Live data from Hacker News

Yesterday, I Went to the American Idol for Startups. It Made Me Want to Die.

slog.thestranger.com

51–60 of 93 posts

Re: Yesterday, I Went to the American Idol for Startups. It Made Me Want to Die.

#51
"Hell, as I check my e-mail, I notice with a resigned shame that my coworkers—smart people I consider to be excellent writers—are unironically using the word “spearhead” as a verb in an e-mail thread."

Aaaaand this is where I dismiss the author as simply looking for things to complain about.

Complaining about names (as if that even matters). Complaining about the way they dress. Complaining about the way they talk.

Might as well end it with "get off my lawn!"

Re: Yesterday, I Went to the American Idol for Startups. It Made Me Want to Die.

#52

Really enjoying the author's prose. This had me rolling: >> It’s like watching some sadist work over a baby lamb with a rusty crowbar and a broken gin bottle. The names of these startups sound like the products of an aggressive brain tumor on the frontal lobe. Crowdegy, Placeling, Kouply, QuoteRobot, Appthwack, Makegood, Onthego, Nickler, Kahal, Tanzio, Taskk. They’re all whimsical and unique in exactly the same way.

Actually, I quite like the name Appthwack.

Thanks!

We've gone back and forth a ton of times, especially because of the obvious "Aflac" thing. We get a lot of comments that are positive, and of course some that are negative, but nobody seems to have a problem remembering it.

I'm way more concerned with providing a good product with a name that's "good enough." Also, it describes in slightly playful terms exactly what we do. We test apps.

Re: Yesterday, I Went to the American Idol for Startups. It Made Me Want to Die.

#53
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually, I quite like the name Appthwack.

I don't mind it, but it sounds like someone with a lisp is trying to say Aflac.

The first time we publicly demoed AppThwack it was pointed out. On the other hand, people seem to remember it and generally react positively. Who knows if it will stick, but we agree on it enough for now that it's better to focus on the product and getting customers.

Re: Yesterday, I Went to the American Idol for Startups. It Made Me Want to Die.

#54

"Hell, as I check my e-mail, I notice with a resigned shame that my coworkers—smart people I consider to be excellent writers—are unironically using the word “spearhead” as a verb in an e-mail thread." Aaaaand this is where I dismiss the author as simply looking for things to complain about. Complaining about names (as if that even matters). Complaining about the way they dress. Complaining about the way they talk. M…

The naming part was a bit annoying. There's a very specific and calculated reason why startups go with uniformly butchered names like those: 1) domain names and branding you don't have to fight over (you have no money to do that as a scrappy startup) 2) you also don't bucket yourself into one specific function "UsefulSpreadsheets.com" can never become a food catering company, whereas "Xorgzyx.com" (or Google/Yelp/Amazon/Zynga and so on) can be whatever they want to be without having to rename themselves.

Re: Yesterday, I Went to the American Idol for Startups. It Made Me Want to Die.

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually, I quite like the name Appthwack.

How do you spell it? (no really, say it to someone on the road and see if they can tell how to spell it)

The first time I say it out loud to someone there's often a request to hear it again. If they're a native speaker it generally clicks with an emphasis on "Thwack." If they're not, spelling it clears it up rather quickly. Usually it's because they've never heard the word before.

Once people get it they repeat it, likely because it's an entertaining and weird thing to say.

I agree with the advice that names should be easy to spell, but I also think it depends on context. Nearly all of our customer acquisition starts visually, either through the site, banners, or press, so it hasn't really been a problem.

Who knows if we'll keep it forever, but it's working for now.

Re: Yesterday, I Went to the American Idol for Startups. It Made Me Want to Die.

#56

Really enjoying the author's prose. This had me rolling: >> It’s like watching some sadist work over a baby lamb with a rusty crowbar and a broken gin bottle. The names of these startups sound like the products of an aggressive brain tumor on the frontal lobe. Crowdegy, Placeling, Kouply, QuoteRobot, Appthwack, Makegood, Onthego, Nickler, Kahal, Tanzio, Taskk. They’re all whimsical and unique in exactly the same way.

Sounds like Sarah Palin's short list for baby names.

Re: Yesterday, I Went to the American Idol for Startups. It Made Me Want to Die.

#57

"Hell, as I check my e-mail, I notice with a resigned shame that my coworkers—smart people I consider to be excellent writers—are unironically using the word “spearhead” as a verb in an e-mail thread." Aaaaand this is where I dismiss the author as simply looking for things to complain about. Complaining about names (as if that even matters). Complaining about the way they dress. Complaining about the way they talk. M…

It's pretty naked snobbery. That's all.

Re: Yesterday, I Went to the American Idol for Startups. It Made Me Want to Die.

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually, I quite like the name Appthwack.

For those of you who are too young to have lived through the original dot-com boom, I can't recommend this 1999 article on company naming from Salon highly enough: http://www.salon.com/1999/11/30/naming/ Read the whole thing, it's hilarious. As soon as I saw the parade of names in the OP I was reminded of one of the names the naming consultants in the the Salon piece devised -- "Jamcracker": When Altman and Manning p…

Amusingly, there is a business called Jamcracker:

http://www.jamcracker.com/

and, what's more, the copyright at the bottom of their website says 1999-2012. I wonder if the naming firm still sold the name after this article!

Re: Yesterday, I Went to the American Idol for Startups. It Made Me Want to Die.

#59
>"You can do anything you want with an idea. It can be as big as you want. It doesn’t have to solve a minor problem that nobody ever really realized was a problem. It doesn’t have to fit into something the size of a button crammed into a “folder” the size of a button on a screen the size of a playing card. But everywhere I look, I see tiny little ideas,ideas that are almost petty in their inconsequentiality."

This. This sums up how I feel about the whole startup scene. The lack of real innovation is incredible.

Re: Yesterday, I Went to the American Idol for Startups. It Made Me Want to Die.

#60
"When the language you employ to communicate your ideas is small and boring, your ideas are going to be small and boring."

That's how I felt reading this blog post. A long, pedantic, raging post that does nothing but demonstrate that the author has an inflated sense of his writing prowess. His post is basically one type of Hipster raging against the Hipsterisms of a different type of Hipster.

Post reply on HN