Live data from Hacker News

My TV started playing a video in full screen by itself. What happened?

support.vizio.com

251–260 of 268 posts

Re: My TV started playing a video in full screen by itself. What happened?

#251
post #238

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wouldn't the data be a lot less useful to them? Instead of 'customer watched X show for Y minutes' it'd be 'customer X watched Y minutes of unknown on HDMI1'.

As edge AI gets better they will be able to send smaller textual descriptions of the screen content.

Something like color histogram data is probably enough for fingerprinting known content.

Re: My TV started playing a video in full screen by itself. What happened?

#252
post #165
post #158

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The FAQ says you can't but apparently that's wrong (or intentionally deceptive?). Someone posted instructions below.

Just reading it wrong. You can't turn off ads in scenic mode, but you can turn off scenic mode. Vizio kind of has a lot of dark pattern messaging. As an example, they make it seem like you HAVE to enable the microphone on the remote or install an app to change the TV volume. They don't provide a diagram of the remote, so if you don't notice the volume rocker on the side, it seems like you only have two rather invasiv…

He's not reading it wrong, it's intentionally written to be read that way.

Re: My TV started playing a video in full screen by itself. What happened?

#253
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's crazy of you to sacrifice your sleep enough nights to notice a pattern. The extent of my patience would be 1st night - disable CEC on the TV 2nd night - to hell with you, into the garbage it goes

I think there should be "pull out the cord" step somewhere

And then what? Keep pulling the plug every evening? No thanks, might as well get a different non-defective setup.

Re: My TV started playing a video in full screen by itself. What happened?

#254
post #167

Very afraid we will get to the point where new TVs will refuse to boot and let you use external inputs unless they have network connection. I’ll live with watching Plex on my phone before I buy a TV like that.

You mean on Apple's/Goole's/Samsung's phone that you're renting, right?

Re: My TV started playing a video in full screen by itself. What happened?

#255

Am I the only one here that read the part where you can absolutely disable this? I don't understand the performative outrage. The TV has an ad-supported screen saver, which they claim is used to support free streaming content. You can disable the screen saver entirely. No, you cannot just disable the ads but keep the screen saver. What is the problem? Meanwhile half the posters here work for Google or other ad-survei…

Hey sorry I broke into your home and ate your food but hey it's ok if you ask me nicely I promise I won't do it again. Won't give up they key though. And might change my mind about that promise in the future. Wait what are you mad for?

Re: My TV started playing a video in full screen by itself. What happened?

#256

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unlikely. Every Smart TV I've used requires you to agree to a EULA before any "smart" features are available.

I’d be surprised if you could even use a smart TV at all without agreeing to an EULA.

The GDPR really got that part right - for consumer-business contracts there is no consent if it wasn't freely given.

Re: My TV started playing a video in full screen by itself. What happened?

#257
post #84

About 2 years ago we got a deal on a smallish Samsung for our nursery. The thing is haunted. On more than a couple occasions in the middle of the night I've heard people talking. On working up the courage and getting out of bed I've found the TV tuned in my daughter's room to one of those Samsung Internet TV channels. My wife and I never use those, so it's absolutely bizarre.

Possibly voice activation trying to interpret baby noises as commands? If so there should be a setting to disable it.

Re: My TV started playing a video in full screen by itself. What happened?

#258
post #117

The good news: large-panel TV sets are inexpensive for their performance. The bad news: like many modern products, and as freely confessed in the linked article, you don't own the TV, it owns you . The remedy: Connect the TV to your computer as a dumb monitor -- make it show only content you directly control. And disable the TV's network connection -- without that connection, it can't show ads. My large-panel TV serv…

> This means no "Scenic Mode" ads and no YouTube corporate ads, only ads embedded by video content creators, which I skip over with a pointing device because the video is being controlled by a browser, not a TV.

You skip over the ones that are obvious, but not the ones that are more stealthily integrated into the content. IMO if a video creator sells out and adds sponsored content of any kind they are no longer to be trusted to not be manipulative in other ways.

Re: My TV started playing a video in full screen by itself. What happened?

#259

OK, related, so I have to share, because it's driving some valley residents crazy. It is currently the portable air conditioner season in Arizona. Home Depots now have them stocked in the front of the store. All Wi-Fi enabled Toshiba models (which are white-label rebranded Midea units,) their overwhelming predominate stock, are susceptible to a bug where your unit can be remotely turned on or off randomly, without yo…

Huh, surprising that portable air conditioners are popular in Arizona - I'd have expected them to be used mainly in climates that don't call for buildings to be equipped with air conditioning already.

Re: My TV started playing a video in full screen by itself. What happened?

#260
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be honest, this is part of why TVs can be offered for so cheap these days. Same reason really cheap phones are stuffed with bloatware. Luckily with TVs you can freeload: just never connect it to the internet and only apply updates via USB. Stick an Apple TV / Chromecast / console into it for playback. This might even become standard operating procedure considering Samsung is getting into the ad game, and LG and So…

I think it’s only a matter of time until TVs refusing to work without internet or randomly interrupting your watching experience to ask you to connect to the internet. Heck, they can even learn from Microsoft now and demand a Vizio account, iPhone apps, etc. Additionally they could start producing them without HDMI or other ports to prevent Apple TV or other similar devices from connecting. What I’m trying to say is…

I hate this as much as you, but don't agree regulation is the only solution. In part because it tends to get things wrong, skew markets, favour incumbents and ultimately retard innovation by startup efforts like mine.

When a company treats its customers like crap, that opens an opportunity for someone else to come along and do better.

Corporations are copying each other's bad habits right now, the kind of behavior you've described is a trend and the ones partaking in this race to the bottom will fail. I'm looking forward to a "revolution" when one rediscovers there's actually a market for quality consumer electronics that treat you decently and are a joy to use (think Apple's earlier iPhone models, auto manufacturers going back to knobs and buttons, etc) and might pursue this myself if nobody else does.

To be clear, I'm not opposed to legislation enforcing some basic, much-needed principles (like privacy preservation, requiring opt-in consent, attaching more liability to collected user data even to the point of establishing fiduciary-like duty on the sensitive stuff, stricter transparency and better user controls promoting consumer choice). I just think you need to be careful about getting too prescriptive on the "how".

Post reply on HN