Live data from Hacker News

The money part of App.net is a red herring

alexhillman.com

21–30 of 108 posts

Re: The money part of App.net is a red herring

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's going to be a self-fulfilling conspiracy. All this talk about how it's gonna succeed, and how noone understands it.. sooner or later, some misled company like FB or Google will just acqui-hire App.net for millions of dollars because everyone is talking about it.

Just like with Zynga and OMGPOP/Draw Something, and look how that ended up. :P

Good for OMGPOP...

Re: The money part of App.net is a red herring

#22

My current suspicion is that Dalton has no idea how to build what he wants, in fact he doesn't even know what the thing he wants is . So he's fanning the flames on this discussion to let everyone else come up with something for him.

"Dalton has no idea how to build what he wants"

How do you correlate that with the mostly-functional alpha which already has 90% of what I use twitter for?

I wasn't expecting anything functional for 5-6 months, and, as it exists, it's already mostly there.

Re: The money part of App.net is a red herring

#23
I think it is probably going to be pretty low volume. Just for fun I would like to see an IRC style realtime interface. Treat hashtags (assuming they have hashtags, I haven't looked past the join page) as channels, read and write as if it were a realtime chat.

Re: The money part of App.net is a red herring

#25

My current suspicion is that Dalton has no idea how to build what he wants, in fact he doesn't even know what the thing he wants is . So he's fanning the flames on this discussion to let everyone else come up with something for him.

"Dalton has no idea how to build what he wants" How do you correlate that with the mostly-functional alpha which already has 90% of what I use twitter for? I wasn't expecting anything functional for 5-6 months, and, as it exists, it's already mostly there.

>How do you correlate that with the mostly-functional alpha which already has 90% of what I use twitter for?

I don't mean technically. I'm sure Dalton is quite qualified to build anything he commits to. I mean he doesn't know how to build it because he doesn't know what he's building. (Yet.)

Re: The money part of App.net is a red herring

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Dalton has no idea how to build what he wants" How do you correlate that with the mostly-functional alpha which already has 90% of what I use twitter for? I wasn't expecting anything functional for 5-6 months, and, as it exists, it's already mostly there.

>How do you correlate that with the mostly-functional alpha which already has 90% of what I use twitter for? I don't mean technically. I'm sure Dalton is quite qualified to build anything he commits to. I mean he doesn't know how to build it because he doesn't know what he's building. (Yet.)

I think part of the disappointment people have in twitter stems from the days when TWITTER didn't know what twitter was going to become. It didn't become what they (and Dalton) hoped, so this is an attempt to reboot.

Except the rules didn't really change.

Re: The money part of App.net is a red herring

#27
post #20
post #4

So the author of this post can't see the reason why anyone would want to pay for this, and yet backed the project himself anyway? It reminds me of the people you see who write forums posts like 'I just got my first Mac, now what?' when the answer is always 'do whatever you wanted it for in the first place'

"yet backed the project himself anyway?" Per the OP: "By the way, I put my $50 in out of pure morbid curiosity of what’s under the hood." I think you can both think something probably isn't going to work or have issues with it and support it as a hedge or out of, as he said, "morbid curiosity". People do this with politics quite frequently.

> People do this with politics quite frequently.

Really? Do you have an example?

"I didn't really think the war in Iraq would go very well, and I don't really support it; I just wanted to see what would happen."

Re: The money part of App.net is a red herring

#29

My current suspicion is that Dalton has no idea how to build what he wants, in fact he doesn't even know what the thing he wants is . So he's fanning the flames on this discussion to let everyone else come up with something for him.

I was once tasked with building a web app for a real estate company. The ultimate stake holder (can't remember his title) told me as we were wrapping up a requirements gathering meeting:

    I don't know what I want, but I'll know it when I see it.
I was still too green to know that I should have run for my life after that statement.
Post reply on HN