Live data from Hacker News

ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

tos-dr.info

41–50 of 131 posts

Re: ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

#41
post #8

An API and chrome addon would be very nice. I wouldn't check the site, but I would like warnings when I accessed the registration page of a bad website.

tossos.com was built about 6 months ago. Trying to do similar things as this. It has a Chrome Plugin... check it out.

Yes. I have been in touch with the author and invited to cooperate. But... where is the code? how does it work exactly? How can it interoperate with other projects trying to back up archives of terms? etc. etc.

Re: ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

#42
post #33
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh, I just assumed "Read the Details" would send me to the ToS! Maybe that should be renamed too :)

I also think it's a poor choice. What do you suggest?

Make each of the line items clickable to reveal the detailed info. And perhaps move the current button to the top right of the block and rename it to something like "Expand All".

Re: ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

#46
post #44

I understand that the project welcomes contributions, but who has the final say on the rating of a website? Are there any gate-keepers, and who are they?

For the moment: Anyone who can push to the 5apps.com git master branch. That is people at http://unhosted.org

We would be happy to get th umbrella of a non profit org like Mozilla or the EFF.

Any way, if you don't like our decision: you can get involved. Or you can fork it.

Re: ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

#47
post #18

Great concept and smart execution. A suggestion - rather than rating "A" through "E" why not change to the more recognizable (for US audience at least) scale of "A through F" (A/B/C/D/F) which we're all mercilessly trained to recognize through years of school grades? "E" as your worst rating confused me at first glance - could be interpreted as "Excellent"

I vouch for a more international 5-star system.

Re: ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

#48
post #5

I attempted a similar feat in 2010 with the now defunct tosgrok.com. This is a very needed service! Edit: Take the domain and put it to good use, I no longer own it and it beats tos;dr!

To be fair, neither is exactly terminology familiar with the average user, who I think they're trying to reach out to here. Both are clever, but known mostly by avid Internet users or nerds.

I think ToS;DR is less nerdy. "Grok" makes me visualize gray-bearded Unix programmers, but young internet-savvy people of all stripes know what TL;DR means. Didn't 4chan popularize that abbreviation?

Re: ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

#49
For those who have decent experience in machine learning (and NLP) and its theoretical foundations...isn't there enough examples of TOS and conventions of the "art" that a classifier could be built to determine restrictiveness and such? Not completely accurate, but even something that's 60% right would be a huge help to services like the OP's

Re: ToS;DR — TL;DR for Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

#50
Suggestion: Include a "Under EU Data Protection law: all/some/none" category.

Companies in the EU, are required to do various things under EU data protection law. E.g. they are legally required to protect your personal data, they can only use the personal data for things you agreed to, they must tell you what data they keep on you if you ask, if they are wrong and you tell them, they are legally required to update the data, there is a national body that is legally empowered to tell a company to stop doing a thing/delete data if they are in breech of data protection law, if they suffer a data breech they are legally required to inform users, etc. All of these things are good for users.

Some companies (e.g. those entirely in the USA) are not bound by these. Some companies (e.g. those entirely in the EU) are bound by this. Some companies (e.g. Facebook) say "If you're in the US or Canada, you're under US law, if you're anyone else, you're under EU law".

Post reply on HN