Live data from Hacker News

Germany's laws on github, machine-readable and ready to be forked

github.com

11–20 of 78 posts

Re: Germany's laws on github, machine-readable and ready to be forked

#11

I find it fascinating that for a repository of German law, written in German, the README and commit history are all in English. I wonder if that will have the effect of scaring off any would-be contributors.

the readme has a german section right above the english one.

Re: Germany's laws on github, machine-readable and ready to be forked

#13
post #9

Awesome stuff. I couldn't find anywhere though: is this an 'official' project, or is it just someone who processed the XML forms into markdown? Also, this: "All German citizens can easily find an up-to-date version of their laws online." And it's only 130 megs of markdown when zipped (246 unzipped)! A mere 4,737,628 lines[1]! Surely you have time to read it, right? And therefore be a well-informed, law-abiding citize…

This is not an official project, "just" someone who registered the organization "Bundesregierung" ("Federal Government") at github and processed the official XMLs into markdown.

Re: Germany's laws on github, machine-readable and ready to be forked

#15

I find it fascinating that for a repository of German law, written in German, the README and commit history are all in English. I wonder if that will have the effect of scaring off any would-be contributors.

the readme has a german section right above the english one.

Ah, right you are! Didn't notice it thanks to the anchor link.

Doesn't change the commit history's melange of English and German.

Re: Germany's laws on github, machine-readable and ready to be forked

#16
post #13
post #9

Awesome stuff. I couldn't find anywhere though: is this an 'official' project, or is it just someone who processed the XML forms into markdown? Also, this: "All German citizens can easily find an up-to-date version of their laws online." And it's only 130 megs of markdown when zipped (246 unzipped)! A mere 4,737,628 lines[1]! Surely you have time to read it, right? And therefore be a well-informed, law-abiding citize…

This is not an official project, "just" someone who registered the organization "Bundesregierung" ("Federal Government") at github and processed the official XMLs into markdown.

Yeah, sorry - 'just' is a relative term :) Didn't mean to belittle the act, it's still a big and interesting project.

Re: Germany's laws on github, machine-readable and ready to be forked

#17
What sucks is this would never happen in the US. The reason being that most of the earmarks and so forth are added to bills after they're passed. And not only that, they're added as images in tiny fonts so that they can't even be scanned in.

God bless America.

Re: Germany's laws on github, machine-readable and ready to be forked

#18

There was a great discussion on HN previously about this topic which also explains why a straight git implementation isn't viable for US law; I'm not sure if doing the same with Germany's laws would be similarly difficult: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3968653

Isn't US law not public-domain anyway? Or at least on a state by state basis? I remember a copyright issue concerning someone reprinting some of Oregon's laws.

Re: Germany's laws on github, machine-readable and ready to be forked

#20

What sucks is this would never happen in the US. The reason being that most of the earmarks and so forth are added to bills after they're passed. And not only that, they're added as images in tiny fonts so that they can't even be scanned in. God bless America.

You mean except for this? https://github.com/divegeek/uscode

Honest question, did you even search for reasons that this would be feasible or did you just rush in to make an anti-US comment?

Post reply on HN