comfortable and look good, if done well.

Granted, I say that as a person who lives in a cold-half-the-year climate, but my point is that, just like coders, there's plenty of shitty knitters out there.

The key with any skill is to approach it as a student, ready to improve. If this is something you wanted to try, get ready to make a few rubbish tea towels before you refine your understanding.

Re: Consider Knitting

#39

The idea of sitting and quietly knitting is appealing but whenever I look at knitted goods I think there's no way I would spend hours making some rubbish tea towel/sweater etc

Yeah. It's similar with origami, very fun to make, but the end result looks unescapably like "something someone made", not a fully cooked "thing". Some musical styles also feel that way, jazz most notably. Wonder if there are any books or articles analyzing this fully cooked / not fully cooked feeling.

Re: Consider Knitting

#40
I find woodworking fun for basically all the same reasons. Plus there's still the math of adding up things to predict cut layouts, and you end up with a new shelf or box or table. I'm not sure I would use anything I knitted.
Post reply on HN