Live data from Hacker News

Open source and self hostable/private file converter

vert.sh

31–40 of 120 posts

Re: Open source and self hostable/private file converter

#31

It's ffmpeg all the way down. I can't imagine what the internet would be if there weren't such a marvelous piece of software.

It is one of the wonders of the world. Such a gift that we get to use it for free, from end users like us to large corporations like Netflix.

Re: Open source and self hostable/private file converter

#32
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As far as I can tell, what you're missing is the massive ease-of-use and approachability, especially for non-technical users, of a web-based graphical "convert X to Y" interface vs. facing command line ffmpeg, which they probably haven't heard of.

There are already GUIs for ffmeg and most image editing applications can save in multiple formats so its still not clear to me what this adds

I feel this is easier than those solutions in a lot of cases - mainly because you don't need to install anything. Just open website, drag and drop a file, pick target format, done.

Re: Open source and self hostable/private file converter

#33

How is this different from image/graphics magick, ffmpeg, oiiotool etc? Or: what am I missing here, why is this on the front page?

For some reason even technical and linux-savvy people, (I’ve seen this on zoom calls) will google up an image or video converter. I don’t get it either, but if this provides an alternative to those awful ad-infested sites I guess it is an improvement.

Re: Open source and self hostable/private file converter

#34

It's ffmpeg all the way down. I can't imagine what the internet would be if there weren't such a marvelous piece of software.

It is one of the wonders of the world. Such a gift that we get to use it for free, from end users like us to large corporations like Netflix.

Actually, ffmpeg exists thanks to the legendary Fabrice Bellard. He's the rarest kind of programmer, stunningly capable and on a totally different wavelength of existence in terms of breadth of achievements. He made ffmpeg, incepted QEMU, and is a mobile / cellular communications guru.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fabrice_Bellard

Re: Open source and self hostable/private file converter

#36
post #5

Why do such things need to be hosted at all? I've got a few file converter apps on my laptop. They're faster and better and you don't need to stream the data off somewhere just to process and stream back, which is silly.

The conversion for this one happens all client-side - no streaming data to a server required.

If you're happy using your existing apps, you probably wouldn't see much use in this. But I can definitely see how the UI/UX would appeal to a lot of people.

Re: Open source and self hostable/private file converter

#37

It's a great UI to ffmpeg - I wish they gave it some credit on their landing page.

I wish it were more common for open source licenses to have an attribution clause, like Apache does with its (optional) NOTICE files. When you put years of effort into a work, you deserve credit for it.

Edit: Actually, using a library via a package manager would likely be considered "linking" and not a Derivative Work, so I don't think even Apache's clause would apply in many cases.

Re: Open source and self hostable/private file converter

#38

It's ffmpeg all the way down. I can't imagine what the internet would be if there weren't such a marvelous piece of software.

I get to be one of the lucky few to learn today that ffmpeg was ported (well, transpiled) to WASM. This is more specifically built on that port: https://github.com/ffmpegwasm/ffmpeg.wasm

That project has an interactive playground that essentially describes and demonstrates how it works: https://ffmpegwasm.netlify.app/playground

This also means that despite being a locally hosted ffmpeg frontend, it's still slower than native ffmpeg and bound to WASM limits like file size (still a generous 2GB for images and audio, but not as viable for big video conversions).

Still weird that this project doesn't seem to acknowledge that anywhere.

Re: Open source and self hostable/private file converter

#40

How is this different from image/graphics magick, ffmpeg, oiiotool etc? Or: what am I missing here, why is this on the front page?

yeah you can already build such a system yourself quite trivially by getting an FTP account, mounting it locally with curlftpfs, and then using SVN or CVS on the mounted filesystem. From Windows or Mac, this FTP account could be accessed through built-in software.
Post reply on HN