Live data from Hacker News

Reproducing Hacker News writing style fingerprinting

antirez.com

121–130 of 168 posts

Re: Reproducing Hacker News writing style fingerprinting

#122
This is great example of what's possible and how true anonymity, even online, is only "technological threshold" anonymity. People obsessed with biometrics might not consider this is another biometric.

Instead of just HN, now do it with the whole internet, imagine what you'd find. Then imagine that it's not being done already.

Re: Reproducing Hacker News writing style fingerprinting

#123

This is a bit tangential but I've noticed lots of comments aping the style of Matt Walsh. Not just on HN either, but probably more here than other places I visit. Anyway, I guess this would be useful cluster the "Matt Walsh"-y commenters together.

Matt Walsh? I mean, sure, maybe he’s your guy. Or maybe he’s… not. Matt Levine, though, that’s the style to ape.

Re: Reproducing Hacker News writing style fingerprinting

#125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think “should” and “ought to” end up being equivalent. I prefer to avoid such absolutes and portray causality instead. For example, in place of “you should not do drugs at work” I prefer “if you take drugs at work you’ll get in trouble”.

Nothing wrong with implying that people ought to behave according to mainstream social norms.

Isn’t that the same as saying that counterculture, fringe culture, and subcultures ought not exist?

Re: Reproducing Hacker News writing style fingerprinting

#126
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you all from the same town? Another user reported this finding.

We had all met in the same city but weren't originally from there or live there any longer. Maybe some "like attracts like" phenomena

Very interesting phenomenon. I feel like the term 'phenomenon' is too unsubstantial for something like this.

Re: Reproducing Hacker News writing style fingerprinting

#127
post #20

The "analyze" feature works pretty well. My comments underindex on "this" - because I have drilled into my communication style never to use pronouns without clear one-word antecedents, meaning I use "this" less frequently that I would otherwise. They also underindex on "should" - a word I have drilled OUT of my communication style, since it is judgy and triggers a defensive reaction in others when used. (If required,…

I would prefer the "analyze" feature focus on content rather than structure words. I forget the specific linguistic terms but to a first approximation, nouns and verbs would be of interest, prepositions and articles not. Let's call the former "syntactic" and the latter "semantic." I suppose it's possible the "analyze"-reported proportions are a lot more precise and reliably diagnostic than I imagine. I haven't yet lo…

Of course, immediately after the edit window closes, I revisit this comment and discover that in the first paragraph I swapped my terms and made a hash of the rest of the thing. Please cut out and paste into your printouts the following corrected version. Thank you!

> I would prefer the "analyze" feature focus on content rather than structure words. I forget the specific linguistic terms but to a first approximation, nouns and verbs would be of interest, prepositions and articles not. Let's call the former "semantic" and the latter "syntactic."

Re: Reproducing Hacker News writing style fingerprinting

#129

The original version nailed all of my accounts with terrifying accuracy. Since then I make a new account every few days or weeks. Against the rules I know. And I’ve learned a lot about HN IP tracking and funny shadowbanning-like tricks they play but dont cop to. Like I get different error messages based on the different banned ips I use. And j see different behavior and inconsistency with flagged messages (like one t…

Care to write it all up somewhere? Sounds interesting

Re: Reproducing Hacker News writing style fingerprinting

#130
I don't mind revealing my alts since none of them seem to link back to my main. But the top 4 results were all correct for me:

https://antirez.com/hnstyle?username=gfd&threshold=20&action...

zawerf (Similarity: 0.7379)

ghj (Similarity: 0.7207)

fyp (Similarity: 0.7197)

uyt (Similarity: 0.7052)

I typically abandon an account once I reach 500 karma since it unlocks the ability to downvote. I'm now very self conscious about the words I overuse...

Post reply on HN