Live data from Hacker News

Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

waymo.com

241–250 of 397 posts

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#241
post #184
post #176

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, that’s called marketing. Believe it when they do what Mercedes does and accept liability rather than trying to shirk it.

If marketing is a 20 min video demonstrating both progress and regressions for each minor rev, then I’ll take more of that.

I'll believe it when they accept liability for the actions of their autonomous vehicles. Videos mean nothing.

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#242
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The funny thing is that I've owned Gen 3 FSD for five years now and only in the last few months has it gotten noticeably better. It's actually respectable at driving around my city now, can handle roundabouts, make turns, etc.

The funny thing is that a nearly perfect template of your comment appears on nearly every post which includes a criticism of FSD. It's always magically "just recently got better!" As well as "being able to do some selected basic driving despite being called FULL self drive."

Look, everyone on the planet agrees that calling it FSD was over-promising. You are not adding anything to the conversation by pointing that out, or by confusing technology with "magic". The fact remains that software developed by a competent team can actually improve over time, despite the insanity of corporate leadership, and that's what is happening here.

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#243

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually, we should also realize that they've been super wildly successful at getting people to move towards clean energy vehicles. Prius is the world's highest selling Hybrid car, and it's been that for more than a decade now. This means Toyota has helped cut down emissions from consumer automobiles by a significant degree. It's not the 1000 EVs out of the 100k vehicles that matter, but rather the 10k hybrid vehicle…

Up until recently (~2022/23) Toyota had cumulatively sold more hybrids than all EVs sold by all manufacturers combined, globally. They arguably have the best hybrid drivetrain on the market, and it's gotten to the point where even the Camry (2025 onwards) are exclusively offered as hybrids now.

>> Camry (2025 onwards) are exclusively offered as hybrids now.

This is a very dope move. Glad to hear that

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#244

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What you're buying is not driving, by itself, fully.

Mine drove me from my house to the airport without my ever touching the steering wheel so what exactly do you mean?

Adaptive cruise control could do that too.

How impressive it is depends on where you live.

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#245

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What you're buying is not driving, by itself, fully.

Mine drove me from my house to the airport without my ever touching the steering wheel so what exactly do you mean?

It sounds like you're recklessly interpreting the parameters by which your "self driving" car was made available to you

Did it also drive itself back to your home empty?

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#246
been watching this space forever, always cracks me up how we go from overhyped PR to endless hedging - nothing feels real till someone puts their name on the liability. anyone else think real change happens only when they truly risk something?

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#247
post #104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the US a plug-in hybrid seems like the best of both worlds. Once the charging infrastructure gets fully flushed out pure EVs will look a lot better.

PHEVs (hybrids with large battery packs) are the worst of both worlds -- weight penalty of a big EV pack, but the complexity/maintenance of an ICE engine. Additionally, rarely used gas can go bad sitting in the tank. Just get a regular hybrid if you're concerned about EV range or don't like the current limited offerings.

It's not as easy as more components = more expensive.

The battery pack is much smaller. A Prius PHEV is almost 500 lbs lighter than a Model 3 and only 100 lbs heavier than a normal hybrid Prius, which also has a battery pack. The MSRP is lower by almost $10k, which can cover a lot of maintenance before you resell it with less depreciation.

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#248
post #213
post #174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except there’s FSD videos everywhere on X with every minor release, demonstrating the progress.

Progress would be get certified for self driving. For comparison, Mercedes, BMW, Honda etc have L3 cars on the market. Mercedes just got approved full highway speeds in EU and working on L4 certification.

I just checked out Mercedes, and it appears to be geofenced with a lot of restrictions[1]:

> DRIVE PILOT can be activated in heavy traffic jams at a speed of 40 MPH or less on a pre-defined freeway network approved by Mercedes-Benz. DRIVE PILOT operates in daytime lighting conditions when inclement weather is not present and in areas where there is not a construction zone. Please refer to the Operator’s Manual for a full list of conditions required for DRIVE PILOT.

Only on select freeways and only under 40 mph (and only during daytime with good weather conditions) sounds like it wouldn't be particularly useful.

Still, the tech is cool, and moving in the right direction. It's just always hard to really tell the state of things without doing some digging, because there's a ton of misinformation that gets thrown about whenever this topic comes up.

[1] https://www.mbusa.com/en/owners/manuals/drive-pilot#2

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#249

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The funny thing is that a nearly perfect template of your comment appears on nearly every post which includes a criticism of FSD. It's always magically "just recently got better!" As well as "being able to do some selected basic driving despite being called FULL self drive."

Look, everyone on the planet agrees that calling it FSD was over-promising. You are not adding anything to the conversation by pointing that out, or by confusing technology with "magic". The fact remains that software developed by a competent team can actually improve over time, despite the insanity of corporate leadership, and that's what is happening here.

The fact also remains that fraud (even if it's not prosecuted) is fraud. You promise X and deliver... not X, for years? You're a fraud. Even if you are getting better at delivering Y, for some value of Y which is Far, Far less than X.

Re: Waymo and Toyota outline partnership to advance autonomous driving deployment

#250
post #204

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Toyota does not want to sell a lot of EVs, because that could mean investing heavily to scale up the manufacturing of a dead-end technology that ends up losing out. Meanwhile they've been iterating on their hybrid tech and are selling 50 MPG vehicles by the millions. When the dust settles, a lot of EV companies will be out of business and their products will be e-waste with 0 spares anywhere. Toyota on the other hand…

Toyota has invested very heavily in hydrogen cars, which is an actual "dead-end technology that ends up losing out". Sure, numerous EV startups will bite the dust, but the actual tech of putting a battery on wheels and spinning the wheels with motors isn't going anywhere.

Toyota invested heavily into the R&D which is distinct from tooling up to produce 70kwh battery packs by the millions. They've sold maybe 20k hydrogen cars, globally over the course of a decade as a pilot. They also sold 4k RAV4 EVs, are working on EVs with BYD and CATL, which means that they're keeping their finger on the pulse of the industry while also staying out of the lithium/neodymium pissing contest which they simply cannot win. The reason Chinese EVs are such a good deal is because all of the hard-to-source stuff is under the same roof because China doesn't really have a fossil fuel story. Their hope with EVs is that the current approach to making them is simply not sustainable on a global scale and that the emergence of less resource-intensive technologies will saddle all earlier entrants (that aren't subsidized by nations) with debt.
Post reply on HN