Live data from Hacker News

Crew-9 Returns to Earth

spacex.com

231–240 of 712 posts

Re: Crew-9 Returns to Earth

#231
post #147

Hate all you want to Elon, you still need to credit to credit due.SpaceX did awesome Job.

I don't think Elon really had that much to do with this.

Not only did they deliver the commercial crew contract faster than Boeing, they did it for a much lower cost.

Re: Crew-9 Returns to Earth

#232
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Berger is an excellent journalist. He’s very knowledgeable about space topics, has good sources, and has been extremely fair to Musk in the past. When he says it’s a “throne of lies”, a line has been crossed.

>"We're going to stand by for splashdown located in the Gulf of America," she said. >Ah, yes. The Gulf of America. >This is why we can't have nice things. That doesn't sound like an "excellent journalist". It sounds like a Redditor.

I cringed reading that. It's like something an edgy West coast teenage Redditor would write.

Re: Crew-9 Returns to Earth

#233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I thought some of those were still free. Do you have information to the contrary? Edit: italicized

Per the Polish government, they’re paying $50M per year for Ukraines service. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy87vg38dnpo.amp

if $50m per year enough for the Starlink services needed in Ukraine?

Re: Crew-9 Returns to Earth

#234

The drone footage is absolutely amazing (as compared to any other camera angle from the recovery boat where you would expect to have better quality but was actually awful). I had trouble, for a moment, believing that it was not CGIed. Is there any information about what drone/camera equipment was used?

It won't play for me. Has it been uploaded anywhere else?

youtube, probably elsewhere as well

Re: Crew-9 Returns to Earth

#235
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Berger is an excellent journalist. He’s very knowledgeable about space topics, has good sources, and has been extremely fair to Musk in the past. When he says it’s a “throne of lies”, a line has been crossed.

I wasn't very convinced by his arguments - the main one being: Senior NASA officials earlier this month confirmed, publicly and on the record, that the decision was made by the space agency in the best interests of the International Space Station Program. Not for political reasons. To be a little snarky here - so Senior NASA officials: honest, Musk: liar? If, hypothetically, NASA was pressured for political reasons,…

Are you only reading every third sentence?

The return vessel was docked in September. The return was always planned to be around today, not in September.

Trump and Musk are lying about the astronauts being forgotten. They're lying when they claim Biden abandoned them.

As far as I can tell, NASA didn't delay for political reasons. Nor did they allow the return journey today for political reasons. This was the plan all along (well, once the initial plans had to be scrapped for technical reasons).

Re: Crew-9 Returns to Earth

#236

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We simply have different outlooks. I'm not going to argue it. I see exploitation (in a negative sense) where you're more optimistic. I truly hope you're right! Before we had machines to put in our factories, we had hordes of dead laborers. Regulations are written in blood. Then we had company towns and truly brutal police enforcement. Why will humans work there? Partly for the reason you gave: poverty. That makes the…

wdym exploitation, space company would not having a hard time to pay their employee the same reason oil company do also human is expensive, if fleet of human slave is cheap then we outsource all of our work to china and india. but that don't happen we build a trillion dollar industry (AI and robotic) to make all of that

When I look at the power dynamics between employee [on a spaceship] and an employer, pay isn't the utmost concern. Not even the trendy replacement, scrip. Nay, performance reviews and how it might relate to oxygen availability.

I don't see a collaborative trip through the cosmos, I see a very unhealthy relationship with danger to boot

This may be all the more reason for robots, but again: humans take no engineering. Just a few minutes and a lot of tries (heh, sex joke). They'll literally pay for themselves.

RE: outsourcing, I don't know what you mean/where you are. That's exactly what's been happening, here. Consistently. For decades. Many ventures can happen.

Re: Crew-9 Returns to Earth

#237

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They were scheduled to stay there for 8 days and had Boeing's vessel proven flight worthy, they would have returned after 8 days. The messaging beyond that was just political in nature. They could have been rescued, but were left on the station until after the election. The situation resulted in significant issues for the next crewing [1] leading to some interesting things like the first time a Russian cosmonaut was…

> They could have been rescued, but were left on the station until after the election This continues to be silly. There were changes to Crew 9, last summer , when it was decided that it would be logistically easier for two (instead of four) astronauts to go up and the two Boeing crew would come down with them on the Crew 9 craft in February/March 2025 (that would be now). This has always been the plan, the only polit…

It's bizarre that anyone thinks the emergency situation continued after the launch of Crew 9 with 2 empty seats for their return.

It's a simple, parsimonious explanation for everything that has happened since. Nonetheless, we apparently have to talk about it.

I wonder how many people expressing strong opinions don't even understand that there were intentionally empty seats.

Re: Crew-9 Returns to Earth

#238
post #135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nobody was stranded.

If my car breaks down and I have to wait a few hours for somebody to pick me up, I'm stranded.

If your car breaks down but you decide to wait for the tow truck even though you have a backup car ready to go in case things get bad are you still "stranded"?

Re: Crew-9 Returns to Earth

#239
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Here is the original song (for those who are ignorant like me): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfSLuEj99d0

Related (vaguely): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43407014

Wow, nice find and highly coincidental!

Re: Crew-9 Returns to Earth

#240
post #86

Eric Berger has a good summary on the narrative: https://arstechnica.com/space/2025/03/can-nasa-remain-nonpar...

Berger is an excellent journalist. He’s very knowledgeable about space topics, has good sources, and has been extremely fair to Musk in the past. When he says it’s a “throne of lies”, a line has been crossed.

Ars has been like this ever since Conde Nast bought them. It was a great publication a long time ago.
Post reply on HN