Live data from Hacker News

France fines Apple €150M for “excessive” pop-ups that let users reject tracking

arstechnica.com

1–10 of 217 posts

Re: France fines Apple €150M for “excessive” pop-ups that let users reject tracking

#2
Actually Apple were fined because they don't apply the same standard to their own pop-ups that allow users to reject tracking. On Apple popups you seem to need one click, while on 3rd party popups you need to confirm twice.

So the fine seems to be for treating 3rd parties differently from their own stuff.

They could make their own popups require double confirmation instead...

Re: France fines Apple €150M for “excessive” pop-ups that let users reject tracking

#6
post #2

Actually Apple were fined because they don't apply the same standard to their own pop-ups that allow users to reject tracking. On Apple popups you seem to need one click, while on 3rd party popups you need to confirm twice. So the fine seems to be for treating 3rd parties differently from their own stuff. They could make their own popups require double confirmation instead...

>The agency said there is an "asymmetry" in which user consent for Apple's own data collection is obtained with a single pop-up, but other publishers are "required to obtain double consent from users for tracking on third-party sites and applications."

Re: France fines Apple €150M for “excessive” pop-ups that let users reject tracking

#8
Most of you won't read the past the headline but this isn't accurate

>The agency said there is an "asymmetry" in which user consent for Apple's own data collection is obtained with a single pop-up, but other publishers are "required to obtain double consent from users for tracking on third-party sites and applications." The press release notes that "while advertising tracking only needs to be refused once, the user must always confirm their consent a second time."

They take issue with Apple making it easier for their apps but applying a different standard for third parties. I think this fine is fair.

Re: France fines Apple €150M for “excessive” pop-ups that let users reject tracking

#9
post #7

"We will not tell you how to fix what we found to be 'wrong', reserve the right to find your fixes 'wrong' again, and will charge you more" At which point do we admit that this is simply extortion?

Reminds me of app store submissions.
Post reply on HN