Live data from Hacker News

NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions

science.org

41–50 of 877 posts

Re: NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions

#41
post #37
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Not OP, but OP did not imply any of the things you mentioned at all.

Correct that OP did not imply those things, but a lot of people will read it that way. There are implications behind the implications, and I think that DiffEq is referencing the latter. I'm not taking a side in this fight.

Re: NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions

#42
This isn't about science, issues, or voting. The message is: "We don't like you and it would be better if you weren't around".

Also, why is NSF fielding 40,000 proposals per year? That is 110 proposals per day. Is there really that much science to perform and not enough universities to host it? Not at all. It exists because every state and local government and educational institution is incentivized to solicit federal aid. Even if a school is located in Beverly Hills, federal aid will be solicited at all levels in K-12 and higher education. Republicans are saying they don't want anything to do with that level of centralized government.

Re: NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions

#45
post #25
post #11

The NSF funded my graduate research. It feels like someone is going through my past and burning all of the ladders that helped me grow and succeed.

[flagged]

What about the current administration gives you the impression that science is a goal?

Is it cancelling current and withholding future grants from Harvard and any university that doesn't allow a government takeover?

Or is it the dismantling science-related government agencies like NOAA and NIH?

Just curious.

Re: NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions

#47
post #31
post #11

The NSF funded my graduate research. It feels like someone is going through my past and burning all of the ladders that helped me grow and succeed.

[flagged]

Yes, the government funding basic research is a good thing.

Re: NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions

#48

The NSF budget is ~$10billion. That's about half of NASA's, 1.2% of the DoD's, 0.5% of the discretionary budget ($1.7 trillion). Why is this the focus of the admin? Science is one of the few things the US is doing well.

The focus is robbing the treasury to give tax breaks to the rich.

Re: NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions

#49
post #31
post #11

The NSF funded my graduate research. It feels like someone is going through my past and burning all of the ladders that helped me grow and succeed.

[flagged]

Is it your position, then, that the government should not fund research? What entity is prepared to take its place? Can you name a country with a successful research community that does not rely in part on government funding?

Re: NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions

#50

[flagged]

No. We did not elect the party majority in Congress or the Supreme Court. If anything, the weakness of our constitution has spoken. Take this as a lesson, and defend your democracy while you still can.

Maybe somewhat indirectly, but the US population did elect those people in the usual sense of the word.
Post reply on HN